1.11 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Power, efficiency and energy density

In a minute

is how fast is transferred: the done each second, measured in watts. is the fraction of the input that comes out as useful output. compares fuels by how much energy each cubic metre of fuel releases.

You'll be able to

  • Define power as the rate of doing work or transferring energy, and calculate it with P=ΔWΔtP = \frac{\Delta W}{\Delta t}.
  • Use P=FvP = Fv for a moving a body at vv, including a vehicle working against resistive forces.
  • Calculate efficiency from energies or powers, and use it to find an input or an output.
  • Explain where wasted energy goes in terms of the work done by and air resistance.
  • Compare fuel sources by energy density and specific energy, and find the volume or mass of fuel a job needs.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A horizontal force of 25 N\pu{25 N} pushes a crate 3.2 m\pu{3.2 m} across a floor, in the direction of the force. How much work does the force do, in J? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A ball of mass 0.50 kg\pu{0.50 kg} moves at a of 12 m s−1\pu{12 m s-1}. What is its , in J? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A 6.0 kg\pu{6.0 kg} box is lifted onto a shelf 1.5 m\pu{1.5 m} higher. By how much does its increase, in J? Give 2 significant figures.

Revise first: 1.1 Describing motion, 1.4 Newton's laws and free-body diagrams, 1.9 Work and energy transfer and 1.10 Mechanical energy

Power

Two friends of equal mass climb the same stairs, one walking and one running. They gain the same gravitational potential energy, so they do the same work, but the runner does it in less time.

What differs is the rate of doing work. That rate is called power.

In the formula booklet
P=ΔWΔtP = \frac{\Delta W}{\Delta t}

ΔW\Delta W is the work done, or energy transferred, in J, and Δt\Delta t is the time taken, in s. is a scalar; large values use kW and MW. This equation is in the data booklet.

If the rate changes during the time, ΔWΔt\frac{\Delta W}{\Delta t} gives the average power over that time.

Worked exampleA motor raises a lift cage of mass 640 kg\pu{640 kg} through a height of 18 m\pu{18 m} at constant speed. The journey takes 24 s\pu{24 s}. Calculate the power the motor develops. Ignore friction.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. At constant speed the cage's kinetic energy does not change. The motor's work all goes into gravitational potential energy.

Power also links to and . A constant force FF pushes a body along at velocity vv. In a time Δt\Delta t the body moves Δs=vΔt\Delta s = v\Delta t, so the force does work FΔsF\Delta s.

Divide by Δt\Delta t: P=FΔsΔt=FvP = \frac{F\Delta s}{\Delta t} = Fv.

In the formula booklet
P=FvP = Fv

FF is the force along the direction of motion, in N, and vv is the at that instant, in m s−1\pu{m s-1}. If vv is changing, FvFv gives the power at that instant.

Horizontal forces on a car moving at constant velocity driving force F resistive forces (air resistance and friction) velocity v (constant) arrows to scale: the two horizontal forces are equal in size
At constant velocity the resultant force is zero, so the driving force equals the total resistive force.

A vehicle at constant velocity has zero , by . So the driving force equals the total resistive force, and the engine's power is P=Fresistive vP = F_\text{resistive}\,v.

Worked exampleA cyclist rides along a level road at a constant 7.50 m s−1\pu{7.50 m s-1}. The total resistive force on the cyclist and bicycle is 31.2 N\pu{31.2 N}. Calculate the power the cyclist develops.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The velocity is constant, so the resultant force is zero. The driving force equals the resistive force: F=31.2 NF = \pu{31.2 N}.
Worked exampleA car travels at constant speed along a level road, and its engine keeps developing power. Explain, in terms of work done, what happens to the energy the engine transfers.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Start from the resultant force, then say what the net work does to the kinetic energy.
Check yourself
A climber of mass 61 kg\pu{61 kg} climbs a vertical height of 8.0 m\pu{8.0 m} up a wall in 25 s\pu{25 s}. What average power does she develop in gaining gravitational potential energy, in W? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A motorboat moves at a constant 6.0 m s−1\pu{6.0 m s-1}. The total resistive force from the water and the air is 1.5 kN\pu{1.5 kN}. What power does the engine deliver to drive the boat?

Efficiency

No real machine passes on all its input as useful output: a motor's coils get warm and its bearings rub. On a the useful arrow is always narrower than the input arrow.

In the formula booklet
η=useful work outtotal work in=useful power outtotal power in\eta = \frac{\text{useful work out}}{\text{total work in}} = \frac{\text{useful power out}}{\text{total power in}}

η\eta (Greek eta) has no unit, because it is joules over joules or watts over watts. Multiply it by 100 to give a percentage. This equation is also in the data booklet.

Sankey diagram for the motor of an electric bike, in watts electrical power in 450 W useful: turns the wheels 360 W thermal (wasted) 90 W arrow widths drawn to scale
The two outputs, 360+90360 + 90, add up to the 450 W\pu{450 W} input.
Worked exampleUse the Sankey diagram above to determine the efficiency of the electric bike's motor.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Read the arrows: useful power out 360 W\pu{360 W}, total power in 450 W\pu{450 W}.

If you know the efficiency and the useful output, rearrange: total power in =useful power outη= \frac{\text{useful power out}}{\eta}. Since η<1\eta < 1, the input is always bigger than the output.

Worked exampleA crane lifts a steel beam of mass 850 kg\pu{850 kg} through a height of 22 m\pu{22 m} at constant speed in 40 s\pu{40 s}. The efficiency of the crane's motor is 0.350.35. Determine the electrical power input to the motor.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Useful work out: the gain in gravitational potential energy, mgΔh=850×9.8×22=183260 Jmg\Delta h = 850 \times 9.8 \times 22 = \pu{183260 J}.
Worked exampleExplain why the efficiency of a machine with moving parts is always less than 1.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use to set an upper limit.
Check yourself
A lamp transfers 60 J\pu{60 J} of electrical energy every second and gives out 8.4 J\pu{8.4 J} of light every second. What is its efficiency, as a percentage? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A motor has an efficiency of 0.250.25 and a useful power output of 300 W\pu{300 W}. What power does it waste?

Energy density of fuels

A fuel is a store of energy. Petrol, coal and wood release it by burning; uranium releases it by fission, which you meet in 5.11.

A car's tank has a fixed volume, and an aircraft can only lift so much mass. So you can compare fuels per cubic metre or per kilogram.

Learn this
energy density=EVspecific energy=Em\text{energy density} = \frac{E}{V} \qquad \text{specific energy} = \frac{E}{m}

Some books call both of these "energy density". The unit tells you which is meant: J m−3\pu{J m-3} is per volume and J kg−1\pu{J kg-1} is per mass. The two are linked by the fuel's ρ=mV\rho = \frac{m}{V}.

Learn this
energy density=specific energy×ρ\text{energy density} = \text{specific energy} \times \rho

Typical values (they vary with the exact fuel):

1. Wood about 16 MJ kg−1\pu{16 MJ kg-1}, coal about 30 MJ kg−1\pu{30 MJ kg-1}, petrol and diesel about 45 MJ kg−1\pu{45 MJ kg-1}. Petrol's energy density is about 3.4⋅1010 J m−3\pu{3.4e10 J m-3}.

2. Hydrogen about 140 MJ kg−1\pu{140 MJ kg-1}. But as a gas at atmospheric pressure its energy density is only about 1⋅107 J m−3\pu{1e7 J m-3}, thousands of times less than petrol.

3. Uranium-235 undergoing fission about 8⋅1013 J kg−1\pu{8e13 J kg-1}, roughly a million times more than burning petrol or coal. A lithium-ion battery stores under 1 MJ kg−1\pu{1 MJ kg-1}.

Worked exampleDiesel has an of 3.8⋅1010 J m−3\pu{3.8e10 J m-3}. Calculate the energy released when 0.025 m3\pu{0.025 m3} (25 litres) of diesel burns completely.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Energy density is energy per volume, so energy = energy density ×\times volume.
Worked exampleA diesel generator delivers a steady useful electrical power of 4.2 kW\pu{4.2 kW}. Its efficiency is 0.300.30, and diesel has an energy density of 3.8⋅1010 J m−3\pu{3.8e10 J m-3}. Determine the volume of diesel the generator uses in 1.0 h\pu{1.0 h}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Total power in from the fuel: 4.2×1030.30=1.4⋅104 W\frac{4.2 \times 10^{3}}{0.30} = \pu{1.4e4 W}.
Worked exampleKerosene has a specific energy of 43 MJ kg−1\pu{43 MJ kg-1} and an energy density of 3.5⋅1010 J m−3\pu{3.5e10 J m-3}. A lithium-ion battery pack has a specific energy of 0.9 MJ kg−1\pu{0.9 MJ kg-1} and an energy density of 2⋅109 J m−3\pu{2e9 J m-3}. Suggest why long-distance airliners burn kerosene rather than run on batteries.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Compare the specific energies, and link mass to what an aircraft can lift.
Check yourself
Coal has a specific energy of 3.0⋅107 J kg−1\pu{3.0e7 J kg-1}. What mass of coal must burn to release 4.5⋅1012 J\pu{4.5e12 J}, in kg? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Ethanol has a specific energy of 2.7⋅107 J kg−1\pu{2.7e7 J kg-1} and a density of 790 kg m−3\pu{790 kg m-3}. What is its energy density?
Check yourself
Hydrogen gas has a higher specific energy than petrol, but a much lower energy density at atmospheric pressure. What does this mean?

Common mistakes

  • Confusing power with energy. Power is a rate, in W; energy is in J. Multiply a power by a time in seconds to get an energy.
  • Using the resultant force in P=FvP = Fv. At constant velocity it is zero, so use the driving force, which equals the total resistive force.
  • Writing efficiency upside down, or mixing an energy with a power in the ratio. Put the useful output on top, and make the top and bottom both energies or both powers.
  • Leaving a time in minutes or hours, or a power in kW, when working in joules. Convert to seconds and watts before you substitute.
  • Mixing up energy density (J m−3\pu{J m-3}, per volume) and specific energy (J kg−1\pu{J kg-1}, per mass). Read the unit you are given before deciding to use a volume or a mass.
  • Saying wasted energy is “lost” or “used up”. Say where it goes: it is dissipated, mostly as thermal energy in the surroundings, for example by friction and air resistance.

Exam tips

  • “Calculate” or “determine” a power: write the equation, substitute in W, J, s and N, then give the answer with its unit. In multi-step questions keep full values and round only at the end.
  • When you are given the efficiency and the useful output, divide by η\eta to find the input. Check that the input you get is bigger than the output.
  • “Suggest” or “explain” a choice of fuel: name the quantity (energy density or specific energy), compare the values, and link it to the limit that matters, the volume of the tank or the mass the vehicle can carry.
  • In Paper 1A, check that a power option reduces to J s−1\pu{J s-1}, as FvFv and mght\frac{mgh}{t} do. A unit check rules out wrong options fast.

Key takeaways

In bookletP=ΔWΔt=FvP = \frac{\Delta W}{\Delta t} = Fv
Learn thisPower is the rate of doing work or transferring energy, in watts: 1 W=1 J s−1\pu{1 W} = \pu{1 J s-1}. In P=FvP = Fv, FF is the force along the motion; at constant velocity the driving force equals the total resistive force.
In bookletη=useful work outtotal work in=useful power outtotal power in\eta = \frac{\text{useful work out}}{\text{total work in}} = \frac{\text{useful power out}}{\text{total power in}}
Learn thisEfficiency has no unit and is always less than 1 for a real machine. Wasted energy is dissipated, mostly as thermal energy: in moving machines, through work done against friction and other resistive forces.
Learn thisEnergy density = energy released per unit volume of fuel, in J m−3\pu{J m-3}. Specific energy = energy released per unit mass, in J kg−1\pu{J kg-1}. Energy density = specific energy ×\times density.

Practise this

62 past-paper questions on Work, energy and power in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Also: Energy sources, production and transmission (33)

Practise Work, energy and power →