5.5 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Matter waves and Compton scattering

In a minute

Moving particles such as electrons behave like a , with a λ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p}, and electron proves it. Light works the other way: in an X-ray bounces off an electron like a particle and comes away with a longer . Together these show that light and matter both have a wave side and a particle side.

You'll be able to

  • Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of a particle from its momentum, speed or kinetic energy.
  • Explain how electron diffraction shows the wave nature of matter, and predict how the pattern changes with the electrons' momentum.
  • Describe an electron-scattering experiment and use the angle of the first minimum to find the diameter of a nucleus.
  • Explain why photons scattered by electrons have a longer wavelength, and calculate the shift with Δλ=hmec(1−cos⁡θ)\Delta\lambda = \frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}(1 - \cos\theta).
  • Explain why Compton scattering is further evidence for the particle nature of light, and what it means to say that light and matter show .
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A trolley of mass 1.5 kg\pu{1.5 kg} moves at 0.80 m s−1\pu{0.80 m s-1}. What is its momentum, in kg m s−1\text{kg m s}^{-1}?
Check yourself
What is the energy of a photon of wavelength 450 nm\pu{450 nm}? Give it in units of 10−19 J10^{-19}\ \text{J}, to 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Monochromatic light passes through a single slit. The slit is made narrower. What happens to the angle of the first minimum of the diffraction pattern?

Revise first: 1.6 Momentum and impulse, 3.6 Single-slit diffraction and diffraction gratings, 5.2 Atomic spectra and energy levels and 5.4 The photoelectric effect

Matter waves and the de Broglie wavelength

In 5.4, light acted like a stream of particles: one photon released at most one electron. Yet light also diffracts and interferes, which only a wave can do. So light behaves as a wave in some experiments and as particles in others.

In 1924 Louis de Broglie turned the question round. If waves can act like particles, can particles such as electrons act like waves?

He proposed that every moving particle has a wavelength set by its pp. The hh links the two, just as it links a photon's energy to its frequency.

In the formula booklet
λ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p}

This equation is in the data booklet. So are the constants you need with it: h=6.63⋅10−34 J sh = \pu{6.63e-34 J s}, the electron mass me=9.110⋅10−31 kgm_\text{e} = \pu{9.110e-31 kg} and c=3.00⋅108 m s−1c = \pu{3.00e8 m s-1}.

For a particle of mass mm moving at speed vv, the momentum is p=mvp = mv, so λ=hmv\lambda = \frac{h}{mv}. A heavier or faster particle has a shorter wavelength.

Worked exampleAn electron moves at 4.5⋅106 m s−1\pu{4.5e6 m s-1}. Calculate its de Broglie wavelength.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Find the momentum: p=mev=9.110×10−31×4.5×106=4.10⋅10−24 kg m s−1p = m_\text{e}v = 9.110 \times 10^{-31} \times 4.5 \times 10^{6} = \pu{4.10e-24 kg m s-1}.

Often you know the kinetic energy, not the speed. The data booklet gives Ek=p22mE_\text{k} = \frac{p^2}{2m}, so p=2mEkp = \sqrt{2mE_\text{k}}.

An electron accelerated from rest through a potential difference VV gains kinetic energy Ek=eVE_\text{k} = eV, in joules. The relations p=mvp = mv and Ek=p22mE_\text{k} = \frac{p^{2}}{2m} hold while the speed is well below cc, which is true for electrons accelerated through a few thousand volts.

Worked exampleElectrons in a diffraction tube are accelerated from rest through a potential difference of 2.50 kV\pu{2.50 kV}. Determine their de Broglie wavelength.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Kinetic energy: Ek=eV=1.60×10−19×2500=4.00⋅10−16 JE_\text{k} = eV = 1.60 \times 10^{-19} \times 2500 = \pu{4.00e-16 J}.

Since p=2mEkp = \sqrt{2mE_\text{k}}, the wavelength is proportional to 1Ek\frac{1}{\sqrt{E_\text{k}}}. Four times the kinetic energy halves the wavelength.

So why does a football never diffract? A 0.43 kg\pu{0.43 kg} ball at 20 m s−1\pu{20 m s-1} has λ=6.63×10−340.43×20≈8⋅10−35 m\lambda = \frac{6.63 \times 10^{-34}}{0.43 \times 20} \approx \pu{8e-35 m}. Nothing is anywhere near that small, so its wave behaviour can never be seen.

Check yourself
The kinetic energy of an electron is made four times larger. Its speed stays well below cc. What happens to its de Broglie wavelength?
Check yourself
A slow neutron from a reactor moves at 2.2⋅103 m s−1\pu{2.2e3 m s-1}. Calculate its de Broglie wavelength, in units of 10−10 m10^{-10}\ \text{m}, to 2 significant figures. The neutron mass is in the data booklet.

Diffraction of particles

Diffraction is the test for a wave. If a beam of electrons diffracts, electrons must have a wave nature. For strong diffraction, the gap or obstacle must be about the size of the wavelength.

Electrons accelerated through a few thousand volts have λ≈10−11\lambda \approx 10^{-11} to 10−1010^{-10} m. The atoms in a crystal are about 10−1010^{-10} m apart, so a crystal is the right size to diffract them.

In an electron diffraction tube, an electron gun accelerates electrons through a potential difference VV. The beam passes through a thin film of graphite and hits a fluorescent screen, which glows where electrons land.

Electron diffraction. On the left, an electron gun accelerates electrons through a potential difference V. The beam travels right and passes through a thin graphite film. Beyond the film the electrons spread out at certain angles and hit a fluorescent screen. On the right, a front view of the screen shows a bright central spot surrounded by two concentric bright rings. Not to scale. electron gun p.d. V beam thin graphite film screen screen, front view
Electrons through a thin graphite film give bright rings, not a single spot.

The screen shows bright rings around a central spot. Each ring is a diffraction maximum, where waves scattered by the regularly spaced atoms arrive in phase. Particles travelling in straight lines would give only the spot.

Increase VV and the electrons' momentum rises, so λ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p} falls. The rings shrink, because a shorter wavelength diffracts through smaller angles. The ring sizes match the wavelength that λ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p} predicts.

Worked exampleA beam of electrons passes through a thin graphite film and forms bright rings on a screen. Explain how this shows that electrons have a wave nature.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: diffraction is a property of waves.
Check yourself
The accelerating potential difference in an electron diffraction tube is reduced. What happens to the rings on the screen?

Particle diffraction can also measure the size of a nucleus. Fire a beam of very high-energy electrons at a thin target, and move a detector round to count the electrons scattered at each angle θ\theta.

Each nucleus acts like a tiny obstacle, so the electrons diffract around it. The intensity falls as θ\theta grows, but at one angle it drops to a clear minimum. This is the first diffraction minimum.

Graph of the intensity of scattered electrons against scattering angle theta, in degrees. The intensity is highest at small angles and falls as the angle increases. At one angle, marked theta min with a dashed line, the curve dips to a clear minimum, then rises slightly before falling again. No numbers are marked on the axes. θmin scattering angle θ / ° intensity of scattered electrons
The dip at θmin\theta_\text{min} is the first diffraction minimum. Its position depends on the electrons' wavelength and the size of the nucleus.

The first minimum comes at the same place as for a pattern from a slit of width DD, where DD is the diameter of the nucleus. The angles here are not always small, so use sin⁡θ\sin\theta.

Learn this
sin⁡θmin≈λD\sin\theta_\text{min} \approx \frac{\lambda}{D}

For small angles, sin⁡θ≈θ\sin\theta \approx \theta in radians, and this becomes θ=λb\theta = \frac{\lambda}{b} from 3.6. To make θmin\theta_\text{min} measurable, λ\lambda must be comparable to DD, about 10−1510^{-15} to 10−1410^{-14} m. That needs electrons with hundreds of MeV. They move at almost cc, so p=2mEkp = \sqrt{2mE_\text{k}} no longer works, and questions give you λ\lambda or pp.

Worked exampleElectrons with a de Broglie wavelength of 3.1⋅10−15 m\pu{3.1e-15 m} are scattered by nuclei of diameter 9.6⋅10−15 m\pu{9.6e-15 m}. Calculate the angle of the first minimum of intensity.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use sin⁡θmin≈λD=3.1×10−159.6×10−15=0.323\sin\theta_\text{min} \approx \frac{\lambda}{D} = \frac{3.1 \times 10^{-15}}{9.6 \times 10^{-15}} = 0.323.
Worked exampleElectrons of momentum 5.2⋅10−19 kg m s−1\pu{5.2e-19 kg m s-1} are scattered by carbon nuclei. The first minimum of intensity is at 13∘13^{\circ}. Determine the diameter of a carbon nucleus.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Find the wavelength: λ=hp=6.63×10−345.2×10−19=1.275⋅10−15 m\lambda = \frac{h}{p} = \frac{6.63 \times 10^{-34}}{5.2 \times 10^{-19}} = \pu{1.275e-15 m}.
Check yourself
Electrons with a de Broglie wavelength of 2.0⋅10−15 m\pu{2.0e-15 m} give a first minimum of intensity at 16∘16^{\circ}. Calculate the diameter of the nuclei, in units of 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}, to 2 significant figures.

Compton scattering

In 1923 Arthur Compton fired X-rays at a carbon block and measured the wavelength of the X-rays scattered at different angles. He found X-rays with a longer wavelength than the ones he sent in.

Picture the X-ray as a photon, a particle with energy E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda}. It hits an electron that is free, or so loosely bound that it acts free. Like one snooker ball hitting another, the photon gives some of its energy to the electron, which recoils.

The scattered photon has less energy, so its wavelength is longer. It still travels at cc: a photon cannot slow down, so losing energy lowers its frequency instead.

Compton scattering. An incident photon, drawn as a wavy arrow with a short wavelength, travels from the left towards an electron at rest. A dashed line continues the original direction to the right. The scattered photon leaves up and to the right at angle theta to the dashed line, drawn with a longer wavelength. The electron recoils down and to the right. Not to scale. θ incident photon, λi scattered photon, λf electron at rest recoiling electron
θ\theta is the angle between the photon's new direction and its original direction.

The shift in wavelength depends only on the angle θ\theta through which the photon is scattered. Its derivation is not needed, but you must be able to use it. It is in the data booklet.

In the formula booklet
λf−λi=Δλ=hmec(1−cos⁡θ)\lambda_\text{f} - \lambda_\text{i} = \Delta\lambda = \frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}(1 - \cos\theta)

λi\lambda_\text{i} is the incident wavelength and λf\lambda_\text{f} the scattered one. The constant hmec=6.63×10−349.110×10−31×3.00×108=2.43⋅10−12 m\frac{h}{m_\text{e}c} = \frac{6.63 \times 10^{-34}}{9.110 \times 10^{-31} \times 3.00 \times 10^{8}} = \pu{2.43e-12 m}.

At θ=0\theta = 0 the photon carries straight on and Δλ=0\Delta\lambda = 0. At 90∘90^{\circ}, cos⁡θ=0\cos\theta = 0, so Δλ=hmec\Delta\lambda = \frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}. The biggest shift, 2hmec=4.85⋅10−12 m\frac{2h}{m_\text{e}c} = \pu{4.85e-12 m}, is for a photon scattered straight back, at 180∘180^{\circ}.

Worked exampleX-rays of wavelength 4.50⋅10−11 m\pu{4.50e-11 m} are scattered by free electrons. Calculate the wavelength of the X-rays scattered through 70.0∘70.0^{\circ}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Find the shift: Δλ=hmec(1−cos⁡θ)=2.426×10−12×(1−cos⁡70.0∘)\Delta\lambda = \frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}(1 - \cos\theta) = 2.426 \times 10^{-12} \times (1 - \cos 70.0^{\circ}).

Energy is conserved in the collision. The kinetic energy of the recoiling electron equals the energy the photon loses: Ek=hcλi−hcλfE_\text{k} = \frac{hc}{\lambda_\text{i}} - \frac{hc}{\lambda_\text{f}}.

Worked exampleA gamma-ray photon of energy 0.360 MeV\pu{0.360 MeV} is scattered by a free electron through 120∘120^{\circ}. Determine the kinetic energy of the recoiling electron, in MeV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Convert the energy to joules: 0.360×1.60×10−13=5.76⋅10−14 J0.360 \times 1.60 \times 10^{-13} = \pu{5.76e-14 J}. Then λi=hcE=6.63×10−34×3.00×1085.76×10−14=3.453⋅10−12 m\lambda_\text{i} = \frac{hc}{E} = \frac{6.63 \times 10^{-34} \times 3.00 \times 10^{8}}{5.76 \times 10^{-14}} = \pu{3.453e-12 m}.

The shift is the same size whatever the incident wavelength. For X-rays of 5⋅10−11 m\pu{5e-11 m}, a shift of a few picometres is several per cent, easy to measure. For visible light of 5⋅10−7 m\pu{5e-7 m} it is about one part in 10510^{5}, so you never notice it.

Check yourself
X-ray photons are scattered by free electrons. In which direction are the scattered photons with the longest wavelength found?
Check yourself
An X-ray photon scatters off a free electron, and its wavelength increases by 3.00⋅10−12 m\pu{3.00e-12 m}. Calculate the scattering angle, in degrees, to 3 significant figures.

Compton scattering as evidence, and wave-particle duality

Why does the shift matter so much? In the wave model, an X-ray wave makes each electron vibrate at the wave's own frequency. The vibrating electron then gives out waves of that same frequency. So the wave model predicts no change of wavelength at any angle.

The photon model predicts the shift exactly. Treat the photon as a particle with energy hcλ\frac{hc}{\lambda} and momentum p=hλp = \frac{h}{\lambda}, the de Broglie relation used the other way round. Then apply and of energy to its collision with an electron. Out comes the Compton formula.

Compare this with the photoelectric effect from 5.4. There, the wave model cannot explain the threshold frequency, why the maximum kinetic energy does not depend on intensity, or why emission starts at once. Those features show that light's energy arrives in packets of hfhf.

Compton scattering adds something new. It shows that a photon also carries momentum, and that it collides with a single electron just as one particle collides with another. So it makes the stronger case for photons.

A photon-electron collision is like a collision of two balls: total momentum and total energy are conserved, and the energy lost by one is gained by the other. But a photon has no mass and always moves at cc. Its momentum is hλ\frac{h}{\lambda}, not mvmv, and it loses energy by getting a longer wavelength, not by slowing down.

Worked exampleExplain, using the photon model, why X-rays scattered by free electrons have a longer wavelength than the incident X-rays.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: an X-ray photon collides with an electron.
Worked exampleOutline why Compton scattering gives stronger support than the photoelectric effect for the idea that light is made of photons.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: the photoelectric effect shows only that light transfers energy in packets of hfhf.

Put the evidence together and you reach . Light shows wave behaviour in interference and diffraction, and particle behaviour in the photoelectric effect and Compton scattering. Electrons sent through graphite one at a time each make a single dot, like particles, yet thousands of dots build up the rings of a wave.

Check yourself
X-rays are scattered by a block of carbon. Which observation can the wave model of light not explain?
Check yourself
Which statement about wave-particle duality is correct?

Common mistakes

  • Using p=mvp = mv for a photon. A photon has no mass: its momentum is p=hλp = \frac{h}{\lambda}.
  • Forgetting to convert the accelerating voltage to energy. Ek=eVE_\text{k} = eV in joules, then p=2mEkp = \sqrt{2mE_\text{k}}.
  • Using the electron's recoil angle in the Compton formula. θ\theta is the angle through which the photon is scattered.
  • Saying the scattered photon slows down. It still travels at cc; its energy and frequency fall, so its wavelength rises.
  • Leaving the calculator in radians when finding cos⁡θ\cos\theta or sin⁡θmin\sin\theta_\text{min} from an angle in degrees.

Exam tips

  • "Calculate" or "determine": write the equation, then substitute the numbers. A formula written down with no substitution does not count as using it.
  • Paper 1A often gives Compton shifts as multiples of hmec\frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}. Work out 1−cos⁡θ1 - \cos\theta: 0 at 0∘0^{\circ}, 1 at 90∘90^{\circ}, 2 at 180∘180^{\circ}.
  • "Describe" a scattering experiment: a high-energy electron beam, a thin target, a detector moved through different angles, and a first minimum where sin⁡θ≈λD\sin\theta \approx \frac{\lambda}{D}.
  • "Explain" the Compton shift with one point per sentence: collision, energy transferred to the electron, less photon energy, E=hcλE = \frac{hc}{\lambda} so a longer wavelength.

Key takeaways

In bookletλ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p}
Learn thisFor a particle well below cc: p=mv=2mEkp = mv = \sqrt{2mE_\text{k}}, and an electron accelerated through VV has Ek=eVE_\text{k} = eV.
Learn thisElectron diffraction is evidence for the wave nature of matter: it needs a gap or spacing similar to the de Broglie wavelength.
Learn thissin⁡θmin≈λD\sin\theta_\text{min} \approx \frac{\lambda}{D}
In bookletλf−λi=Δλ=hmec(1−cos⁡θ)\lambda_\text{f} - \lambda_\text{i} = \Delta\lambda = \frac{h}{m_\text{e}c}(1 - \cos\theta)
Learn thisCompton scattering: the photon loses energy to a free electron, so its wavelength increases. θ\theta is the photon's scattering angle.
Learn thisCompton scattering shows photons carry momentum as well as energy, so it is stronger evidence for photons than the photoelectric effect.

Practise this

88 past-paper questions on Quantum physics and matter-radiation interaction in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Quantum physics and matter-radiation interaction →