The nuclear atom
In a minute
Firing at thin gold foil showed that an atom is mostly empty space, with almost all its mass and positive charge packed into a tiny . You describe any nucleus with two whole numbers: its and its .
You'll be able to
- Describe the and what the alpha particles did.
- Explain how each observation leads to a tiny, dense, positive nucleus surrounded by mostly empty space.
- Read and write nuclear notation , and count the protons, neutrons and electrons in an atom or ion.
- Calculate the charge on a nucleus from its proton number.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 2.12 Current, potential difference and emf and 4.4 Electric charge and Coulomb's law
The Geiger–Marsden–Rutherford experiment
Around 1900, the accepted picture of the atom was the "plum pudding" model. Positive charge was spread evenly through the whole atom, with tiny negative electrons dotted through it. Nobody could see inside an atom, so the model had to be tested.
In 1909, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, working in Ernest Rutherford's laboratory, fired at very thin gold foil. An alpha particle is two protons and two neutrons bound together. Its charge is , where is the , and its mass is about 7300 times an electron's.
Each alpha particle that hits the zinc sulfide screen makes a tiny flash of light. Through the microscope, the experimenters counted the flashes at each angle.
The air was pumped out, because alpha particles travel only a few centimetres in air before stopping. The foil was less than a micrometre thick, so almost every alpha particle got through it.
What they saw:
1. Most alpha particles passed straight through the foil, with little or no deflection.
2. Some were deflected through small angles.
3. A very few, roughly one in many thousands, were deflected by more than . Some came almost straight back towards the source.
The plum pudding model can't explain observation 3. Its positive charge is spread thinly through the whole atom, so the electric force on an alpha particle is never large. Every alpha particle should get through, bent by a tiny angle at most.
Rutherford explained the results in 1911. The positive charge and almost all the mass of each atom must be packed into a tiny nucleus at its centre. Close to such a concentrated charge, the electric repulsion on an alpha particle becomes very large, because Coulomb's force grows as when the distance shrinks.
Each observation leads to a conclusion:
1. Most pass straight through, so most of the atom is empty space. The nucleus is tiny compared with the whole atom.
2. Some are deflected away from their path, so the nucleus is positively charged. It repels the positive alpha particles.
3. A very few bounce back, so the positive charge and almost all the mass are concentrated in that tiny nucleus. Only a strong force from a much heavier target can turn a fast alpha particle around.
The electrons play almost no part. An alpha particle is thousands of times heavier than an electron, so electrons cannot noticeably deflect it.
An atom is about across, while a nucleus is about to across. So an atom is roughly to times wider than its nucleus.
At SL you describe and explain this experiment in words; no formula is needed. In these experiments the alpha particles never get close enough to feel any force except electric repulsion, so that is the only force you consider.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- A large deflection needs a large force. Ask what makes the force large, then why that happens rarely.
- Link both the size of the force and the rarity to the nucleus: its charge, its mass and its size.
- The positive charge of each silver atom is concentrated in a tiny nucleus, which also holds almost all of the atom's mass. An alpha particle passing very close to a nucleus feels a very large electric repulsion, because both are positive and the force increases as the distance decreases. The massive nucleus barely moves, so the alpha particle is turned back through a large angle. The nucleus is tiny compared with the atom, so very few alpha particles pass close enough, and the fraction is very small.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Divide the atom's diameter by the nucleus's: .
- Both lengths are in metres, so the ratio has no unit. The data have 2 significant figures, so round to 2.
- Sense check: if the nucleus were a bead, the atom would be about across, all of it nearly empty.
This is how models change in physics. The plum pudding model fitted earlier evidence, but it could not survive one clear result it failed to predict. The nuclear model replaced it, and later models of the electrons were built on it (5.2).
Nuclear notation
A is made of protons and neutrons. Together they are called . A proton has charge ; a neutron is uncharged.
Nuclear notation puts both numbers on the chemical symbol X: at the top left, at the bottom left.
The question always gives the chemical symbol, so you don't need to recall it. The element sets anyway, so is sometimes left off: means .
The neutron number is what is left once you take away the protons:
A neutral atom has as many electrons as protons, so it has electrons. An ion with charge has lost electrons; an ion with charge has gained . The nucleus itself always carries charge .
Nuclei of one element always share the same but can have different numbers of neutrons, so different . You meet these in 5.6.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- The bottom number is the proton number: .
- The top number is the nucleon number, . So .
- A neutral cobalt atom would also have 27 electrons.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Protons give the proton number: .
- Nucleons are protons plus neutrons: .
- Charge: 38 protons and 36 electrons give more positive charges than negative, so the charge is .
- So the ion is written . The electrons change the charge, never or .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Only the protons are charged. There are of them; the 70 neutrons add nothing.
- Use the elementary charge from the data booklet, : .
- , positive.
Common mistakes
- Saying the experiment shows the nucleus is mostly empty. The atom is mostly empty; the nucleus is tiny and dense.
- Saying the alpha particles are attracted to the nucleus. Both are positive, so the force is repulsive and the paths bend away.
- Blaming the large deflections on electrons. Electrons are far too light to turn an alpha particle back; the nucleus does it.
- Claiming the scattering experiment shows electrons in discrete energy levels. That evidence comes from atomic spectra.
- Taking as the number of neutrons. counts all the nucleons, so the neutrons are .
- Using for the electrons in an ion. Adjust for the charge: a ion has electrons.
Exam tips
- "Describe" two observations: most alpha particles pass straight through, and a very few are deflected through more than . Write what happened, not what it means.
- "Explain" or "outline" a conclusion: link each observation to one feature of the nucleus, such as "a few bounce back, so the positive charge and mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus".
- When asked for the charge on a nucleus, use with from the data booklet. The nucleon number plays no part.
Key takeaways
Practise this
57 past-paper questions on Atomic structure and discrete energy levels in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.