2.8 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Resonance, expanded octets and formal charge

In a minute

When a double bond could sit in more than one place, each drawing is a and the real species is an average, with . Atoms in period 3 and below can break the with an of five or six . picks the preferred .

You'll be able to

  • Deduce resonance structures of molecules and ions, and explain delocalization.
  • Discuss the evidence for benzene's delocalized ring.
  • Draw expanded-octet Lewis formulas and deduce their shapes with VSEPR.
  • Use formal charges to choose the preferred Lewis formula.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
In the Lewis formula of ammonia, NHX3\ce{NH3}, how many lone pairs are on the nitrogen atom?
Check yourself
What is the of boron trichloride, BClX3\ce{BCl3}?
Check yourself
Each carbon in graphite forms three bonds. Where is its fourth valence electron?

Revise first: 2.2 Covalent bonds and Lewis formulas, 2.3 Shapes of molecules (VSEPR) and 2.5 Covalent network structures

Resonance structures and delocalization

Draw the carbonate ion, COX3X2−\ce{CO3^2-}. Carbon needs a double bond to one oxygen, but any of the three could take it. Which drawing is right?

None of them alone. All three carbon–oxygen bonds in carbonate are measured to be identical, but each drawing has one short bond and two long ones.

The real species is a resonance hybrid, an average of all the . It does not flip between them. The double-bond electrons are : spread over three or more atoms, which makes the species more stable.

Three resonance structures of the carbonate ion joined by double-headed arrows, each in square brackets with a 2 minus charge. In each, carbon is bonded to three oxygens; the double bond goes to a different oxygen each time. A fourth drawing shows the resonance hybrid with three equal partial bonds and a charge of minus two thirds on each oxygen. C O O O 2− C O O O 2− C O O O 2− C O O O ⅔− ⅔− ⅔− three resonance structures resonance hybrid
The resonance structures of COX3X2−\ce{CO3^2-} and the hybrid. Only electrons move; the atoms stay put.

1. Draw one , with every lone pair and the charge.

2. Move the double bond to each other atom that could take it, moving lone pairs so every atom keeps an octet. Never move an atom.

3. Join the structures with ↔\leftrightarrow, each ion in square brackets with its charge.

The hybrid's bond order is the number of bonds shared out divided by the positions sharing them.

Worked exampleDeduce the number of resonance structures of the carbonate ion, and calculate the bond order of each carbon–oxygen bond.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Valence electrons: 4+3(6)+2=244 + 3(6) + 2 = 24. One structure has one C=O\ce{C=O} and two C−OX−\ce{C-O^-}.
Worked exampleExplain why the two carbon–oxygen bonds in the methanoate ion, HCOOX−\ce{HCOO^-}, are the same length, and compare that length with the booklet's C−O\ce{C-O} and C=O\ce{C=O} values.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. One structure has C=O\ce{C=O} and C−OX−\ce{C-O^-}; the double bond could go to either oxygen.
Check yourself
Which species has resonance structures?
Check yourself
Ozone, OX3\ce{O3}, has two resonance structures. Why is it dissociated by longer-wavelength ultraviolet than oxygen, OX2\ce{O2}?

Benzene

Benzene, CX6HX6\ce{C6H6}, is a ring of six carbons, each bonded to one hydrogen. A Lewis formula needs three C=C\ce{C=C} bonds alternating with single bonds, and there are two ways to place them: the Kekulé structures.

Two Kekulé structures of benzene drawn as hexagons with alternating single and double bonds, the double bonds in different positions, joined by a double-headed arrow. To the right, the resonance hybrid: a hexagon with a circle inside, labelled six delocalized electrons, all carbon-carbon bonds 140 picometres. Kekulé structures resonance hybrid 6 delocalized electrons all C–C bonds 140 pm
Benzene's two resonance structures and the hybrid, drawn as a circle in a hexagon.

In the hybrid, six electrons are delocalized around the ring, above and below its plane. All six carbon–carbon bonds are identical, with bond order 1.5.

Benzene is the simplest . The evidence for its structure:

1. Physical: X-ray diffraction shows a flat regular hexagon, angles 120∘120^{\circ}, with six bonds of 140 pm\pu{140 pm}. Kekulé structures predict three of 154 pm\pu{154 pm} and three of 134 pm\pu{134 pm} (data booklet, section 11).

2. Physical: adding hydrogen releases far less energy than three C=C\ce{C=C} bonds would, so benzene is more stable than a Kekulé structure. The difference is its resonance energy.

3. Chemical: benzene does not decolourize bromine water by addition, as alkenes do. Addition would destroy the stable delocalized ring, so benzene undergoes substitution instead (6.20).

4. Chemical: only one 1,2-dichlorobenzene exists. Fixed alternating bonds would give two, with C=C\ce{C=C} or C−C\ce{C-C} between the chlorinated carbons.

Worked exampleCX6HX10(l)+HX2(g)→CX6HX12(l)\ce{C6H10(l) + H2(g) -> C6H12(l)}, ΔH=−120 kJ mol−1\Delta H = \pu{-120 kJ mol-1} (cyclohexene, one C=C\ce{C=C}). CX6HX6(l)+3 HX2(g)→CX6HX12(l)\ce{C6H6(l) + 3H2(g) -> C6H12(l)}, ΔH=−208 kJ mol−1\Delta H = \pu{-208 kJ mol-1}. Calculate how much more stable benzene is than a structure with three C=C\ce{C=C} bonds.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Three C=C\ce{C=C} bonds: expect 3×(−120)=−360 kJ mol−13 \times (-120) = \pu{-360 kJ mol-1}.
Worked exampleDiscuss one piece of physical and one piece of chemical evidence that benzene does not have alternating single and double bonds.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. For each piece of evidence, say what alternating bonds would predict.
Check yourself
Which best describes the carbon–carbon bonds in benzene?
Check yourself
Only one 1,2-dichlorobenzene exists. What does this show?

Expanded octets: five and six electron domains

Nitrogen forms NClX3\ce{NCl3} but never NClX5\ce{NCl5}. Phosphorus, in the same group, forms both. In PClX5\ce{PCl5}, phosphorus has ten electrons around it.

Atoms in period 3 and below have a d sublevel in their outer shell, with room for more than four electron pairs. They are also larger, so more atoms fit around them. Period 2 atoms have only 2s and 2p: at most eight electrons, so no .

To count domains on a central atom bonded to halogens: take its valence electrons, adding one per negative charge or taking one away per positive charge. Each single bond uses one. Halve the rest for lone pairs. Domains = bonded atoms + lone pairs; then apply the .

Five domains form a trigonal bipyramid: three equatorial positions in a triangle at 120∘120^{\circ}, and two axial ones at 90∘90^{\circ} to it. Lone pairs go equatorial, where fewer domains are 90∘90^{\circ} away.

Four shapes with five electron domains, each based on a trigonal bipyramid with two axial and three equatorial positions. Phosphorus pentachloride: five chlorines, trigonal bipyramidal, angles 90, 120 and 180 degrees. Selenium tetrafluoride: one equatorial lone pair, seesaw. Bromine trifluoride: two equatorial lone pairs, T-shaped, angle slightly under 90 degrees. Triiodide ion: three equatorial lone pairs, linear, 180 degrees. Cl Cl Cl Cl Cl P PCl₅ trigonal bipyramidal 90°, 120°, 180° F F F F Se SeF₄ seesaw 1 lone pair F F F Br BrF₃ T-shaped 2 lone pairs, under 90° I I I I₃⁻ linear 3 lone pairs, 180°
Five domains with 0, 1, 2 and 3 lone pairs: trigonal bipyramidal (PClX5\ce{PCl5}), seesaw (SeFX4\ce{SeF4}), T-shaped (BrFX3\ce{BrF3}), linear (IX3X−\ce{I3^-}).

Six domains form an octahedron, all angles 90∘90^{\circ}. One lone pair gives a square pyramid. A second lone pair goes opposite the first, giving a square plane.

Three shapes with six electron domains, each based on an octahedron. Sulfur hexafluoride: six fluorines, octahedral, all angles 90 degrees. Chlorine pentafluoride: one lone pair, square pyramidal, angles slightly under 90 degrees. Xenon tetrafluoride: two lone pairs opposite each other, square planar, 90 degrees. F F F F F F S SF₆ octahedral 90° F F F F F Cl ClF₅ square pyramidal 1 lone pair, under 90° F F F F Xe XeF₄ square planar 2 lone pairs, 90°
Six domains with 0, 1 and 2 lone pairs: octahedral (SFX6\ce{SF6}), square pyramidal (ClFX5\ce{ClF5}), square planar (XeFX4\ce{XeF4}).

Lone pairs repel more than bonding pairs, so angles next to them close slightly below 90∘90^{\circ} or 120∘120^{\circ}. Lone pairs placed symmetrically, as in linear and square planar shapes, leave the angles at 180∘180^{\circ} and 90∘90^{\circ}.

Worked exampleFor chlorine trifluoride, ClFX3\ce{ClF3}, deduce the , then the , and estimate the bond angle.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Chlorine: 7 valence electrons, 3 used in bonds, 4 left: two lone pairs. Each fluorine has three lone pairs.
Worked exampleDeduce the shape of the tetrachloroiodate ion, IClX4X−\ce{ICl4^-}: give its electron domain geometry and its molecular geometry.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Iodine: 7+1=87 + 1 = 8 electrons (one for the charge). Four bonds use 4, leaving two lone pairs.
Check yourself
Tellurium is in group 16. What is the molecular geometry of TeClX4\ce{TeCl4}?
Check yourself
Why does nitrogen not form NClX5\ce{NCl5}, when phosphorus does?

Formal charge

Sometimes several Lewis formulas look reasonable: an octet or an expanded one, or atoms in a different order. Formal charge helps you choose.

Learn this
FC=(valence electrons)−12(bonding electrons)−(non-bonding electrons)\text{FC} = (\text{valence electrons}) - \tfrac{1}{2}(\text{bonding electrons}) - (\text{non-bonding electrons})

Use only the electrons around that atom. The in a species add up to its overall charge, a useful check.

Worked exampleIn carbon monoxide, carbon and oxygen share a triple bond and each has one lone pair. Calculate the formal charge on carbon.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Carbon: 4 valence electrons, 6 bonding electrons, 2 non-bonding.
Two Lewis formulas of phosphoryl chloride. In each, phosphorus is in the centre, bonded to an oxygen above and three chlorines to the left, right and below; each chlorine has three lone pairs. Structure A has a phosphorus-oxygen single bond with three lone pairs on oxygen: formal charge plus 1 on phosphorus and minus 1 on oxygen. Structure B has a phosphorus-oxygen double bond with two lone pairs on oxygen: every formal charge is zero, so B is preferred. P O Cl Cl Cl +1 −1 A: P +1, O −1 P O Cl Cl Cl 0 0 B: every atom 0 (preferred)
Two Lewis formulas of POClX3\ce{POCl3}. B has an expanded octet on phosphorus.
Worked exampleFor phosphoryl chloride, POClX3\ce{POCl3}, structure A has a P−O\ce{P-O} single bond and structure B a P=O\ce{P=O} double bond. Use formal charges to deduce which is preferred.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. A: phosphorus 5−4−0=+15 - 4 - 0 = +1; oxygen 6−1−6=−16 - 1 - 6 = -1.

Formal charge treats every bond as shared equally (purely covalent). An (3.3) gives the bonding electrons to the more electronegative atom (purely ionic). So in CO\ce{CO}, carbon's formal charge is −1-1 but its oxidation state is +2+2.

Check yourself
In the nitronium ion, NOX2X+\ce{NO2^+}, nitrogen has two double bonds and no lone pairs. Calculate its formal charge, with the sign.
Check yourself
The cyanate ion can be drawn as [O=C=N]X−\ce{[O=C=N]^-}, [O−C≡N]X−\ce{[O-C#N]^-} or [O≡C−N]X−\ce{[O#C-N]^-}. In the preferred structure, which atom has a formal charge of −1-1?

Common mistakes

  • Drawing the dashed hybrid when asked for a Lewis formula. Draw one resonance structure with every lone pair and charge.
  • Leaving out lone pairs on outer atoms: each halogen in PClX5\ce{PCl5} needs three.
  • Saying a species flips between resonance structures. It is always the hybrid.
  • Putting five-domain lone pairs axial. They go equatorial.

Exam tips

  • "Deduce" resonance structures: draw each one with lone pairs, brackets and charge, joined by ↔\leftrightarrow.
  • "Discuss" benzene: give physical and chemical evidence, each against what alternating bonds predict.
  • Paper 1A shapes: count domains first, then check which geometry the question asks for.
  • "Apply" formal charge: give the formal charge of every atom in each structure, then the choice with its reason.

Key takeaways

Learn thisResonance structures differ only in the positions of multiple bonds and lone pairs. The real species is a hybrid with delocalized electrons; bonds that are equivalent in it, such as the three in carbonate, have equal length.
Learn thisBenzene: six identical C−C\ce{C-C} bonds of 140 pm\pu{140 pm} and a delocalized ring. It is about 150 kJ mol−1\pu{150 kJ mol-1} more stable than a Kekulé structure and prefers substitution to addition.
Learn thisOnly atoms in period 3 and below can expand their octet.
Learn thisFive domains (lone pairs equatorial): trigonal bipyramidal, seesaw, T-shaped, linear. Six domains: octahedral, square pyramidal, square planar.
Learn thisFC=(valence electrons)−12(bonding electrons)−(non-bonding electrons)\text{FC} = (\text{valence electrons}) - \tfrac{1}{2}(\text{bonding electrons}) - (\text{non-bonding electrons})
Learn thisPreferred Lewis formula: formal charges closest to zero, with any negative charge on the most electronegative atom.

Practise this

161 past-paper questions on Lewis structures, VSEPR, hybridization, formal charge and resonance in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Lewis structures, VSEPR, hybridization, formal charge and resonance →