5.9 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Nuclear stability and the neutrino

In a minute

The holds nuclei together, but only over about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}. That short range explains the of stable nuclei and the flat part of the curve. The energies of emitted particles reveal and the .

You'll be able to

  • Describe the evidence for a strong, short-range attraction between nucleons.
  • Explain why heavy stable nuclei have more neutrons than protons, and predict how an unstable nuclide decays.
  • Explain why the binding energy per nucleon is about constant above A≈60A \approx 60, using masses in u, MeV c−2\text{MeV}\,c^{-2} and kg.
  • Explain how alpha and gamma line spectra show discrete nuclear energy levels.
  • Explain how the continuous beta spectrum led to the neutrino, and find the maximum beta energy from masses.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
Which statement about the is correct?
Check yourself
In , what happens to the numbers of protons and neutrons in the nucleus?
Check yourself
A nucleus with nucleon number 40 has a total of 342 MeV\pu{342 MeV}. What is its binding energy per nucleon, in MeV? Give 3 significant figures.

Revise first: 5.6 Binding energy and mass defect and 5.7 Radioactive decay

Evidence for the strong nuclear force

In 5.6 you met the , an attraction between nucleons with a range of about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}. You can't see a force. So what is the evidence for this one?

Evidence 1: nuclei exist. Protons in a nucleus are about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m} apart, and every pair repels. Gravity is about 103610^{36} times too weak to hold them, so a much stronger attraction must act.

Evidence 2: neutrons are bound. The deuteron, one proton plus one neutron, is stable. No electric force acts on the uncharged neutron, so the binding force acts on neutrons too.

Worked exampleTwo protons in a nucleus are 2.0⋅10−15 m\pu{2.0e-15 m} apart. Calculate the electric force between them, and show that gravity cannot hold them together.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Constants from the data booklet: k=8.99⋅109 N m2 C−2k = \pu{8.99e9 N m2 C-2}, e=1.60⋅10−19 Ce = \pu{1.60e-19 C}, G=6.67⋅10−11 N m2 kg−2G = \pu{6.67e-11 N m2 kg-2}, mp=1.673⋅10−27 kgm_\text{p} = \pu{1.673e-27 kg}.

Evidence 3: fast . At low energies, alpha particles scattered by a nucleus follow a model with only the electric force (5.3). Faster ones get closer before they are turned back.

Above a certain energy, they come within a few femtometres (1 fm=10−15 m\pu{1 fm} = 10^{-15}\ \text{m}) and the model fails, because the strong force now acts too. So the force exists, and its range is very short.

Worked exampleAlpha particles are fired at an aluminium foil. Above a certain energy, the numbers scattered through large angles no longer agree with a model that uses only the electric force. Explain why, and state what this shows about the strong nuclear force.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Faster alpha particles get closer to the nucleus.
Check yourself
Which observation shows that a force other than gravity and the electric force acts in a nucleus?
Check yourself
Two protons are 2.5⋅10−15 m\pu{2.5e-15 m} apart. What is the electric force between them, in N? Give 2 significant figures.

The neutron-to-proton ratio

A nucleus has ZZ protons and N=A−ZN = A - Z neutrons. Plot every stable nuclide on a graph of NN against ZZ, and they fall in a narrow band.

Graph of neutron number N, from 0 to 150, against proton number Z, from 0 to 100. A dashed straight line shows N equal to Z. A shaded band of stable nuclides follows the N equals Z line for light nuclei, then curves above it as Z increases, passing calcium-40 at Z 20, N 20, iron-56 at Z 26, N 30, tin-120 at Z 50, N 70, and ending at lead-208 at Z 82, N 126. Nuclides above the band have too many neutrons and decay by beta-minus decay. Nuclides below the band have too few neutrons and decay by beta-plus decay. Beyond Z 82 no nuclide is stable, and many of these heavy nuclides decay by alpha decay. 0 20 40 60 80 100 0 40 80 120 proton number Z neutron number N N = Z Ca-40 Fe-56 Sn-120 Pb-208 too many neutrons: beta-minus decay too few neutrons: beta-plus decay Z above 82: none stable, alpha decay stable nuclides
The band follows N=ZN = Z for light nuclei and bends towards more neutrons as ZZ grows.

For light stable nuclei the is about 1. For the heaviest it rises to about 1.5.

Why? The electric force has a long range, so every proton repels every other proton. The strong force reaches only nearest neighbours. So as ZZ grows, the repulsion grows faster than the attraction.

Extra neutrons add strong-force attraction with no repulsion, and spread the protons apart. But too many neutrons also makes a nucleus unstable. A nuclide off the band decays towards it:

1. Above the band (too many neutrons): turns a neutron into a proton.

2. Below the band (too few neutrons): turns a proton into a neutron.

3. Z>82Z > 82: no nuclide is stable. Many of these large nuclei decay by .

Worked exampleOxygen-16, 816O^{16}_{8}\text{O}, and mercury-202, 80202Hg^{202}_{80}\text{Hg}, are both stable. Calculate the neutron-to-proton ratio of each, and comment.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Oxygen-16: N=16−8=8N = 16 - 8 = 8, so NZ=1.00\frac{N}{Z} = 1.00.
Worked exampleNitrogen-13, 713N^{13}_{7}\text{N}, is used in PET heart scans. Stable nitrogen nuclei have 7 or 8 neutrons. Deduce how nitrogen-13 decays, and explain why the decay makes the nucleus more stable.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Nitrogen-13 has too few neutrons.
Check yourself
Cobalt-60 has 27 protons and 33 neutrons. The only stable isotope of cobalt has 32 neutrons. How does cobalt-60 decay?
Check yourself
What is the neutron-to-proton ratio of zirconium-90, 4090Zr^{90}_{40}\text{Zr}? Give 3 significant figures.

Why the binding energy curve levels off

In 5.6 you read the curve. Look again at the part above A≈60A \approx 60.

Graph of binding energy per nucleon in MeV, from 0 to 10, against nucleon number A, from 0 to 250. The curve rises steeply for light nuclei, with helium-4 a separate point above the curve at about 7.1 MeV. It peaks at about 8.8 MeV between A 56 and A 62. A dashed vertical line marks A equal to 60. To the right of it, the shaded strip between two dashed horizontal lines at 7.6 MeV and 8.8 MeV contains the whole rest of the curve, which falls only slowly to about 7.6 MeV at A 238. The strip is labelled approximately constant. 0 50 100 150 200 250 0 2 4 6 8 10 nucleon number A binding energy per nucleon / MeV He-4 A = 60 8.8 7.6 approximately constant above A = 60
Above A≈60A \approx 60 the curve stays between about 7.6 and 8.8 MeV.

From A≈60A \approx 60 to 238, the nucleon number quadruples. Yet the binding energy per nucleon falls only from 8.8 to 7.6 MeV, under 15%.

If each nucleon attracted every other one, the binding energy per nucleon would keep rising with AA. It doesn't. So the flat curve is more evidence of the strong force's short range.

The slow fall comes from the electric force. Every proton repels every other proton, so the repulsion grows faster than AA.

Nuclear masses come in three units, linked in the data booklet: 1 u=931.5 MeV c−2=1.661⋅10−27 kg\pu{1 u} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2} = \pu{1.661e-27 kg}.

Worked exampleA nucleus has nucleon number 120 and a binding energy per nucleon of 8.5 MeV. Determine its mass defect in MeV c−2\text{MeV}\,c^{-2}, in u and in kg.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Total : EB=120×8.5=1020 MeVE_\text{B} = 120 \times 8.5 = \pu{1020 MeV}, so Δm=1020 MeV c−2\Delta m = 1020\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2}.
Worked exampleExplain how the binding energy per nucleon curve, for nucleon numbers above about 60, is evidence that the strong nuclear force has a short range.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The curve is approximately constant there.
Check yourself
Why does the binding energy per nucleon fall slowly for the heaviest nuclei?
Check yourself
Nuclei with A=90A = 90 and A=200A = 200 have binding energies per nucleon of 8.71 MeV and 7.90 MeV. By what percentage is the second smaller than the first? Give 3 significant figures.

Nuclear energy levels

In 5.2, line spectra showed that an atom's electrons have only certain energies. Spectra show the same for nuclei.

Evidence 1: in , the alpha particles from one nuclide have only a few exact kinetic energies. Their spectrum is a few sharp lines.

Only two bodies come out, the alpha particle and the daughter. Conservation of momentum fixes how they share the energy released, so each alpha energy means one energy release.

Different alpha energies mean the daughter is left in different states, each with a definite energy. These are its .

Evidence 2: a daughter in an excited state drops to a lower level by . Each photon carries the gap between two levels, so gamma spectra are line spectra too.

Learn this
Eγ=Eupper−Elower=hfE_\gamma = E_\text{upper} - E_\text{lower} = hf

E=hfE = hf and hh are in the data booklet. The gap between two alpha energies matches a gamma photon energy, give or take the daughter's small recoil.

Energy-level diagram, not to scale. On the left, a short horizontal line high up is the parent nucleus. On the right, two horizontal lines are levels of the daughter nucleus: an excited state 0.29 MeV above the ground state, and the ground state at the bottom. A long arrow labelled alpha 1, 6.05 MeV, goes down from the parent to the daughter's ground state. A shorter arrow labelled alpha 2, 5.76 MeV, goes down from the parent to the excited state. A vertical arrow labelled gamma, 0.29 MeV, goes down from the excited state to the ground state. parent nucleus excited state, 0.29 MeV ground state, 0 daughter nucleus α1: 6.05 MeV α2: 5.76 MeV γ: 0.29 MeV
Not to scale. Each alpha energy leaves the daughter in a different level.
Two graphs side by side, each of number of particles against kinetic energy. Left, alpha particles from one nuclide: two narrow vertical lines, a taller one at 6.05 MeV and a shorter one at 5.76 MeV, with nothing in between. This is a line spectrum. Right, beta-minus particles from one nuclide: a smooth hump that starts at zero energy, rises to a peak at low energy, about a fifth of the maximum energy, then falls to zero at the maximum kinetic energy, E max. This is a continuous spectrum. alpha particles: line spectrum beta particles: continuous spectrum 5.76 6.05 kinetic energy / MeV 0 E max kinetic energy number of particles number of particles
Alpha particles have a few exact energies; beta particles have every energy up to a maximum (next section).
Worked exampleA nuclide emits alpha particles with kinetic energies of 6.05 MeV and 5.76 MeV, as in the diagram. Ignoring recoil, determine the frequency of the gamma photon the daughter then emits.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The gap between the levels is the difference in alpha energies: Eγ=6.05−5.76=0.29 MeVE_\gamma = 6.05 - 5.76 = \pu{0.29 MeV}.

Gamma photons and atomic photons are both photons. Nuclear levels are typically 10410^{4} to 10610^{6} times further apart, so gamma photons carry far more energy than the few eV of atomic photons.

Worked exampleA nuclide's alpha particles have only two kinetic energies, and its daughter nuclei emit gamma photons of one energy. Explain how these observations show that the nucleus has discrete energy levels.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The alpha energies are discrete, and a two-body decay fixes each one.
Check yourself
Why do the gamma photons from one nuclide have only a few definite energies?
Check yourself
A nuclide emits alpha particles with kinetic energies of 4.87 MeV and 4.68 MeV. Ignoring recoil, what is the energy, in MeV, of the gamma photon its daughter emits? Give 2 decimal places.

The beta spectrum and the neutrino

Every beta decay of one nuclide to the same daughter state releases the same energy, because the parent and daughter have fixed masses. With only two bodies, momentum conservation would give every beta particle the same kinetic energy.

Instead, beta particles from one nuclide have every kinetic energy from about zero up to a maximum, EmaxE_\text{max}: a continuous spectrum. EmaxE_\text{max} equals the energy released, less the nucleus's tiny recoil.

In 1930 Pauli proposed a third particle that shares the energy, differently each time: an in , a in beta-plus decay. The beta particle gets EmaxE_\text{max} when the antineutrino gets almost nothing.

The charges already balance, so the particle is neutral. EmaxE_\text{max} is almost the whole energy released, so its mass is tiny. It was first detected in 1956, 26 years after conservation of energy predicted it.

To find EmaxE_\text{max}, convert the mass lost to energy. The electron mass, me=0.000549 um_\text{e} = \pu{0.000549 u}, is in the data booklet.

Worked examplePhosphorus-32, a beta-minus emitter used in cancer treatment, decays to sulfur-32. Their nuclear masses are 31.965672 u and 31.963287 u. Calculate the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted electrons, in MeV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Mass lost: Δm=31.965672−31.963287−0.000549=0.001836 u\Delta m = 31.965672 - 31.963287 - 0.000549 = \pu{0.001836 u}. Subtract the electron, which is created in the decay.
Worked exampleA student measures the kinetic energies of the beta-minus particles from a sample of one nuclide. Describe what she finds, and explain how it shows that a third particle is emitted.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The energies form a continuous range up to a maximum.
Check yourself
Which observation about beta-minus decay led physicists to propose a third particle?
Check yourself
In a beta decay the mass lost is 2.65⋅10−30 kg\pu{2.65e-30 kg}. What is the maximum kinetic energy of the beta particles, in MeV? Give 3 significant figures.

Common mistakes

  • Saying all beta particles from one nuclide have the same energy. Only alpha and gamma energies are discrete; beta energies spread up to EmaxE_\text{max}.
  • Saying N = Z for every stable nucleus. Heavy stable nuclei have up to 1.5 neutrons per proton.
  • Mixing up the beta decays: too many neutrons gives beta-minus, too few gives beta-plus.
  • Calling the curve above A≈60A \approx 60 'constant'. It is approximately constant, falling slowly from 8.8 to 7.6 MeV.

Exam tips

  • 'Explain' the neutrino evidence in two steps: the beta spectrum is continuous, so another emitted particle shares the energy. A momentum-only answer may lose a mark.
  • 'Deduce' a decay mode: compare N with the stable isotopes, then name the decay that moves the nuclide towards the band.
  • 'Determine' a gamma photon's frequency: subtract the alpha energies, convert MeV to J, then use E=hfE = hf.

Key takeaways

Learn thisStrong force evidence: nuclei hold together against proton repulsion, neutrons are bound, and fast alpha particles depart from the electric-force model within about 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}.
Learn thisStable nuclei: NZ≈1\frac{N}{Z} \approx 1 when light, up to about 1.5 when heavy. Too many neutrons: beta-minus. Too few: beta-plus. Z>82Z > 82: none stable.
Learn thisAbove A≈60A \approx 60 the binding energy per nucleon is approximately constant, because each nucleon is bound only to its nearest neighbours.
Learn thisAlpha and gamma line spectra show discrete nuclear energy levels; a gamma photon carries the gap between two levels.
Learn thisThe beta spectrum is continuous up to EmaxE_\text{max}, so the (anti)neutrino shares the energy released.
Learn thisEmax≈Δm c2,Δm=Mparent−Mdaughter−me (nuclear masses)E_\text{max} \approx \Delta m\,c^{2}, \qquad \Delta m = M_\text{parent} - M_\text{daughter} - m_\text{e}\ \text{(nuclear masses)}

Practise this

117 past-paper questions on Radioactivity and nuclear reactions in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Radioactivity and nuclear reactions →