5.6 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Binding energy and mass defect

In a minute

A has less mass than the separate that make it. That missing mass, the , is the divided by c2c^{2}: the needed to pull the nucleus apart. tells you which nuclei are most tightly bound, and why both fission and fusion release energy.

You'll be able to

  • Explain what are, and count the protons and neutrons in each.
  • Describe the and explain why a nucleus needs it.
  • Use , E=mc2E = mc^{2}, to find the energy released by a mass change, with masses in kg, u or MeV c−2\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}.
  • Calculate the mass defect and binding energy of a nucleus.
  • Interpret the binding energy per nucleon curve, and use it to explain and calculate the energy released in fission and fusion.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
How many nucleons are in a nucleus of 1327Al^{27}_{13}\text{Al}?
Check yourself
Convert 2.0 MeV\pu{2.0 MeV} to joules. Use 1 eV=1.60⋅10−19 J\pu{1 eV} = \pu{1.60e-19 J}.
Check yourself
A system is isolated: no energy enters or leaves it. What happens to its total energy?

Revise first: 1.9 Work and energy transfer, 3.3 Travelling waves, 5.1 The nuclear atom and 6.1 Units, measurement and estimation

Isotopes

In 5.1 you described a nucleus by its ZZ and its AA. The proton number fixes the element. The number of neutrons, N=A−ZN = A - Z, can vary.

A nuclide is one particular kind of nucleus, set by its values of ZZ and NN. Nuclides of the same element with different numbers of neutrons are called .

Carbon-12, 612C^{12}_{6}\text{C}, and carbon-14, 614C^{14}_{6}\text{C}, are isotopes. Both have 6 protons. Carbon-12 has 6 neutrons; carbon-14 has 8.

Isotopes of an element have the same chemical properties, because their atoms have the same number of electrons. They differ in mass. They can also differ in stability: carbon-12 is stable, while carbon-14 is radioactive (5.7).

Worked exampleCopper has two stable isotopes, 2963Cu^{63}_{29}\text{Cu} and 2965Cu^{65}_{29}\text{Cu}. Find the number of neutrons NN in a nucleus of copper-65, and the number of protons ZZ.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The bottom number is the proton number, so Z=29Z = 29. Copper-63 has the same, as it is the same element.
Worked exampleNeon has the isotopes 1020Ne^{20}_{10}\text{Ne} and 1022Ne^{22}_{10}\text{Ne}. Outline what is meant by isotopes, and state one way in which these two nuclides differ.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Give both parts of the definition: what is the same and what is different.
Check yourself
Each option gives two nuclei as protons (p) and neutrons (n). Which pair are isotopes?
Check yourself
One isotope of lead has 82 protons and 126 neutrons. Another isotope of lead has nucleon number 204. How many neutrons does a nucleus of this second isotope have?

The strong nuclear force

A packs several protons into a space about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m} across. Every proton is positive, so each pair repels by Coulomb's law (4.4). At that tiny distance the repulsion is huge.

Gravity attracts the protons too, but it is far too weak to help. So something else must hold the nucleus together.

Inside a nucleus, nucleons are about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m} apart. At that separation the is stronger than the electric repulsion between protons, so the nucleus holds together.

Its short range matters. At separations much beyond a few times 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m} the strong force is negligible. (At very small separations, below about 0.5×10−15 m0.5 \times 10^{-15}\ \text{m}, it turns repulsive, which stops nucleons crowding closer. You don't need this detail.) So a nucleon only feels its nearest neighbours, while the electric repulsion reaches every proton in the nucleus.

Neutrons feel the strong force but no electric force. They add attraction without adding repulsion, which is why every nucleus except hydrogen-1 contains neutrons.

Worked exampleTwo protons in a nucleus are 2.2⋅10−15 m\pu{2.2e-15 m} apart. Calculate the electric force between them.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use Coulomb's law, F=kq1q2r2F = k\frac{q_1q_2}{r^{2}}, with k=8.99⋅109 N m2 C−2k = \pu{8.99e9 N m2 C-2} and q=e=1.60⋅10−19 Cq = e = \pu{1.60e-19 C}. These constants are from the data booklet.
Worked exampleA helium-4 nucleus contains two protons and two neutrons. Outline why the nucleus does not fly apart, even though the two protons repel each other.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Say what pushes the protons apart and why gravity can't balance it.
Check yourself
Which statement about the strong nuclear force is correct?
Check yourself
Calculate the ratio electric forcegravitational force\frac{\text{electric force}}{\text{gravitational force}} between two protons. Use mp=1.673⋅10−27 kgm_\text{p} = \pu{1.673e-27 kg}.

Mass-energy equivalence

Einstein showed that mass and are two forms of the same thing. Whenever a system gains or loses energy, its mass changes too. This is .

In the formula booklet
E=mc2E = mc^{2}

Here EE is the energy in J, mm the mass in kg, and cc the in a vacuum, 3.00⋅108 m s−1\pu{3.00e8 m s-1}. You don't need to memorise this formula; it is in the data booklet.

In a nuclear reaction, the energy released ΔE\Delta E comes from a loss of mass Δm\Delta m: the products have less mass than the particles you started with. So ΔE=Δm c2\Delta E = \Delta m\, c^{2}.

The released energy appears mostly as kinetic energy of the products, and sometimes as gamma photons.

Nuclear masses are tiny, so they are often given in the unified atomic mass unit, u. The data booklet gives 1 u=1.661⋅10−27 kg=931.5 MeV c−2\pu{1 u} = \pu{1.661e-27 kg} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2}.

The unit MeV c−2\text{MeV}\,c^{-2} is a unit of mass: an energy in MeV divided by c2c^{2}. It makes the conversion quick. A mass decrease of 1 u releases 931.5 MeV. One MeV is 10610^{6} , so 1 MeV=1.60⋅10−13 J\pu{1 MeV} = \pu{1.60e-13 J}.

Worked exampleWhen one uranium-235 nucleus undergoes fission, the total mass decreases by 3.10⋅10−28 kg\pu{3.10e-28 kg}. Calculate the energy released, in MeV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use ΔE=Δm c2\Delta E = \Delta m\, c^{2} with c=3.00⋅108 m s−1c = \pu{3.00e8 m s-1}.
Worked exampleIn 1932, Cockcroft and Walton fired protons at lithium-7 nuclei. Each reaction gave two helium-4 nuclei: 37Li+11p→2 24He^{7}_{3}\text{Li} + {}^{1}_{1}\text{p} \rightarrow 2\,{}^{4}_{2}\text{He}. The nuclear masses are lithium-7: 7.014357 u and helium-4: 4.001506 u. Calculate the energy released in one reaction.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take the proton mass from the data booklet: 1.007276 u\pu{1.007276 u}.
Check yourself
A nuclear reaction releases energy. How does the total mass of the products compare with the total mass of the particles before the reaction?
Check yourself
In a reaction, the total mass decreases by 0.0250 u. Calculate the energy released in MeV, to 3 significant figures.

Mass defect and binding energy

Weigh a nucleus, then weigh its protons and neutrons one by one. The separate always have more mass. The difference is the .

Learn this
Δm=(Zmp+(A−Z)mn)−Mnucleus\Delta m = \left(Zm_\text{p} + (A - Z)m_\text{n}\right) - M_\text{nucleus}

Here mpm_\text{p} and mnm_\text{n} are the proton and neutron masses, from the data booklet, and MnucleusM_\text{nucleus} is the mass of the nucleus.

Why is mass missing? To pull a nucleus apart, you must do work against the strong nuclear force. So the separate nucleons have more energy than the nucleus, and by mass-energy equivalence, more mass.

Learn this
EB=Δm c2E_\text{B} = \Delta m\, c^{2}
Mass diagram for a small nucleus of three protons and three neutrons. The upper level shows the six nucleons far apart, with total mass Z times the proton mass plus N times the neutron mass. The lower level shows the same six nucleons packed together as a nucleus, with the smaller mass M. An arrow pointing up on the left shows that the binding energy must be supplied to pull the nucleus apart. An arrow pointing down on the right shows that the same energy is released when the nucleus forms. A double-headed arrow on the far right marks the gap between the two levels as the mass defect, delta m. binding energy supplied to pull it apart same energy released when it forms separate nucleons mass Zmp + Nmn nucleus mass M mass defect Δm coloured circles: protons; grey circles: neutrons. Not to scale.
The nucleus sits lower in mass than its separate nucleons. The gap is the mass defect, and Δm c2\Delta m\, c^{2} is the .
Worked exampleThe mass of an oxygen-16 nucleus, 816O^{16}_{8}\text{O}, is 15.99052 u. Calculate its binding energy in MeV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Count: Z=8Z = 8 protons and N=16−8=8N = 16 - 8 = 8 neutrons. Masses from the data booklet: mp=1.007276 um_\text{p} = \pu{1.007276 u}, mn=1.008665 um_\text{n} = \pu{1.008665 u}.
Worked exampleThe mass of a nitrogen-14 nucleus is less than the total mass of 7 separate protons and 7 separate neutrons. Explain why, with reference to binding energy.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Start from what it takes to pull the nucleus apart.
Check yourself
Which statement describes the binding energy of a nucleus?
Check yourself
The binding energy of a carbon-12 nucleus is 92.2 MeV. Using mp=938 MeV c−2m_\text{p} = 938\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2} and mn=940 MeV c−2m_\text{n} = 940\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2}, calculate the mass of the nucleus in MeV c−2\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}. Give 3 significant figures.

Binding energy per nucleon

A big nucleus has more binding energy than a small one just because it has more nucleons. To compare nuclei fairly, divide by the number of nucleons.

The higher the , the more tightly bound, and so in general the more stable, the nucleus.

Graph of binding energy per nucleon in MeV against nucleon number A, from 0 to 250. The curve rises steeply from hydrogen-2 at about 1.1 MeV. Helium-4 sits well above the curve near it, at about 7.1 MeV, and oxygen-16 is marked at about 8.0 MeV. The curve reaches a broad maximum of about 8.8 MeV at iron-56, then falls slowly to about 7.6 MeV at uranium-238. To the left of the peak, an arrow pointing right shows that fusing light nuclei releases energy. To the right of the peak, an arrow pointing left shows that splitting heavy nuclei releases energy. 050100150200250 0246810 binding energy per nucleon / MeV nucleon number A helium-4 oxygen-16 iron-56, about 8.8 (peak) uranium-238 hydrogen-2 fusion releases energy fission releases energy
Binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number. Nuclei near the peak are the most tightly bound.

Reading the curve from left to right:

1. Light nuclei: it rises steeply. Each extra nucleon has more neighbours to attract it.

2. Helium-4 sits well above its neighbours, so it is unusually stable.

3. The peak, about 8.8 MeV, is near A=56A = 56 to 6262, at iron-56 and nickel-62. These are the most tightly bound nuclei.

4. Heavy nuclei: it falls slowly. The strong force only reaches nearby nucleons, but the electric repulsion acts between every pair of protons and keeps growing.

Any change that moves nuclei towards the peak makes them more tightly bound, so it releases energy. Joining light nuclei is (5.12). Splitting a heavy nucleus into two medium ones is (5.11).

To find the energy released, use total binding energy, EB=A×EBAE_\text{B} = A \times \frac{E_\text{B}}{A}, for each nucleus. Energy released == total binding energy after −- total binding energy before. A free neutron or proton has no binding energy.

Worked exampleA uranium-235 nucleus absorbs a neutron and splits into two medium-mass nuclei. Explain, with reference to binding energy per nucleon, why energy is released.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Locate uranium and the products on the curve.
Worked exampleOne fission of uranium-235 is 01n+92235U→56141Ba+3692Kr+3 01n^{1}_{0}\text{n} + {}^{235}_{92}\text{U} \rightarrow {}^{141}_{56}\text{Ba} + {}^{92}_{36}\text{Kr} + 3\,{}^{1}_{0}\text{n}. The binding energies per nucleon are uranium-235: 7.59 MeV, barium-141: 8.33 MeV, krypton-92: 8.51 MeV. Determine the energy released.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Total binding energy before: only the uranium nucleus is bound. 235×7.59=1783.65 MeV235 \times 7.59 = 1783.65\ \text{MeV}.
Check yourself
The binding energy per nucleon of molybdenum-98, 4298Mo^{98}_{42}\text{Mo}, is 8.64 MeV. Calculate its total binding energy in MeV, to 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
Which of these changes releases energy?

Common mistakes

  • Defining isotopes by the neutrons alone. Say both: the proton number is the same and the neutron number differs.
  • Calling binding energy the energy stored in a nucleus. It is the energy needed to separate the nucleus into its nucleons.
  • Rounding masses before subtracting. The mass defect is a small difference of large numbers, so keep every decimal place.
  • Multiplying a mass in u by c2c^{2}. Convert to kg first, or multiply by 931.5 to get MeV.
  • Judging stability by total binding energy instead of binding energy per nucleon.

Exam tips

  • "Outline" isotopes for two marks: say the proton number is the same and the neutron number is different. State both; an implied comparison doesn't score.
  • In a "show that" energy calculation, show the substituted mass difference, then give one more significant figure than the stated value.
  • "Explain" why fission or fusion releases energy: the products are nearer the peak, so they are more tightly bound.

Key takeaways

Learn thisIsotopes: the same proton number ZZ but a different neutron number NN. Same chemistry, different mass.
Learn thisStrong nuclear force: attractive between all nucleons, short range (about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}), stronger than the electric repulsion inside a nucleus.
In bookletE=mc2,1 u=931.5 MeV c−2E = mc^{2}, \qquad \pu{1 u} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2}
Learn thisΔm=Zmp+(A−Z)mn−Mnucleus,EB=Δm c2\Delta m = Zm_\text{p} + (A - Z)m_\text{n} - M_\text{nucleus}, \qquad E_\text{B} = \Delta m\, c^{2}
Learn thisBinding energy is the energy needed to separate a nucleus into its nucleons, not energy stored in it. Products of an energy-releasing reaction have less mass.
Learn thisBinding energy per nucleon peaks at about 8.8 MeV near iron-56. Fusion of light nuclei and fission of heavy nuclei both move towards the peak and release energy.

Practise this

117 past-paper questions on Radioactivity and nuclear reactions in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Radioactivity and nuclear reactions →