2.11 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

The bonding triangle and alloys

In a minute

Most bonds are not purely ionic, covalent or metallic but a blend. The maps that blend from two values, so you can predict a compound's properties. An mixes a metal with other elements, and its non-directional metallic bonding explains why it is harder and stronger.

You'll be able to

  • Describe real bonds as a blend of the three bonding models, and show this on the bonding triangle.
  • Explain a substance's properties from its bonding, and say why fixed bonding categories fall short.
  • Calculate Δχ\Delta\chi and Σχ\Sigma\chi for a binary compound and place it on the bonding triangle.
  • Predict the properties of a compound from its position on the triangle.
  • Explain why an alloy is a , and explain its properties using non-directional metallic bonding.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
Using section 9 of the data booklet, which of these elements is the most electronegative?
Check yourself
Which description fits the bonding in a metal?
Check yourself
When does potassium iodide conduct electricity?

Revise first: 1.1 The particulate nature of matter, 2.1 The ionic model, 2.4 Bond and molecular polarity, 2.5 Covalent network structures and 2.10 The metallic model

Bonding as a continuum

You have met three bonding models. In the ionic model, oppositely charged ions attract: an (2.1). In the covalent model, two atoms share a pair of electrons (2.2). In the metallic model, a lattice of cations is held together by delocalized electrons: a (2.10).

Real bonds rarely fit one model exactly. In H−Cl\ce{H-Cl}, chlorine pulls the shared pair towards itself, and that gives the bond some ionic character (2.4).

The data booklet prints the in section 17 (the van Arkel–Ketelaar triangle). Each corner is an extreme substance.

Bottom left is caesium, Cs\ce{Cs}, which holds its outer electron weakly: pure metallic bonding.

Bottom right is fluorine, FX2\ce{F2}: two identical, strongly attracting atoms share a pair evenly, so the bonding is purely covalent.

At the top is caesium fluoride, CsF\ce{CsF}. Its elements differ so much in that an electron is in effect transferred: the most ionic bonding.

The bonding triangle. Average electronegativity runs along the horizontal axis from about 0.8 to 4.0, and electronegativity difference runs up the vertical axis from 0 to about 3.2. The triangle's bottom left corner is caesium, Cs, its bottom right corner is fluorine, F2, and its top corner is caesium fluoride, CsF. The top part of the triangle is the ionic region. A small triangle in the bottom left corner is the metallic region. The bottom right part is the covalent region, labelled polar covalent higher up and covalent near the base. The border between the ionic and covalent regions is a sloping line, parallel to the left edge, running from the right edge at a difference of about 2.3 down to the edge of the metallic region at an average of about 1.8. 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 average electronegativity, Σχ electronegativity difference, Δχ ionic polar covalent covalent metallic CsF Cs F₂
The bonding triangle, redrawn from section 17 of the data booklet. The borders between regions are drawn as lines, but the bonding changes gradually across them.

Every element sits on the bottom edge, because a bond between identical atoms has no electronegativity difference. Along that edge, bonding changes from metallic on the left to covalent on the right.

Silicon and germanium sit near the metallic–covalent border. That fits their in-between behaviour: shiny, brittle solids that conduct only weakly.

Each model explains a set of properties. 1. Ionic: a lattice of ions. High melting point, brittle, conducts only when molten or dissolved.

2. Covalent: no ions or delocalized electrons, so most do not conduct. Small molecules melt easily, but a melts at a very high temperature.

3. Metallic: conducts as a solid and a liquid, and is malleable and ductile.

Worked exampleMagnesium and magnesium oxide both have high melting points, but only magnesium conducts electricity as a solid. Explain this using bonding models.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Name each bonding type: magnesium is metallic, magnesium oxide is ionic.

Fixed categories are a simplification. A substance near a border has properties of both neighbouring models.

Worked exampleAluminium chloride is made from a metal and a non-metal. Yet it turns straight from a solid to a gas at about 180 °C\pu{180 \degree C}, and when melted under pressure it barely conducts electricity. Use section 9 of the data booklet to explain why calling its bonding "ionic" shows a limitation of discrete bonding categories.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Section 9: aluminium 1.61.6, chlorine 3.23.2. The difference is 1.61.6 and the average is 2.42.4, on the ionic–polar covalent border.
Check yourself
Which substance sits at the top corner of the bonding triangle?
Check yourself
Why does every element lie on the bottom edge of the bonding triangle?

Placing a compound on the triangle

To place a binary compound (two elements, aa and bb) on the triangle, you need two numbers, both from the electronegativities in section 9 of the data booklet.

Learn this
Δχ=∣χa−χb∣\Delta\chi = \lvert \chi_a - \chi_b \rvert

The electronegativity difference, Δχ\Delta\chi, goes up the vertical axis. The higher a point, the more ionic the bonding.

Learn this
Σχ=χa+χb2\Sigma\chi = \frac{\chi_a + \chi_b}{2}

The average electronegativity, which the booklet writes Σχ\Sigma\chi, goes along the horizontal axis. When Δχ\Delta\chi is small, a low average means both atoms hold electrons weakly (metallic), and a high one means both hold them strongly (covalent).

Both formulas are printed beside the triangle in section 17, and its axis labels show which value goes on which axis.

Go across to Σχ\Sigma\chi, then up to Δχ\Delta\chi, mark the point and read the region.

The booklet also shows a rough percentage ionic character beside each height. Calculating it is not required.

Worked exampleDetermine the position of calcium chloride, CaClX2\ce{CaCl2}, on the bonding triangle, and predict whether it conducts electricity as a solid.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Section 9: calcium 1.01.0, chlorine 3.23.2.

The triangle gives the bonding type, not the structure. A covalent substance can be small molecules (low melting point) or a network (very high), and graphite is a network that conducts (2.5).

The period 3 oxides show the whole continuum. Across the period, the element's electronegativity rises towards oxygen's, so Δχ\Delta\chi falls and the points move from ionic to covalent.

The bonding triangle with the six period 3 oxides plotted. Sodium oxide, at an average electronegativity of 2.15 and a difference of 2.5, and magnesium oxide, at 2.35 and 2.1, sit well inside the ionic region. Aluminium oxide, at 2.5 and 1.8, sits right on the border between the ionic and covalent regions. Silicon dioxide, at 2.65 and 1.5, phosphorus(V) oxide, P4O10, at 2.8 and 1.2, and sulfur trioxide, at 3.0 and 0.8, sit in the covalent region. The points fall on a straight line running down to the right, from ionic to covalent. 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 average electronegativity, Σχ electronegativity difference, Δχ ionic covalent metallic Na₂O MgO Al₂O₃ SiO₂ P₄O₁₀ SO₃
The period 3 oxides run from ionic (NaX2O\ce{Na2O}, MgO\ce{MgO}) through the border (AlX2OX3\ce{Al2O3}) to covalent (SiOX2\ce{SiO2}, PX4OX10\ce{P4O10}, SOX3\ce{SO3}).

Sodium and magnesium oxides are ionic lattices with high melting points. Aluminium oxide also melts high, but its bonding is partly covalent.

Silicon dioxide is a covalent network with a very high melting point. Phosphorus(V) oxide and sulfur trioxide are molecular and melt far lower. More period 3 trends are in 3.1.

Worked examplePhosphorus trichloride, PClX3\ce{PCl3}, is made of small molecules. Use its position on the bonding triangle to predict its melting point and electrical conductivity, giving reasons.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Section 9: phosphorus 2.22.2, chlorine 3.23.2. Δχ=1.0\Delta\chi = 1.0 and Σχ=2.7\Sigma\chi = 2.7.
Check yourself
Boron nitride, BN\ce{BN}, is a hard binary compound. Calculate its average electronegativity, Σχ\Sigma\chi, using section 9. Give 2 decimal places.
Check yourself
A substance of magnesium and zinc has Δχ=0.3\Delta\chi = 0.3. Nitrogen trichloride has Δχ=0.2\Delta\chi = 0.2. Which value tells you that their bonding types are different?
Check yourself
A binary compound has Σχ=2.2\Sigma\chi = 2.2 and Δχ=2.4\Delta\chi = 2.4. Which property do you predict?

Alloys

Examples: brass (copper and zinc), bronze (copper and tin), steel (iron and carbon) and stainless steel (iron, chromium, nickel and carbon). You needn't learn them.

An is a mixture, not a compound. Brass can have a range of copper-to-zinc ratios, so it has no fixed composition and no formula.

Every atom in an alloy is held by the same metallic bonding, so an alloy still conducts electricity and heat.

So atoms of another element can replace some metal atoms, or fit into the gaps, and still be bonded.

In a pure metal, identical cations sit in regular layers. A force slides one layer over the next and the bonding holds, so metals are malleable.

Two side-by-side diagrams of metal cations in layers. Left, a pure metal: four rows of identical cations packed in regular layers, with a dashed line between the second and third rows and an arrow showing the top layers sliding over the ones below when a force is applied. Labelled: pure metal, layers slide easily. Right, an alloy: the same rows, but three larger atoms of a second element are scattered through them, so the rows are no longer flat. The force arrow is crossed out. Labelled: alloy, layers slide less easily. pure metal: layers slide easily alloy: layers slide less easily force force
Atoms of a different size break up the regular layers, so a force can't slide them as easily.

Alloys can improve other properties too: stainless steel resists corrosion, for example.

Worked exampleBronze, an alloy of copper and tin, is harder than pure copper. Tin atoms are larger than copper atoms. Explain why bronze is harder, in terms of its structure and bonding.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Bonding: non-directional metallic bonding, so tin atoms fit into the copper lattice.
Worked exampleBrass is described as a mixture rather than a compound. Explain why.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. A compound always has a fixed ratio of elements, and so a formula.
Check yourself
Why can atoms of a second element join a metal's lattice and still be held in place?
Check yourself
Steel is harder than pure iron. Which is the best explanation?

Common mistakes

  • Placing a substance from Δχ\Delta\chi alone. A small difference can mean metallic or covalent bonding, so use the average electronegativity too.
  • Calling an alloy a compound. It has no fixed composition and no formula, so it is a mixture.
  • Explaining an alloy's hardness with "stronger bonds". Say that atoms of a different size disrupt the layers, so they slide less easily.
  • Describing a metal as positive nuclei in a sea of electrons. The lattice is made of cations (positive ions), not bare nuclei.

Exam tips

  • "Determine" a position on the triangle: quote both electronegativities from section 9, show Δχ\Delta\chi and Σχ\Sigma\chi, then name the region.
  • "Predict" properties: name the bonding type first, then link each property to it.
  • "Explain" why an alloy is harder than the pure metal in three linked steps: atoms of a different size, disrupted layers, layers slide less easily.
  • In Paper 1A, never judge the bonding from "metal plus non-metal" alone: work out both values.

Key takeaways

Learn thisBonding is a continuum. The bonding triangle (data booklet, section 17) has metallic (Cs\ce{Cs}), covalent (FX2\ce{F2}) and ionic (CsF\ce{CsF}) corners.
Learn thisΔχ=∣χa−χb∣\Delta\chi = \lvert \chi_a - \chi_b \rvert
Learn thisΣχ=χa+χb2\Sigma\chi = \frac{\chi_a + \chi_b}{2}
Learn thisAcross: average Σχ\Sigma\chi. Up: difference Δχ\Delta\chi. Large Δχ\Delta\chi is ionic; small Δχ\Delta\chi is metallic with a low average and covalent with a high one.
Learn thisThe triangle gives the type of bonding, not the structure: a covalent substance can be molecular (low melting point) or a network (very high).
Learn thisAn alloy is a mixture of a metal with other metals or non-metals. It has no fixed composition, so it is not a compound.
Learn thisMetallic bonding is non-directional, so other atoms fit into the lattice. Different-sized atoms disrupt the layers, so alloys are usually harder and stronger than the pure metal.

Practise this

97 past-paper questions on Polymers, materials, alloys and nanotechnology in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Polymers, materials, alloys and nanotechnology →