Acid–base indicators
In a minute
An is a weak acid, HInd, whose two forms have different colours. It changes colour at a close to its . For a , choose an indicator that changes colour in the steep part of the pH curve, ideally around the pH at the .
You'll be able to
- Write the equilibrium and the expression for an indicator, HInd, and use them to explain why its colour changes with pH.
- Explain why an indicator changes colour near its pKa, and describe universal indicator as a mixture of indicators.
- Distinguish the from the equivalence point of a titration.
- Choose an indicator for a titration from the salt formed and the indicator's pH range.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 1.8 Concentration and Avogadro's law, 3.5 Coloured transition element complexes, 5.8 Dynamic equilibrium and the equilibrium constant, 5.9 Le Châtelier's principle, 6.2 The pH scale and Kw, 6.3 Strong and weak acids, neutralization and pH curves, 6.4 pOH, Ka and Kb and 6.5 Salt solutions and pH curves
Why an indicator changes colour
In 6.3 you stopped a at the , when the indicator changed colour. Now you'll see why it changes.
HInd stands for any indicator; Ind is the rest of the molecule. Like any , it ionizes only partly.
HInd and are a that absorb different wavelengths of light. You see the of the light absorbed (data booklet, section 15).
You see the colour of whichever form is in excess. tells you which.
1. Add acid: rises, the position shifts left, and HInd's colour shows.
2. Add alkali: removes as water. The position shifts right, and the colour of shows.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Write the equilibrium, then say where it lies in acid.
- Say what hydroxide does to , which way the position shifts, and the new colour.
- Methyl orange is a weak acid: . In the acid, is high, so the position lies to the left and red HInd is in excess. Hydroxide ions react with ions, lowering . The position shifts to the right, so yellow is in excess and the solution turns yellow.
The acid dissociation constant, (6.4), is the for this ionization.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Products go on top: .
- Water is the solvent: its concentration is effectively constant and part of , so leave it out.
- goes underneath. Every coefficient is 1, so there are no powers.
Rearranged, with for , it gives the ratio of the two coloured forms.
is fixed at a given temperature. So as the pH rises, falls, the ratio grows, and the alkali colour takes over.
The end point and pKa
Halfway through the colour change, . In the expression these cancel, so . Take of both sides.
So an indicator's , the where it changes colour, is close to its . Different indicators change at different pH values.
Your eye sees one clear colour only once that form is roughly ten times the other. So the change spreads over a range of about 1 to 2 pH units that contains the pKa.
Section 18 of the data booklet gives the pKa, range and colours of common indicators.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- to 2 d.p.
- The end point is near , so about pH 8.5, in weakly alkaline solution.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Section 18: , so . At pH 8.0, .
- .
- outnumbers HInd ten to one, so it is blue, as expected above its range (6.0 to 7.6).
Universal indicator is a mixture of indicators with different pKa values. Their changes overlap, giving a series of colours from about pH 1 to 14. Match the colour to a chart to estimate pH.
Its colour changes gradually, with no sharp end point, so it is not used in titrations.
Choosing an indicator for a titration
The (6.3) is where acid and base have reacted in the mole ratio of the equation. The is what you see: the colour change.
Near the equivalence point, the pH jumps several units for a drop or two of titrant. An indicator whose range lies inside that jump changes colour in that same drop or two.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- One is set by the equation, the other by what you observe. Define each, then link them.
- The equivalence point is where the titrant added has reacted exactly with the substance in the flask, in the mole ratio of the equation. The end point is where the indicator changes colour, which you observe. With a suitable indicator the end point is very close to the equivalence point, but they are different things.
First predict the equivalence-point pH from the salt formed (, 6.5). Values are typical for about solutions.
1. Strong acid, strong base: neutral salt, pH 7. Bromothymol blue and phenol red include pH 7. The jump runs from about pH 3 to 11, so phenolphthalein, whose range lies inside it, also works.
2. Weak acid, strong base: the anion is a weak base, so pH 8 to 9. Use phenolphthalein.
3. Strong acid, weak base: the cation, such as , is a weak acid, so pH 5 to 6. Use methyl red or bromocresol green.
4. Weak acid, weak base: no steep jump, so no indicator works. Use a pH meter or conductivity meter.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Propanoic acid is weak; sodium hydroxide is strong. Is sodium propanoate solution acidic, neutral or basic?
- Match the equivalence-point pH to a range in section 18.
- The salt, sodium propanoate, contains the propanoate ion, the conjugate base of a weak acid. It reacts with water to form hydroxide ions, so the equivalence point is above 7, about pH 8 to 9. Phenolphthalein is suitable: its range, pH 8.0 to 10.0, includes this pH and lies within the steep part of the curve.
Common mistakes
- Saying every indicator changes colour at pH 7. Each changes near its own pKa.
- Treating the end point and the equivalence point as the same. One is seen; the other is set by the mole ratio.
- Naming an indicator without a reason. Link its range to the steep part of the curve around the equivalence-point pH.
- Saying alkali shifts the indicator equilibrium left. Hydroxide removes , so it shifts right.
Exam tips
- "Explain" a colour change: write the HInd equilibrium, then say what changes , which way the position shifts and which coloured form is in excess.
- "Distinguish" end point and equivalence point: define each in one sentence, then link them.
- In Paper 1A, given indicators with pKa values, choose the pKa closest to the equivalence-point pH.
Key takeaways
Practise this
55 past-paper questions on Titrations, curves and indicators in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.