6.20 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Electrophilic substitution of benzene

In a minute

Benzene's ring of attracts , but benzene does not add them as alkenes do. It undergoes : an electrophile replaces a hydrogen atom, so the stable ring survives. The mechanism has two steps, through a intermediate.

You'll be able to

  • Explain why benzene reacts with electrophiles by substitution, not addition.
  • Draw and explain the two-step mechanism for benzene and an electrophile EX+\ce{E^+}, with and the intermediate.
  • Describe the acid–base role of nitric acid in the nitrating mixture that makes NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
How many electrons are delocalized in one benzene ring?
Check yourself
What does an electrophile do when it reacts?
Check yourself
How many bonds does the positive carbon in a carbocation have?

Revise first: 2.5 Covalent network structures, 2.8 Resonance, expanded octets and formal charge, 6.15 Radicals, 6.16 Nucleophiles and electrophiles, 6.17 Lewis acids and bases, and complex ions and 6.18 Nucleophilic substitution mechanisms

Why benzene substitutes rather than adds

In 2.8 you met benzene, CX6HX6\ce{C6H6}, the simplest . It is a flat ring of six carbons, each bonded to one hydrogen atom.

Its real structure is a hybrid of two . Six electrons are shared by all six carbons, above and below the ring. So we draw benzene as a hexagon with a circle.

This cloud of negative charge attracts an : a species that accepts an electron pair. Here it is a positive ion, written EX+\ce{E^+}.

An alkene adds an electrophile across its C=C\ce{C=C} bond (6.19). Benzene's formula looks just as unsaturated, yet it does not usually add. Addition would use up ring electrons for good, and the delocalized ring is far more stable than three separate C=C\ce{C=C} bonds.

It is a because one atom swaps for another: CX6HX6+EX+→CX6HX5E+HX+\ce{C6H6 + E^+ -> C6H5E + H^+}. The product still has its ring of six delocalized electrons.

Worked exampleCyclohexene, CX6HX10\ce{C6H10}, reacts with electrophiles by addition. Explain why benzene, CX6HX6\ce{C6H6}, reacts with electrophiles by substitution instead.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Start from the structure: what is special about benzene's electrons?
Worked exampleWith an aluminium chloride catalyst, benzene reacts with chlorine: CX6HX6(l)+ClX2(g)→CX6HX5Cl(l)+HCl(g)\ce{C6H6(l) + Cl2(g) -> C6H5Cl(l) + HCl(g)}. Calculate ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus, in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}, using section 13 of the data booklet.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. ΔHf⊖\Delta H_\text{f}^\ominus values (data booklet, section 13), in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}: CX6HX6(l)\ce{C6H6(l)} +49+49, CX6HX5Cl(l)\ce{C6H5Cl(l)} +11+11, HCl(g)\ce{HCl(g)} −92-92. ClX2(g)\ce{Cl2(g)} is an element, so 00.
Check yourself
When benzene reacts with an electrophile, what does the electrophile replace?
Check yourself
If bromine added across benzene's ring, as it does to an alkene, what would be lost?

The mechanism with $\ce{E^+}$

You need to draw how a positive electrophile, EX+\ce{E^+}, attacks benzene. It happens in two steps.

Step 1. A starts at the circle and ends at E. Two of the six delocalized electrons form a new C–E bond.

That carbon now has four single bonds: to E, to H and to two ring carbons. It drops out of the delocalized system. The other four electrons spread over five carbons, which share the positive charge.

This positive ion is a intermediate. Draw its ring as a broken circle (a horseshoe) over five carbons, open towards the carbon with H and E, and put a + inside.

Step 2. A curly arrow goes from the C–H bond into the ring. Those two electrons rejoin the delocalized system, which is complete again, and HX+\ce{H^+} leaves.

Electrophilic substitution of benzene by an electrophile E plus, in two steps: the ring attacks E plus to give a carbocation intermediate, then the C–H bond breaks to restore the ring and release H plus E + step 1 slow H E + [ ] step 2 fast E + H + benzene carbocation intermediate (broken ring over five carbons) substituted product Curly arrows: step 1 from the ring to E⁺; step 2 from the C–H bond back into the ring
Electrophilic substitution of benzene by EX+\ce{E^+}.

Step 1 is slow, because the ring loses its delocalization. Step 2 is fast, because the stable ring comes back.

In step 1 benzene donates an electron pair, so it acts as a . EX+\ce{E^+} accepts the pair, so it acts as a (6.17).

Worked exampleBenzene reacts with the nitronium ion, NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}, to give nitrobenzene, CX6HX5NOX2\ce{C6H5NO2}. Describe the mechanism, including the curly arrows and the intermediate.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Here E is the NOX2\ce{NO2} group, and the ring bonds to its nitrogen atom.
Worked exampleBenzene reacts with the electrophile BrX+\ce{Br^+}. Write an equation for step 1, giving the formula of the intermediate.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. In step 1 nothing leaves: BrX+\ce{Br^+} bonds to the ring, and all six H atoms are still there.
Check yourself
Where does the curly arrow in step 2 start?
Check yourself
How many delocalized electrons does the carbocation intermediate have?
Check yourself
In step 1, what is benzene's role?

Where the electrophile comes from

You won't be asked for the mechanism that forms EX+\ce{E^+}. This section shows it so the mechanism makes sense, and because the acid–base roles in it can still be asked.

To nitrate benzene, it is warmed with concentrated HNOX3\ce{HNO3} and concentrated HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4}. Sulfuric acid is the stronger acid, so it gives a proton to nitric acid.

So here HNOX3\ce{HNO3} acts as a (6.1). The protonated nitric acid, HX2NOX3X+\ce{H2NO3^+}, then loses water, leaving NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}.

Worked exampleWrite one overall equation for making NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+} from nitric and sulfuric acids, giving HX3OX+\ce{H3O^+} and HSOX4X−\ce{HSO4^-} as the other products.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Proton transfer: HNOX3+HX2SOX4→HX2NOX3X++HSOX4X−\ce{HNO3 + H2SO4 -> H2NO3^+ + HSO4^-}.
Worked exampleOutline the acid–base role of nitric acid in the nitrating mixture, and how this produces the electrophile.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Decide which acid is stronger, and so which one donates the proton.

The HX+\ce{H^+} lost in step 2 joins HSOX4X−\ce{HSO4^-}, so the sulfuric acid is made again. It acts as a catalyst.

For halogenation, a halogen carrier such as FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3} or AlClX3\ce{AlCl3} is used. It accepts a lone pair from the halogen molecule, and the halogen–halogen bond breaks heterolytically: BrX2+FeBrX3→BrX++FeBrX4X−\ce{Br2 + FeBr3 -> Br^+ + FeBr4^-}.

Check yourself
In BrX2+FeBrX3→BrX++FeBrX4X−\ce{Br2 + FeBr3 -> Br^+ + FeBr4^-}, what is the role of FeBrX3\ce{FeBr3}?
Check yourself
In nitration, the HX+\ce{H^+} lost in step 2 reacts with HSOX4X−\ce{HSO4^-}. What does this show about sulfuric acid?

Common mistakes

  • Giving an addition product, such as a dibromo compound, for benzene. Benzene substitutes: one H is replaced and the ring stays.
  • Closing the circle in the intermediate, or leaving out its + charge. Draw a broken ring over five carbons with + inside.
  • Starting the step 2 arrow at the H atom or the + sign. It starts at the C–H bond and ends in the ring.
  • Forgetting HX+\ce{H^+} as a product. Charge must balance: EX+\ce{E^+} in, HX+\ce{H^+} out.
  • Treating ClX2\ce{Cl2} or a chlorine radical as the species that attacks benzene. It is a cation, such as ClX+\ce{Cl^+}, that accepts the pair.

Exam tips

  • "Describe and explain" the mechanism: marks go to the arrow from the ring to EX+\ce{E^+}, the intermediate with a broken ring and a + charge, the arrow from C–H into the ring, and the products including HX+\ce{H^+}.
  • "Explain" substitution rather than addition: name the delocalized electrons and their stability, then say addition would disrupt them while substitution keeps them.
  • Paper 1A may ask which species substitutes into benzene: choose the cation, such as ClX+\ce{Cl^+} or NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}, not ClX2\ce{Cl2}, a radical or an anion. An electrophile in general is any electron-pair acceptor, and it can be neutral.

Key takeaways

Learn thisBenzene's delocalized ring attracts electrophiles. It undergoes substitution, not addition, because substitution keeps the stable ring.
Learn thisStep 1: arrow from the ring to EX+\ce{E^+}; carbocation intermediate with a broken ring over five carbons and a + inside.
Learn thisStep 2: arrow from C–H into the ring; HX+\ce{H^+} lost, ring restored. Overall CX6HX6+EX+→CX6HX5E+HX+\ce{C6H6 + E^+ -> C6H5E + H^+}.
Learn thisNitration: concentrated HNOX3\ce{HNO3} and HX2SOX4\ce{H2SO4} give NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}; nitric acid acts as a Brønsted–Lowry base.

Practise this

114 past-paper questions on Synthesis and mechanisms in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Synthesis and mechanisms →