2.6 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Greenhouse gases and the greenhouse effect

In a minute

such as carbon dioxide and methane let most sunlight through, but absorb the that Earth's surface gives off. They re-emit it in all directions, so part comes back down and the surface stays warmer: the . Human activities, above all burning fossil fuels, add more of these gases and strengthen it. That is the .

You'll be able to

  • Name the four main greenhouse gases and give a natural source and a human source of each.
  • Explain how a greenhouse gas molecule absorbs infrared using its energy levels, and why it re-emits radiation in all directions.
  • Explain the greenhouse effect with both the resonance model and the energy-level model, and link them with E=hfE = hf.
  • Explain the enhanced greenhouse effect, name burning fossil fuels as its primary cause, and estimate the temperature rise with an energy balance.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
On the , which region has wavelengths just longer than those of red light?
Check yourself
Calculate the energy of a of frequency 5.0×1014 Hz5.0 \times 10^{14}\ \text{Hz}, in joules to 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A planet's surface starts to absorb more radiation power than it emits. What happens next?

Revise first: 2.3 Conduction and convection, 2.4 Thermal radiation and black bodies, 2.5 Emissivity, albedo and Earth's energy balance, 3.3 Travelling waves, 3.8 Resonance and damping and 5.2 Atomic spectra and energy levels

The main greenhouse gases

The Sun's surface is at about 5800 K, so by its peaks near 500 nm, in the visible.

Earth's surface is far cooler, so it radiates mostly : longer than red light, from about 700 nm to 1 mm.

Nitrogen and oxygen, most of the air, are not greenhouse gases. The four main ones are water vapour (HX2O\ce{H2O}), carbon dioxide (COX2\ce{CO2}), methane (CHX4\ce{CH4}) and nitrous oxide (NX2O\ce{N2O}).

Each has natural sources and human ones. Water vapour comes naturally from evaporation; humans add a little from irrigation and burning fuels.

Carbon dioxide comes from respiration, decay and volcanoes. Humans add it by burning coal, oil and gas, and by clearing forests.

Methane comes from wetlands, where plants rot without oxygen. Humans add it from livestock, rice paddies, landfill and gas leaks.

Nitrous oxide comes from bacteria in soils and oceans. Humans add it mainly through nitrogen fertilisers.

The atmosphere lets most visible sunlight through, but greenhouse gases absorb much of the infrared coming back up. The wavelengths a gas absorbs form its .

Worked exampleEarth's surface has a mean temperature of about 288 K288\ \text{K}. Treating it as a black body, calculate the wavelength at which its emission peaks, and state the region of the electromagnetic spectrum.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use Wien's displacement law from the data booklet: λmaxT=2.9×10−3 m K\lambda_{\text{max}} T = 2.9 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m K}.
Worked exampleMethane and nitrous oxide are both greenhouse gases. For each gas, outline one natural source and one source caused by human activity.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take each gas in turn: one natural source, one human source.
Check yourself
Which of these gases is a greenhouse gas?
Check yourself
Desert sand at midday reaches 320 K320\ \text{K}. Treating it as a black body, calculate the peak wavelength of its emission in micrometres (μm\mu\text{m}), to 2 significant figures.

Absorbing infrared: molecular energy levels

An atom has only certain (5.2). So does a molecule: its atoms vibrate as the bonds stretch and bend, and each vibration's energy can take only certain values.

The gap between two vibrational levels is small, around 0.1 eV. That is the energy of an infrared , given by:

In the formula booklet
E=hfE = hf

hh is the Planck constant and ff the frequency. With c=fλc = f\lambda, E=hcλE = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda}. Both equations and hh are in the data booklet.

A molecule absorbs a photon only if its energy equals the gap ΔE\Delta E between two levels. The molecule then moves up to the higher level.

Left: two vibrational energy levels of a greenhouse gas molecule, separated by an energy gap delta E. An infrared photon with energy h f equal to delta E arrives and is absorbed, raising the molecule from the lower level to the higher level. Right: the excited molecule above Earth's surface re-emits infrared photons in all directions: up, down and sideways. Only part of the radiation heads back down to the surface. 1. absorption 2. re-emission higher vibrational level lower vibrational level ΔE infrared photon absorbed only if hf = ΔE surface part returns to the surface in all directions
Absorption needs hf=ΔEhf = \Delta E; re-emission goes in every direction.

The excited molecule soon drops back and emits an infrared photon in a random direction. So the re-emitted radiation goes out in all directions: up, sideways and back down to the surface.

Often the molecule first shares the energy with other air molecules in collisions. The warmed air then radiates infrared, again in all directions.

The greenhouse effect is natural. It raises Earth's mean surface temperature from about 255 K, below freezing, to about 288 K.

Worked exampleCarbon dioxide absorbs strongly at a wavelength of 15 μm15\ \mu\text{m}. Calculate the energy of a photon of this wavelength, in electronvolts.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Combine E=hfE = hf and c=fλc = f\lambda: E=hcλE = \dfrac{hc}{\lambda}, with hh and cc from the data booklet.
Worked exampleOutline how a greenhouse gas molecule absorbs infrared radiation emitted by Earth's surface, and how this leads to more radiation reaching the surface.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Give the condition for absorption, then where the energy goes.
Check yourself
A molecule has two vibrational levels separated by an energy ΔE\Delta E. Which infrared photon can it absorb to move between them?
Check yourself
A vibrational transition in a water molecule has an energy gap of 0.20 eV0.20\ \text{eV}. Calculate the wavelength of the photon it absorbs, in micrometres to 2 significant figures.

The resonance model

Now picture a molecule as balls (atoms) joined by springs (bonds). Like a mass on a spring, it has of vibration. For carbon dioxide and water these are about 101310^{13} to 1014 Hz10^{14}\ \text{Hz}: infrared.

The atoms carry small charges: in COX2\ce{CO2} the oxygens are slightly negative, the carbon slightly positive. The oscillating electric field of an infrared pushes them back and forth: a periodic driving force.

When the driving frequency equals a natural frequency, occurs. The amplitude grows large and the molecule absorbs energy strongly. At other frequencies it absorbs very little.

Resonance model of a carbon dioxide molecule. Left: two oxygen atoms, each slightly negative, joined by springs to a slightly positive carbon atom in the middle; the oscillating electric field of an infrared wave pushes the charged atoms back and forth. Right: graph of energy absorbed against driving frequency, with a sharp peak at the natural frequency in the infrared and almost no absorption at the much higher frequencies of visible light. model: atoms on springs O C O δ− δ+ δ− oscillating electric field of the infrared wave drives the charged atoms energy absorbed driving frequency f₀ resonance at the natural frequency (infrared) visible light: far above f₀, little absorbed
The molecule absorbs strongly only near a natural frequency f0f_0.

Visible light, around 6×1014 Hz6 \times 10^{14}\ \text{Hz}, is well above these natural frequencies. No resonance, so it mostly passes through.

The two models agree: a natural frequency f0f_0 matches an energy gap ΔE=hf0\Delta E = hf_0.

A limitation: the resonance model is classical, with energy flowing in smoothly. It cannot explain absorption in fixed amounts, one photon at a time; the energy-level model can.

Beyond the syllabus: nitrogen and oxygen molecules are two identical atoms with no separated charges, so the wave's field cannot drive them. That is why they absorb almost no infrared.

Worked exampleOne vibration of a carbon dioxide molecule has a natural frequency of 2.0×1013 Hz2.0 \times 10^{13}\ \text{Hz}. Calculate the wavelength of the radiation that drives this vibration at resonance.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. At resonance the wave's frequency equals the natural frequency: f=2.0×1013 Hzf = 2.0 \times 10^{13}\ \text{Hz}.
Worked exampleUse the resonance model to explain why carbon dioxide absorbs infrared radiation emitted by Earth's surface but lets most visible light from the Sun pass through.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Compare each radiation's frequency with the molecule's natural frequencies.
Check yourself
One vibration of a methane molecule has a natural frequency of 3.9×1013 Hz3.9 \times 10^{13}\ \text{Hz}. Calculate the wavelength that drives it at resonance, in micrometres to 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
What does the molecular energy-level model explain that the resonance model cannot?

The enhanced greenhouse effect

Since the 1800s, people have added greenhouse gases faster than natural processes remove them. Carbon dioxide has risen by about half; methane has more than doubled.

Burning fossil fuels (coal, oil and gas) is the primary cause: it releases carbon dioxide locked underground for millions of years. Clearing forests, farming and fertilisers add more.

More greenhouse gas means more of the surface's infrared is absorbed and re-radiated back down. The surface absorbs more than it emits, so it warms to a new, higher equilibrium (2.5).

Warmer air holds more water vapour, which absorbs more infrared. This feedback amplifies the warming.

Worked exampleIn a simple model, a planet's surface acts as a black body. It absorbs 168 W m−2168\ \text{W m}^{-2} of sunlight and 232 W m−2232\ \text{W m}^{-2} radiated down by the atmosphere, and loses energy only by radiation. Extra greenhouse gases raise the downward intensity from the atmosphere by 6.0 W m−26.0\ \text{W m}^{-2}. Determine the rise in the surface's equilibrium temperature.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Before: the surface radiates what it absorbs, 168+232=400 W m−2168 + 232 = 400\ \text{W m}^{-2}. So σT14=400\sigma T_1^{4} = 400, with σ\sigma from the data booklet, and T1=4005.67×10−84=289.81 KT_1 = \sqrt[4]{\dfrac{400}{5.67 \times 10^{-8}}} = 289.81\ \text{K}.
Worked exampleDistinguish between the greenhouse effect and the enhanced greenhouse effect, and identify the primary cause of the enhanced effect.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Describe the natural effect, then what humans change and why.
Check yourself
Which statement about water vapour in Earth's atmosphere is correct?
Check yourself
A planet's surface acts as a black body at 250 K250\ \text{K} in equilibrium, losing energy only by radiation. More greenhouse gas makes the atmosphere radiate an extra 5.0 W m−25.0\ \text{W m}^{-2} down to it. Calculate the new equilibrium temperature, in K to 3 significant figures.

Common mistakes

  • Writing that greenhouse gases reflect infrared or "trap heat". They absorb it and re-emit radiation; write "radiation" or "energy", not "heat".
  • Saying the re-emitted radiation goes back to the surface. It goes out in all directions; only part returns.
  • Saying greenhouse gases absorb incoming sunlight. They let most visible light through and absorb the surface's infrared.
  • Mixing up the greenhouse effect with the ozone hole, which is about ultraviolet. Nor is the greenhouse effect itself human-made: only the enhancement is.

Exam tips

  • A two-mark "outline" of absorption needs: photon energy matching a gap between molecular energy levels (or resonance at a natural frequency), then re-emission in all directions. "Back to the surface" alone is not enough.
  • "Explain" the effect of more greenhouse gas: more infrared absorbed, more re-radiated down, surface absorbs more than it emits, temperature rises to a new equilibrium.
  • Paper 1A can ask which gas is a greenhouse gas, or what mainly causes the enhanced effect: burning fossil fuels, not volcanoes or melting ice.

Key takeaways

Learn thisThe four main greenhouse gases are HX2O\ce{H2O}, COX2\ce{CO2}, CHX4\ce{CH4} and NX2O\ce{N2O}, each with natural and human sources.
Learn thisSunlight peaks in the visible and mostly passes through; Earth radiates infrared (peak near 10 μm10\ \mu\text{m}), much of which greenhouse gases absorb.
In bookletE=hfE = hf
Learn thisEnergy levels: a photon is absorbed only if hfhf equals a gap between vibrational levels; re-emission goes in all directions.
Learn thisResonance: the wave's electric field drives the molecule; it absorbs strongly at a natural frequency f0f_0, where ΔE=hf0\Delta E = hf_0.
Learn thisThe natural greenhouse effect warms Earth from about 255 K to 288 K. The enhanced effect is extra human-caused warming; burning fossil fuels is the primary cause.

Practise this

27 past-paper questions on Greenhouse effect and climate-energy systems in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Greenhouse effect and climate-energy systems →