5.12 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Fusion and the life of stars

In a minute

Stars shine because in their cores turns hydrogen into helium, and the lost mass becomes energy. While outward pressure balances the inward gravitational force, a star sits stably on the . Its mass then decides its future: a and then a , or a red supergiant and a supernova.

You'll be able to

  • Explain how outward radiation pressure and the inward gravitational force keep a star stable.
  • Calculate the energy released in a fusion reaction, and link it to a star's .
  • Explain why fusion needs both a very high temperature and a very high density.
  • Outline how a star's mass decides its lifetime, its later stages and its remnant.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
In a nuclear reaction, the total mass decreases by 0.0042 u. Calculate the energy released, in MeV, to 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Two very light nuclei join to make one heavier nucleus, releasing energy. Why is energy released?
Check yourself
What is the luminosity of a star?

Revise first: 2.1 Particles, density and temperature, 2.4 Thermal radiation and black bodies and 5.6 Binding energy and mass defect

Why a star is stable

A star is a huge ball of hot gas. Gravity pulls every part of it towards the centre. So why doesn't it collapse?

Fusion in the core keeps the gas very hot, and hot gas pushes outwards: gas pressure. The radiation streaming out from the core pushes outwards too: radiation pressure.

Cross-section of a star. A shaded core sits at the centre, where fusion releases energy. A dashed circle part-way out marks one layer of gas. On a small piece of that layer at the top, two arrows of equal length act: one points outwards, away from the centre, labelled radiation and gas pressure; the other points inwards, towards the centre, labelled gravitational force. Equal lengths show that the two balance. outward: radiation pressure and gas pressure inward: gravitational force (towards the centre) core: fusion releases energy one layer of gas: the two arrows balance, so the layer stays where it is
On every layer, outward pressure balances the inward gravitational force.

A star in this steady state, fusing hydrogen into helium in its core, is on the . The Sun has been there for about 4.6 billion years.

The balance corrects itself. If fusion speeds up, the pressure rises and the core expands, which cools it and lowers its density. Fusion slows again. If fusion slows, gravity squeezes the core, heating it, and fusion speeds up.

Worked exampleA main-sequence star stays almost the same size for billions of years. Outline how it stays in equilibrium.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Name the inward force, then the outward effect and its energy source.
Worked exampleFor a short time, the rate of fusion in a main-sequence star's core increases. Explain how the star returns to equilibrium.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Say what extra energy does to the outward pressure, and how the core responds.
Check yourself
What stops a main-sequence star from collapsing under its own gravity?
Check yourself
Fusion in the core of a star stops. What happens to the core next?

Fusion: where a star's energy comes from

No chemical fuel could keep the Sun shining for billions of years. Only nuclear reactions release enough energy per kilogram.

In a main-sequence star, hydrogen becomes helium. Overall, four protons make a helium-4 nucleus, two positrons (e+\mathrm{e}^{+}) and two neutrinos (νe\nu_\text{e}). The steps (the proton–proton chain) need not be learnt.

Learn this
4 11H→24He+2 e++2 νe4\,{}^{1}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow {}^{4}_{2}\text{He} + 2\,\mathrm{e}^{+} + 2\,\nu_\text{e}

The products have less mass. This mass lost, also called the of the reaction, has become energy, by , E=mc2E = mc^{2}, which is in the data booklet.

With masses in u, use 1 u=931.5 MeV c−2\pu{1 u} = 931.5\ \text{MeV}\,c^{-2}. The proton mass 1.007276 u\pu{1.007276 u} and the electron (and positron) mass 0.000549 u\pu{0.000549 u} are in the data booklet. Count every particle, positrons included; neutrino mass is negligible.

Worked exampleIn one fusion step in the Sun, two helium-3 nuclei fuse: 23He+23He→24He+2 11H{}^{3}_{2}\text{He} + {}^{3}_{2}\text{He} \rightarrow {}^{4}_{2}\text{He} + 2\,{}^{1}_{1}\text{H}. The nuclear masses are helium-3: 3.014932 u and helium-4: 4.001506 u. Calculate the energy released, in MeV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Mass before: 2×3.014932=6.029864 u2 \times 3.014932 = \pu{6.029864 u}.

A star's is the energy it radiates each second. For a star in equilibrium this equals the energy fusion releases each second, so divide it by the energy from one reaction to get the reactions per second.

Worked exampleA main-sequence star has a luminosity of 7.2⋅1026 W\pu{7.2e26 W}. Each helium-4 nucleus it makes releases 26.7 MeV in total. Determine the mass of hydrogen nuclei it turns into helium each second.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Energy per helium nucleus: 26.7×1.60×10−13=4.272⋅10−12 J26.7 \times 1.60 \times 10^{-13} = \pu{4.272e-12 J}.
Check yourself
Using nuclear masses, calculate the energy released when four protons become a helium-4 nucleus (4.001506 u), two positrons and two neutrinos.
Check yourself
A star has a luminosity of 5.4⋅1027 W\pu{5.4e27 W}. Calculate the mass it loses each second as radiated energy, in kg, to 2 significant figures.

Conditions for fusion: temperature and density

Nuclei are positive, so they repel. The attractive only acts over about 10−1510^{-15} m. To fuse, two nuclei must get that close.

Why a high temperature? Mean kinetic energy is 32kBT\frac{3}{2}k_\text{B}T (2.1). In a very hot core, nuclei move fast enough to get close despite the repulsion.

Why a high density? With many nuclei in each cubic metre, collisions are frequent, so enough fusions happen each second.

Gravity supplies both: a contracting gas cloud gets denser and hotter. At about 10710^{7} K in the core, hydrogen fusion starts. Heavier nuclei repel more strongly: helium fusion needs about 10810^{8} K.

Worked exampleExplain why fusion in a star's core happens only when the temperature and the density are both very high.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Temperature: what must the nuclei overcome, and why?
Worked exampleEstimate the core temperature at which the mean kinetic energy of the nuclei is 2.2 keV.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Ek=32kBTE_\text{k} = \frac{3}{2}k_\text{B}T, so T=2Ek3kBT = \frac{2E_\text{k}}{3k_\text{B}}.

Beyond the syllabus: 2 keV is far below the repulsion barrier. Only the fastest nuclei fuse, and only by quantum tunnelling, so each fusion is rare and stars burn slowly.

Check yourself
Why does fusing helium nuclei need a hotter core than fusing hydrogen nuclei?
Check yourself
A star's core is at 1.2⋅108 K\pu{1.2e8 K}. Calculate the mean kinetic energy of its nuclei, in J, to 2 significant figures.

How mass decides a star's life

Mass decides a star's life: how hot its core gets, which reactions happen, how long each stage lasts and what is left.

Stars spend about 90% of their lives on the main sequence. A more massive star has a hotter core and fuses much faster. It is more luminous, with a hotter surface, and it uses up its core hydrogen sooner despite having more.

When the core hydrogen runs out, core fusion stops. Gravity squeezes the core, which heats up, and hydrogen fuses in a shell around it. The outer layers swell and cool: the star becomes a , or a red supergiant if massive.

The hotter core now fuses helium into carbon and oxygen.

Flow chart of how a star's mass decides its life. A cloud of gas and dust contracts to form a main-sequence star, which fuses hydrogen in its core. The path then splits. For an initial mass up to about 8 solar masses, the star becomes a red giant with helium fusion in its core, its outer layers drift off as a planetary nebula, and a white dwarf is left, with no fusion. For more than about 8 solar masses, the star becomes a red supergiant with fusion up to iron, its core collapses in a supernova, and a neutron star is left, or a black hole for the most massive stars. cloud of gas and dust contracts main-sequence star: hydrogen fusion in core red giant: helium fusion in core outer layers drift off as a planetary nebula white dwarf: no fusion, cools red supergiant: fusion up to iron core collapses: supernova neutron star, or black hole for the most massive stars up to about 8 solar masses more than about 8 solar masses
The two paths. The 8 solar-mass boundary is approximate.

Up to about 8 solar masses, the core never fuses carbon. The outer layers drift off as a planetary nebula, leaving a : Earth-sized, very dense and with no fusion. It shines only because it is hot, and slowly cools. The Sun will end this way.

Above about 8 solar masses, the core fuses heavier nuclei, up to iron. Iron sits at the top of the curve (with nickel), so fusing it would absorb energy. With no energy source, the core collapses and the star explodes as a supernova. A neutron star is left, or a black hole for the most massive stars.

In 5.13 you will follow these stages on a Hertzsprung–Russell diagram.

Worked exampleIn a red giant's core, three helium-4 nuclei fuse into one carbon-12 nucleus. The nuclear masses are helium-4: 4.001506 u and carbon-12: 11.996706 u. Calculate the energy released.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Mass before: 3×4.001506=12.004518 u3 \times 4.001506 = \pu{12.004518 u}. Mass after: 11.996706 u\pu{11.996706 u}.
Worked exampleA main-sequence star has a mass of 15 solar masses. Outline its likely evolution after the main sequence.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Name the next stage and its core fusion.
Check yourself
Which main-sequence star will leave the main sequence first?
Check yourself
Why can't fusion release energy once a massive star's core is iron?

Common mistakes

  • Writing only "gravity". Name the inward gravitational force (or pressure) and the outward radiation (or gas) pressure.
  • Ignoring positrons in a mass defect from nuclear masses. Subtract 0.000549 u\pu{0.000549 u} for each.
  • Calling a red giant "brighter" or just "hotter". Say luminosity, and say surface or core temperature.
  • Sending a star of a few solar masses to a supernova. Up to about 8 solar masses, stars end as white dwarfs.

Exam tips

  • "Outline" or "describe" equilibrium: name the inward gravitational force and the outward radiation pressure, and say they balance.
  • "Calculate" the energy released: write the mass-defect line with every particle, then multiply by 931.5.
  • "Explain" the conditions for fusion: kinetic energy to overcome repulsion, the strong force at short range, and density for frequent collisions.

Key takeaways

Learn thisA star is stable when the outward force from radiation and gas pressure balances the inward gravitational force.
Learn this4 11H→24He+2 e++2 νe4\,{}^{1}_{1}\text{H} \rightarrow {}^{4}_{2}\text{He} + 2\,\mathrm{e}^{+} + 2\,\nu_\text{e}
Learn thisEnergy released == mass defect in u × 931.5\times\ 931.5 MeV, positrons included. Luminosity ÷\div energy per reaction == reactions per second.
Learn thisFusion needs a high temperature (to overcome electrostatic repulsion) and a high density (for frequent collisions).
Learn thisMore massive main-sequence stars are more luminous and leave the main sequence sooner.
Learn thisUp to about 8 solar masses: red giant, planetary nebula, white dwarf. Above: red supergiant, supernova, neutron star or black hole.

Practise this

36 past-paper questions on Stellar evolution and processes in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Stellar evolution and processes →