2.4 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Bond and molecular polarity

In a minute

Atoms pull on shared electrons with different strengths. When two bonded atoms differ in , the bond is polar: one end is slightly negative and the other slightly positive. A molecule is a only if its bond dipoles do not cancel, and that depends on its shape.

You'll be able to

  • Use electronegativity values from the data booklet to deduce whether a is polar, and which atom is δ−\delta^{-}.
  • Show a bond dipole with or with a dipole arrow.
  • Explain how and together decide whether a molecule has a net .
  • Deduce whether a molecule or ion has a net dipole, including species whose bond dipoles cancel.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
What holds the ions together in an ?
Check yourself
In the of NFX3\ce{NF3}, nitrogen forms a single to each fluorine atom. How many are on the nitrogen atom?
Check yourself
In PBrX3\ce{PBr3}, phosphorus has three bonding pairs and one lone pair. What is its molecular geometry?

Revise first: 2.1 The ionic model, 2.2 Covalent bonds and Lewis formulas and 2.3 Shapes of molecules (VSEPR)

Electronegativity and polar bonds

In a , two nuclei share a pair of electrons. In ClX2\ce{Cl2} the two atoms are identical, so they pull equally and the pair sits midway between them.

Two different atoms pull with different strengths, like an uneven tug of war. The stronger atom draws the shared pair towards itself. How strongly an atom pulls is its .

Electronegativity has no units. The data booklet (section 9) gives values from 0.7 for francium up to 4.0 for fluorine. Fluorine is followed by oxygen (3.4), chlorine (3.2), then nitrogen and bromine (3.0).

Electronegativity rises across a period: the nuclear charge grows while the bonding pair stays in the same shell. It falls down a group: the bonding pair sits in a shell further from the nucleus, with more shielding. You meet these trends again in 3.1.

So comes from the electronegativity difference. We write it Δχ\Delta\chi (χ\chi, the Greek letter chi, stands for electronegativity).

The symbol δ\delta (delta) means a small amount. A partial charge is less than the full charge on an ion, because no electron has been transferred.

Two ways to show the polar H–Cl bond: partial charges, delta plus on hydrogen and delta minus on chlorine, or a dipole arrow with a crossed tail at hydrogen pointing towards chlorine H Cl δ+ δ− partial charges H Cl dipole arrow points to the δ− end 2.2 3.2 electronegativity
Two ways to show the same bond dipole in H−Cl\ce{H-Cl}. The crossed tail of the arrow looks like a plus sign at the δ+\delta^{+} end.

You can show a bond dipole in either way. Partial charges go above the atoms. A dipole arrow points along the bond towards the δ−\delta^{-} atom.

Worked exampleOxygen difluoride, OFX2\ce{OF2}, contains two O−F\ce{O-F} bonds. Use data booklet values to calculate Δχ\Delta\chi for the O−F\ce{O-F} bond, and deduce which atom carries the partial negative charge.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Look up the values (data booklet, section 9): oxygen 3.4, fluorine 4.0.
Worked exampleUse electronegativity values to explain why the N−H\ce{N-H} bond is polar but the P−H\ce{P-H} bond is not.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Values: nitrogen 3.0, phosphorus 2.2, hydrogen 2.2.

A bigger Δχ\Delta\chi means more ionic character. In NaF\ce{NaF}, Δχ=3.1\Delta\chi = 3.1: the electron is in effect transferred and an forms (2.1). Bonding is a continuum, which 2.11 maps onto the bonding triangle.

So a compound with very polar covalent bonds can behave a little like an ionic one. Hydrogen chloride, for example, dissolves well in water and forms ions there.

Check yourself
Use the data booklet to decide which bond is the most polar.
Check yourself
Which atom carries the partial negative charge in an Si−H\ce{Si-H} bond in silane, SiHX4\ce{SiH4}?

Polar and nonpolar molecules

A molecule with one bond is polar if that bond is polar. HCl\ce{HCl} is a polar molecule, but ClX2\ce{Cl2} is not.

With several bonds, each polar bond has its own bond dipole. Picture each one as a rope pulling on the central atom. Equal ropes pulling in balanced directions go nowhere.

Add the bond dipoles as vectors, taking account of their directions. What is left over is the molecule's net .

Bond dipoles in four molecules. Carbon dioxide (linear) and boron trifluoride (trigonal planar): the bond dipoles cancel, so there is no net dipole. Water (bent) and ammonia (trigonal pyramidal): the bond dipoles do not cancel and leave a net dipole pointing towards the oxygen or nitrogen atom bond dipoles cancel: nonpolar bond dipoles do not cancel: polar O O C CO₂, linear no net dipole F F F B BF₃, trigonal planar no net dipole H H O net H₂O, bent net dipole towards O H H H N net NH₃, trigonal pyramidal net dipole towards N
Symmetric shapes cancel the bond dipoles. Lone pairs on the central atom bend the molecule, so the dipoles add up instead.

1. No on the central atom and identical outer atoms: linear, trigonal planar or tetrahedral. The dipoles cancel, so the molecule is nonpolar, even though its bonds are polar.

2. With polar bonds and up to four electron domains, lone pairs on the central atom give a bent or trigonal pyramidal shape. The dipoles all lean one way, so the molecule is polar.

3. Different outer atoms give bond dipoles of different sizes. In a tetrahedral molecule such as CHX2FX2\ce{CH2F2}, they no longer balance, so it is polar.

The same reasoning works for ions. In NHX4X+\ce{NH4^+}, four identical N−H\ce{N-H} dipoles point to the corners of a tetrahedron and cancel, so the ion has no net dipole.

Worked exampleSilicon tetrachloride, SiClX4\ce{SiCl4}, is a tetrahedral molecule. Use electronegativity values to deduce whether its bonds are polar and whether the molecule is polar. Explain your answer.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Bonds: chlorine 3.2, silicon 1.9, so Δχ=1.3\Delta\chi = 1.3. Each bond is polar, chlorine δ−\delta^{-}.
Worked exampleBoron trifluoride, BFX3\ce{BF3}, and nitrogen trifluoride, NFX3\ce{NF3}, each have three bonds to fluorine. Explain why BFX3\ce{BF3} is nonpolar but NFX3\ce{NF3} is polar.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Bonds: fluorine (4.0) is more electronegative than boron (2.0) and nitrogen (3.0). All six bonds are polar, fluorine δ−\delta^{-}.
Check yourself
Which molecule is polar?
Check yourself
Which species has no net dipole moment?
Check yourself
Tetrafluoromethane, CFX4\ce{CF4}, is nonpolar, but trifluoromethane, CHFX3\ce{CHF3}, is polar. Both are tetrahedral. Why is CHFX3\ce{CHF3} polar?

Common mistakes

  • Deciding a molecule is polar from its bonds alone. CClX4\ce{CCl4} and COX2\ce{CO2} have polar bonds but no net dipole: always check the shape too.
  • Putting δ+\delta^{+} on hydrogen without looking. Compare the two data booklet values every time; hydrogen is δ−\delta^{-} next to silicon or boron.
  • Drawing the dipole arrow the wrong way round. It points towards the more electronegative, δ−\delta^{-} atom, with the crossed tail at the δ+\delta^{+} end.
  • Leaving the lone pair off the central atom. Without it, NFX3\ce{NF3} looks trigonal planar and you wrongly decide its dipoles cancel.

Exam tips

  • To deduce a bond's polarity, quote both electronegativity values from the data booklet and say which atom is δ−\delta^{-}.
  • To explain whether a molecule is polar, give three things: the bonds are polar (with the reason), the name of the shape, and whether the bond dipoles cancel.
  • In Paper 1A, work out the shape of every option before judging polarity. A lone pair on the central atom, or mixed outer atoms, is the usual sign of a polar molecule.

Key takeaways

Learn thisElectronegativity: how strongly an atom attracts the shared pair in a covalent bond. It rises across a period and falls down a group; fluorine is highest (4.0).
Learn thisDifferent electronegativities give a polar bond. The more electronegative atom is δ−\delta^{-}, and a larger Δχ\Delta\chi means a more polar bond.
Learn thisShow a bond dipole with δ+\delta^{+} and δ−\delta^{-}, or with an arrow pointing towards the δ−\delta^{-} end.
Learn thisA polar molecule needs polar bonds and a shape in which the bond dipoles do not cancel.
Learn thisNo lone pairs on the central atom and identical outer atoms (linear, trigonal planar, tetrahedral): the dipoles cancel and the molecule is nonpolar. Lone pairs on the central atom, or different outer atoms, usually leave a net dipole.

Practise this

161 past-paper questions on Lewis structures, VSEPR, hybridization, formal charge and resonance in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Lewis structures, VSEPR, hybridization, formal charge and resonance →