5.13 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

The HR diagram, parallax and stellar radii

In a minute

A plots stars by and surface temperature, and they group into regions: the , , and . gives the distance to nearby stars, d=1pd = \frac{1}{p} in . With distance, and temperature, you can work out how big a star is.

You'll be able to

  • Sketch an HR diagram, describe the stars in each region, and read sizes from lines of equal radius.
  • Explain how a star's spectrum gives its surface temperature and its composition.
  • Use stellar parallax to find a star's distance, and convert between AU, light years and parsecs.
  • Determine a star's radius from its luminosity and surface temperature.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A star's radius doubles while its surface temperature stays the same. By what factor does its luminosity change?
Check yourself
The spectrum of star A peaks at a shorter wavelength than the spectrum of star B. What can you conclude?
Check yourself
What happens in the core of a star?

Revise first: 2.4 Thermal radiation and black bodies, 3.9 The Doppler effect, 5.2 Atomic spectra and energy levels and 5.12 Fusion and the life of stars

The Hertzsprung–Russell diagram

Plot stars by and surface temperature, and they don't scatter at random. They crowd into a few regions, each a stage in a star's life.

This is the . Both axes are usually logarithmic, because luminosities range from about 10−410^{-4} to 10610^{6} times the Sun's luminosity, L⊙L_\odot. Temperature runs backwards: hot on the left, cool on the right.

Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. Vertical axis: luminosity relative to the Sun, on a logarithmic scale from 10 to the minus 4 up to 10 to the 6. Horizontal axis: surface temperature in kelvin, on a logarithmic scale, decreasing from 40 000 K on the left to 2500 K on the right. The main sequence is a band running from hot, very luminous stars at the top left down to cool, dim stars at the bottom right, with the Sun near the middle at 5800 K and luminosity 1. Red giants are a group above and to the right of the main sequence, cool but about 100 to 1000 times the Sun's luminosity. Supergiants lie across the top of the diagram, at luminosities of about 10 to the 4 to 10 to the 6. White dwarfs are at the bottom left: hot but very dim. The instability strip is a narrow, almost vertical band at about 6000 to 7500 K, rising from the main sequence up to the supergiants. Three dashed lines of constant radius, labelled 0.01, 1 and 100 solar radii, slope down from left to right; radius increases towards the top right. 10-410-2110210410640 00020 00010 00050002500 surface temperature / K (hotter to the left) luminosity / L⊙ Sun main sequence red giants supergiants white dwarfs instability strip 100 R⊙ 1 R⊙ 0.01 R⊙
The main regions of the HR diagram. Dashed lines join stars of equal radius.

: a diagonal band from top left to bottom right, where stars spend most of their lives. They hydrogen into helium in their cores. Higher up the band, stars are more massive, hotter, more luminous and larger. The Sun is near the middle.

: above and to the right of the main sequence. Their surfaces are cool, about 3000 to 5000 K, yet they are roughly 100 to 1000 times as luminous as the Sun. A red giant has used up the hydrogen in its core and fuses helium in the core or hydrogen in a shell around it.

: across the top, at about 10410^{4} to 106 L⊙10^{6}\,L_\odot, over the whole temperature range. A supergiant is a massive star late in its life, with a radius of up to about 1000 R⊙1000\,R_\odot (R⊙R_\odot is the Sun's radius). Red supergiants sit at the top right.

: bottom left. A white dwarf is hot, often 10000 K\pu{10000 K} or more, but only about 10−410^{-4} to 10−2 L⊙10^{-2}\,L_\odot. It is the leftover core of a low-mass star, with no fusion, and it slowly cools.

Instability strip: a narrow, nearly vertical band at about 6000 to 7500 K, between the main sequence and the supergiants. Stars that cross it pulsate: their outer layers swell and shrink regularly, so their luminosity rises and falls. The details of these variable stars are not required.

Position on the diagram also tells you size. From 2.4, L=σ4πR2T4L = \sigma 4\pi R^{2} T^{4}. Two stars at the same temperature can only differ in luminosity if they differ in size.

So white dwarfs (bottom left) are the smallest stars on the diagram, about Earth-sized, and red supergiants (top right) the largest.

Worked exampleA star has a surface temperature of 15000 K\pu{15000 K} and a luminosity of 0.004 L⊙0.004\,L_\odot. Identify its region of the HR diagram, and describe its properties compared with the Sun.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Place it: hotter than the Sun (5800 K\pu{5800 K}) puts it to the left; 0.004 L⊙0.004\,L_\odot puts it far below the Sun.
Worked exampleStars A and B lie on the same line of constant radius. Star A has a surface temperature of 12000 K\pu{12000 K} and a luminosity of 250 L⊙250\,L_\odot. Star B has a surface temperature of 3000 K\pu{3000 K}. Calculate the luminosity of star B, in terms of L⊙L_\odot.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Same radius, so σ\sigma, 4π4\pi and R2R^{2} cancel in the ratio: LBLA=(TBTA)4\dfrac{L_\text{B}}{L_\text{A}} = \left(\dfrac{T_\text{B}}{T_\text{A}}\right)^{4}.
Check yourself
A star lies at the bottom left of the HR diagram. Which describes it?
Check yourself
What is true of a star in the instability strip?

What a star's spectrum tells you

A star's spectrum gives two things: its surface temperature and what its outer layers are made of.

Temperature. A star's spectrum is close to a black-body curve. The peak wavelength gives the surface temperature by , which is in the data booklet.

In the formula booklet
λmaxT=2.9×10−3 m K\lambda_\text{max} T = 2.9 \times 10^{-3}\ \text{m K}

Composition. Light from the hot interior passes through the cooler gas of the star's outer layers. Atoms in that gas absorb photons of particular wavelengths, so dark cross the continuous spectrum.

Each element absorbs its own set of wavelengths, fixed by its energy levels (5.2). Matching the dark lines to the spectra of elements measured in a laboratory shows which elements are present.

If the star moves along our line of sight, the shifts every line by the same fraction: a if it moves away. The pattern of lines is kept, so the elements can still be identified.

Worked exampleThe spectrum of a star peaks at a wavelength of 870 nm. Determine its surface temperature.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Convert the wavelength to metres: λmax=870×10−9 m\lambda_\text{max} = 870 \times 10^{-9}\ \text{m}.
Worked exampleOutline how astronomers identify the elements in a star's outer layers from its spectrum.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Say where the absorption happens and why it picks out particular wavelengths.
Check yourself
Which feature of a star's spectrum shows which elements are in its outer layers?
Check yourself
A star has a surface temperature of 18000 K\pu{18000 K}. Calculate the wavelength at which its spectrum peaks, in nm, to 2 significant figures.

Stellar parallax and the parsec

Look at a raised finger with one eye, then the other: it jumps against the background. Astronomers use the Earth's orbit in place of your two eyes.

As the Earth orbits the Sun, a nearby star seems to shift against much more distant stars, which barely move. This is . Astronomers record the star's position twice, six months apart, from opposite sides of the orbit.

Stellar parallax, not to scale. The Sun is at the bottom centre, with the Earth shown at two points of its orbit six months apart, one on each side of the Sun, each 1 AU from it. A nearby star is above the Sun, a distance d away. Lines of sight from the two Earth positions pass through the nearby star and continue to a row of very distant background stars at the top, meeting it at two different points: the star appears in different places against the background. At the nearby star, the parallax angle p is marked between the line to the Sun and the line to one Earth position. very distant background stars apparent positions nearby star Sun Earth Earth 6 months later 1 AU d p not to scale
The parallax angle pp is half the angle between the two lines of sight.

These angles are tiny, so they are measured in arc-seconds: 1 arc-second is 13600\frac{1}{3600} of a degree. Even the nearest star beyond the Sun has pp less than 1 arc-second.

In the right-angled triangle Sun–Earth–star, tan⁡p=1 AUd\tan p = \frac{1\ \text{AU}}{d}. For a tiny angle in radians, tan⁡p≈p\tan p \approx p, so d=1 AUpd = \frac{1\ \text{AU}}{p}. Distance is inversely proportional to the parallax angle.

With dd in and pp in arc-seconds, the distance is one over the angle. This equation is in the data booklet.

In the formula booklet
d (parsec)=1p (arc-second)d\,(\text{parsec}) = \frac{1}{p\,(\text{arc-second})}

The data booklet also gives the conversions: 1 pc=3.26 ly1\ \text{pc} = 3.26\ \text{ly}, 1 ly=9.46⋅1015 m1\ \text{ly} = \pu{9.46e15 m} and 1 AU=1.50⋅1011 m1\ \text{AU} = \pu{1.50e11 m}. A light year (ly) is the distance light travels in one year.

Parallax works only for fairly nearby stars. Further away, pp is too small to measure precisely, even from space.

Worked exampleThe parallax angle of a nearby star is 0.064 arc-seconds. Calculate its distance from the Earth in light years.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Distance in parsecs: d=1p=10.064=15.6 pcd = \dfrac{1}{p} = \dfrac{1}{0.064} = \pu{15.6 pc}.
Worked exampleUse the definition of the parsec to show that 1 pc1\ \text{pc} is about 3×1016 m3 \times 10^{16}\ \text{m}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. By definition, 1 AU subtends 1 arc-second at a distance of 1 pc: tan⁡(13600)∘=1 AU1 pc\tan\left(\frac{1}{3600}\right)^{\circ} = \dfrac{1\ \text{AU}}{1\ \text{pc}}.
Check yourself
Over six months, a star's position shifts by 0.046 arc-seconds against the distant stars. What is its distance from the Earth?
Check yourself
A star is 2.7⋅1017 m\pu{2.7e17 m} from the Earth. Calculate its parallax angle, in arc-seconds, to 2 significant figures.

Determining a star's radius

Almost all stars look like points, even in large telescopes, so a radius can't be measured directly. It is worked out from the luminosity and the surface temperature.

A star behaves almost like a black body, so the applies. Its surface area is that of a sphere, A=4πR2A = 4\pi R^{2}.

In the formula booklet
L=σAT4L = \sigma A T^{4}

Rearranged for the radius:

Learn this
R=L4πσT4R = \sqrt{\frac{L}{4\pi\sigma T^{4}}}

1. Surface temperature TT: from the peak wavelength of the spectrum, by Wien's law.

2. Distance dd: from the parallax angle, converted to metres.

3. Luminosity LL: measure the bb at the Earth, then use the inverse square law, L=4πd2bL = 4\pi d^{2} b. Finally substitute LL and TT to find RR.

In the formula booklet
b=L4πd2b = \frac{L}{4\pi d^{2}}

Comparing with the Sun is often quicker. Divide the law for the star by the law for the Sun, and σ\sigma and 4π4\pi cancel.

Learn this
RR⊙=LL⊙(T⊙T)2\frac{R}{R_\odot} = \sqrt{\frac{L}{L_\odot}}\left(\frac{T_\odot}{T}\right)^{2}
Worked exampleA star has a surface temperature of 0.55 T⊙0.55\,T_\odot and a luminosity of 320 L⊙320\,L_\odot, where T⊙T_\odot and L⊙L_\odot are the Sun's values. Determine its radius in terms of the Sun's radius R⊙R_\odot.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Write the ratio form: RR⊙=LL⊙(T⊙T)2\dfrac{R}{R_\odot} = \sqrt{\dfrac{L}{L_\odot}}\left(\dfrac{T_\odot}{T}\right)^{2}.
Worked exampleThe parallax angle of a star is 0.0125 arc-seconds, and its apparent brightness is 6.4⋅10−10 W m−2\pu{6.4e-10 W m-2}. Its spectrum peaks at 290 nm. Determine the radius of the star.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Distance: d=10.0125=80.0 pcd = \dfrac{1}{0.0125} = \pu{80.0 pc}, and 80.0×3.26×9.46×1015=2.467⋅1018 m80.0 \times 3.26 \times 9.46 \times 10^{15} = \pu{2.467e18 m}.
Check yourself
Star Y has 16 times the luminosity of star X and twice its surface temperature. Calculate the ratio of radii RYRX\frac{R_\text{Y}}{R_\text{X}}.
Check yourself
A star has a luminosity of 5.2⋅1030 W\pu{5.2e30 W} and a surface temperature of 3600 K. Calculate its radius, in m, to 2 significant figures.

Common mistakes

  • Writing "brighter" when you mean more luminous. Luminosity is the power a star emits; apparent brightness also depends on distance.
  • Comparing temperatures without saying which. Say surface temperature or core temperature.
  • Reading the HR temperature axis as increasing to the right. Hot stars are on the left.
  • Deciding a star is not on the main sequence from one property. Use luminosity and temperature together: a main-sequence star at that temperature would have a very different luminosity.

Exam tips

  • "Sketch" an HR diagram: luminosity on the vertical axis, temperature decreasing to the right, and labelled regions for the main sequence, red giants, supergiants and white dwarfs.
  • "Determine" or "calculate" a radius or distance: write the equation, substitute, then give the answer with its unit. A bare answer may earn no marks.
  • "Describe what is meant by" the parallax angle: half the angular shift seen six months apart, or the angle 1 AU subtends at the star. A labelled sketch of the angle also works.
  • Paper 1A ratio questions: use R∝LT2R \propto \frac{\sqrt{L}}{T^{2}} or d=1pd = \frac{1}{p} with the given factors. No constants are needed.

Key takeaways

Learn thisHR diagram: luminosity up, temperature decreasing to the right. Main sequence diagonal; red giants above right; supergiants across the top; white dwarfs bottom left; instability strip nearly vertical.
Learn thisLines of constant radius (L∝T4L \propto T^{4}) slope down to the right; radius increases towards the top right.
Learn thisSpectrum: the peak wavelength gives the surface temperature (Wien's law); the dark absorption lines give the composition.
In bookletd (parsec)=1p (arc-second)d\,(\text{parsec}) = \frac{1}{p\,(\text{arc-second})}
Learn thispp is half the shift seen six months apart. 1 pc=3.26 ly1\ \text{pc} = 3.26\ \text{ly}, 1 ly=9.46⋅1015 m1\ \text{ly} = \pu{9.46e15 m}, 1 AU=1.50⋅1011 m1\ \text{AU} = \pu{1.50e11 m}.
Learn thisR=L4πσT4R = \sqrt{\frac{L}{4\pi\sigma T^{4}}}
Learn thisRR⊙=LL⊙(T⊙T)2\frac{R}{R_\odot} = \sqrt{\frac{L}{L_\odot}}\left(\frac{T_\odot}{T}\right)^{2}

Practise this

45 past-paper questions on Stellar quantities and observations in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Stellar quantities and observations →