6.18 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Nucleophilic substitution mechanisms

In a minute

A swaps its halogen for a in one of two ways. Primary ones use the one-step . Tertiary ones use the two-step , through a . Iodoalkanes react fastest because the C–I bond is the weakest.

You'll be able to

  • Draw the SN2 mechanism with and the , and explain .
  • Draw the two-step SN1 mechanism for a tertiary halogenoalkane.
  • Tell SN1 from SN2 by rate equation and energy profile, and know that secondary halogenoalkanes react both ways.
  • Predict and explain the relative rates of chloro-, bromo- and iodoalkanes.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
How is 2-iodopropane, CHX3CHICHX3\ce{CH3CHICH3}, classified?
Check yourself
Which species can act as a nucleophile?
Check yourself
For rate=k[A][B]\text{rate} = k[\ce{A}][\ce{B}], you triple [A][\ce{A}] and keep [B][\ce{B}] the same. By what factor does the rate increase?

Revise first: 3.6 Organic formulas, functional groups and homologous series, 3.7 Naming organic compounds and structural isomers, 3.8 Stereoisomers, 5.4 Activation energy and catalysts, 5.5 Reaction mechanisms and the rate-determining step, 5.6 Rate equations and orders of reaction and 6.16 Nucleophiles and electrophiles

The SN2 mechanism: primary halogenoalkanes

In (6.16), a nucleophile replaces the halogen, which leaves as a halide ion: the . The carbon bonded to the halogen is δ+.

S is substitution, N is nucleophilic and 2 is the : two species collide in the one step.

Primary halogenoalkanes react this way. The nucleophile attacks from the side opposite the halogen, which is open: only one alkyl group and two small H atoms are nearby.

SN2 mechanism for bromoethane and the hydroxide ion: one step through a transition state, with inversion of the three groups on carbon HO − C Br H3C H H δ+ δ− HO C Br CH3 H H − HO C CH3 H H + Br − bromoethane + hydroxide ion transition state ethanol + bromide ion
SN2 for bromoethane. The three groups on carbon flip like an umbrella in the wind.

To draw it: one arrow from a lone pair on the nucleophile to the carbon, and one from the C–X bond to X. The transition state goes in square brackets, with dashed partial bonds 180° apart. With an anion such as OHX−\ce{OH^-} as the nucleophile, it carries an overall negative charge.

Worked example1-Iodopropane reacts with aqueous hydroxide ions by SN2. Outline the curly arrows, then write the ionic equation.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. It is primary, so SN2 fits.

The flip shows only at a , so not at a primary carbon (it has two H atoms). One gives one enantiomer of product, so the product shows too. One giving one particular product makes SN2 stereospecific.

Worked exampleA single enantiomer of 2-bromobutane reacts with hydroxide ions by SN2. Explain why the butan-2-ol formed is a single enantiomer.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Carbon 2 carries H, CHX3\ce{CH3}, CX2HX5\ce{C2H5} and Br, so it is chiral.
Check yourself
Which describes the SN2 transition state for OHX−\ce{OH^-} and bromoethane?

The SN1 mechanism: tertiary halogenoalkanes

In 2-bromo-2-methylpropane, three methyl groups crowd the side opposite the bromine. This steric hindrance blocks SN2. Instead the C–Br bond breaks on its own, by .

The 1 means only the halogenoalkane is in the rate-determining step. The carbocation is a .

SN1 mechanism for 2-bromo-2-methylpropane and the hydroxide ion: a slow step that forms a carbocation, then a fast step in which the hydroxide ion bonds to it Step 1 (slow, rate-determining): the C–Br bond breaks Step 2 (fast): the hydroxide ion bonds to the carbocation C CH3 H3C CH3 Br C + CH3 H3C CH3 + Br − slow 2-bromo-2-methylpropane tertiary carbocation (trigonal planar) C + CH3 H3C CH3 OH − C CH3 H3C CH3 OH fast 2-methylpropan-2-ol
SN1 for 2-bromo-2-methylpropane.

A tertiary carbocation is stable enough to form: its three alkyl groups push electron density onto the positive carbon (6.19). A primary one is not, so primary halogenoalkanes use SN2.

The carbocation is trigonal planar, so the nucleophile can attack either face. SN1 is not stereospecific: a reactant that is chiral at the reacting carbon gives both enantiomers.

Worked example2-Chloro-2-methylpropane, (CHX3)X3CCl\ce{(CH3)3CCl}, is hydrolysed by SN1. Write an equation for the rate-determining step.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The slow step is heterolytic fission of C–Cl. Both electrons go to Cl.
Worked exampleExplain why 2-chloro-2-methylbutane, CHX3CHX2C(CHX3)X2Cl\ce{CH3CH2C(CH3)2Cl}, reacts with hydroxide ions by SN1, not SN2.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The carbon bonded to Cl carries CHX3\ce{CH3}, CHX3\ce{CH3} and CX2HX5\ce{C2H5}: tertiary.
Check yourself
What happens in the rate-determining step of SN1?

Telling SN1 from SN2

The shows which species are in the rate-determining step (5.5). RX is the halogenoalkane and NuX−\ce{Nu^-} the nucleophile.

Learn this
SN2: rate=k[RX][NuX−]SN1: rate=k[RX]\text{SN2: } \text{rate} = k[\text{RX}][\ce{Nu^-}] \qquad \text{SN1: } \text{rate} = k[\text{RX}]

SN2 is second order overall. SN1 is first order, and zero order in the nucleophile: changing [NuX−][\ce{Nu^-}] does not change the rate.

Worked example1-Bromopentane reacts with OHX−\ce{OH^-} by SN2, with k=2.35⋅10−3 dm3 mol−1 s−1k = \pu{2.35e-3 dm3 mol-1 s-1}. Calculate the initial rate when [CX5HX11Br]=0.0450 mol dm−3[\ce{C5H11Br}] = \pu{0.0450 mol dm-3} and [OHX−]=0.0800 mol dm−3[\ce{OH^-}] = \pu{0.0800 mol dm-3}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. rate=k[CX5HX11Br][OHX−]=(2.35×10−3)×0.0450×0.0800\text{rate} = k[\ce{C5H11Br}][\ce{OH^-}] = (2.35 \times 10^{-3}) \times 0.0450 \times 0.0800.
Check yourself
In an SN1 you halve [RX][\text{RX}] and triple [OHX−][\ce{OH^-}]. By what factor does the rate change?

The energy profiles differ too. SN2 has one hump: one transition state and one . SN1 has two humps, with the carbocation in the dip.

Energy profiles: SN2 has one hump and one transition state; SN1 has two humps with the carbocation intermediate in the dip between them, and the first hump is the higher one SN2: one step transition state reactants products Ea reaction coordinate potential energy SN1: two steps TS 1 TS 2 carbocation intermediate reactants products Ea reaction coordinate potential energy
In SN1 the first hump is higher: step 1 is rate-determining.
Worked exampleFor 2-iodo-2-methylbutane and OHX−\ce{OH^-}, doubling [OHX−][\ce{OH^-}] leaves the rate unchanged, and doubling [RX][\text{RX}] doubles it. Deduce the mechanism, and outline how its energy profile differs from SN2.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. No change with [OHX−][\ce{OH^-}]: zero order. Doubling with [RX][\text{RX}]: first order.

Secondary halogenoalkanes are in between: less crowded than tertiary, with a more stable carbocation than primary. Both mechanisms happen. So SN1 and SN2 are useful models of two extremes, which explain rate data and stereochemistry, but real reactions can lie between them.

Check yourself
Which can react with hydroxide ions by both SN1 and SN2?

The leaving group: chloro, bromo and iodo

With the same alkyl group, the rate order is iodoalkane > bromoalkane > chloroalkane. In both mechanisms the C–X bond breaks in the rate-determining step, so a weaker bond means a lower activation energy and a faster reaction.

C–X (data booklet, section 12), in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}: C–Cl 324324, C–Br 285285, C–I 228228. C–F, at 492492, hardly reacts.

Iodine is the largest atom, so its bonding pair is furthest from the nucleus: C–I is the longest, weakest bond. The large iodide ion also spreads its charge, so it is stable once it leaves.

Worked exampleUse section 12 of the data booklet to find how much more energy breaks one mole of C–Cl bonds than of C–I bonds. Hence predict whether 1-chlorobutane or 1-iodobutane is hydrolysed faster.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. C–Cl is 324 kJ mol−1\pu{324 kJ mol-1} and C–I is 228 kJ mol−1\pu{228 kJ mol-1}.
Worked exampleExplain why 2-iodo-2-methylpropane is hydrolysed faster than 2-chloro-2-methylpropane, even though C–Cl is more polar.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Both are tertiary, so both use SN1; only the halogen differs.
Check yourself
Under the same conditions, which is hydrolysed fastest by aqueous OHX−\ce{OH^-}?
Check yourself
Using section 12, by how many kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1} is C–Br stronger than C–I?

Common mistakes

  • Drawing the arrow from carbon to the nucleophile. Arrows start at an electron pair and end where it goes.
  • Missing charges or brackets on the transition state or the halide ion.
  • Drawing SN1 for a primary halogenoalkane. Primary means SN2.
  • Putting [OHX−][\ce{OH^-}] in the SN1 rate equation.

Exam tips

  • "Draw" or "explain" an SN2 mechanism: marks go to each curly arrow and to a bracketed transition state with partial bonds and the overall charge (negative for OHX−\ce{OH^-}).
  • "Deduce" from rate data: give each order, the rate equation, then SN1 or SN2.
  • "Predict and explain" rates: give RI > RBr > RCl, quote section 12 bond enthalpies and link them to activation energy.

Key takeaways

Learn thisSN2 (primary): one step; arrows from the nucleophile's lone pair to C and from C–X to X; bracketed transition state (negative with OHX−\ce{OH^-}); inversion.
Learn thisSN1 (tertiary): slow C–X heterolysis to a planar carbocation, then fast attack.
Learn thisSN2: rate=k[RX][NuX−]\text{rate} = k[\text{RX}][\ce{Nu^-}], one transition state. SN1: rate=k[RX]\text{rate} = k[\text{RX}], two transition states. Secondary: both.
Learn thisRate: RI > RBr > RCl, as the C–X bond weakens (section 12).

Practise this

114 past-paper questions on Synthesis and mechanisms in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Synthesis and mechanisms →