5.5 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Reaction mechanisms and the rate-determining step

In a minute

Most reactions happen in a series of : the . The slowest step, the , sets the rate. On an each step is a hump with a at its peak, and each sits in a dip. The of a step is how many particles react in it.

You'll be able to

  • Check that the steps of a mechanism add up to the overall equation, and pick out and .
  • Deduce the rate equation from the , including when it is not the first step, and evaluate proposed mechanisms against kinetic data.
  • Construct and interpret energy profiles for multistep reactions, telling from intermediates.
  • Interpret unimolecular, bimolecular and termolecular for an .
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
What is ?
Check yourself
How does a catalyst increase the rate of a reaction?
Check yourself
On the energy profile of an exothermic reaction, where are the products?

Revise first: 4.1 Measuring enthalpy changes, 5.3 Rates of reaction and collision theory and 5.4 Activation energy and catalysts

Mechanisms and elementary steps

An overall equation such as 2 HX2OX2→2 HX2O+OX2\ce{2H2O2 -> 2H2O + O2} shows what goes in and comes out, not how. Three or more particles rarely meet at the same instant with enough energy and the right orientation, so most reactions happen in a series of simpler steps.

A is a model: it is proposed to explain experimental data. Its first test is the stoichiometry. Add the and cancel anything that appears on both sides. The result must be the overall equation.

Worked exampleNitryl chloride, NOX2Cl\ce{NO2Cl}, decomposes in two steps. Step 1 (slow): NOX2Cl→NOX2+Cl\ce{NO2Cl -> NO2 + Cl}. Step 2 (fast): NOX2Cl+Cl→NOX2+ClX2\ce{NO2Cl + Cl -> NO2 + Cl2}. Deduce the overall equation and identify the .

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Add the left sides: NOX2Cl+NOX2Cl+Cl\ce{NO2Cl + NO2Cl + Cl}. Add the right sides: NOX2+Cl+NOX2+ClX2\ce{NO2 + Cl + NO2 + Cl2}.

A can also cancel out, but the other way round. It is used up in an early step and made again in a later one, so it is there at the start and at the end. An intermediate appears only part-way through.

Worked exampleIodide ions speed up the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide. Step 1 (slow): HX2OX2+IX−→HX2O+IOX−\ce{H2O2 + I^- -> H2O + IO^-}. Step 2 (fast): HX2OX2+IOX−→HX2O+OX2+IX−\ce{H2O2 + IO^- -> H2O + O2 + I^-}. Explain the roles of IX−\ce{I^-} and IOX−\ce{IO^-}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Follow each ion. IX−\ce{I^-}: used in step 1, made in step 2.
Check yourself
Chlorine atoms destroy ozone in two steps: Cl+OX3→ClO+OX2\ce{Cl + O3 -> ClO + O2}, then ClO+O→Cl+OX2\ce{ClO + O -> Cl + O2}. Which species acts as a catalyst?

The rate-determining step

The steps of a mechanism run at different speeds. The reaction can go no faster than its slowest step, as a queue moves only as fast as its one ticket desk.

Kinetic data link to it through the , found by experiment (5.6). For example, rate=k[A]2[B]\text{rate} = k[\ce{A}]^{2}[\ce{B}]: the power on each concentration is the with respect to that reactant.

Only species that take part in the , or in fast steps before it, appear in the rate equation. A reactant that joins after the slow step does not: its order is zero.

If the slow step is first, read the rate equation off that step: each reactant, to the power of its coefficient in the step. For NOX2Cl\ce{NO2Cl} above, step 1 is slow, so rate=k[NOX2Cl]\text{rate} = k[\ce{NO2Cl}].

If the slow step comes later, the fast steps before it reach a quick equilibrium that makes an intermediate. The intermediate can't go in the rate equation, but its concentration depends on the reactants that form it. So swap it for those reactants.

Worked exampleA proposed mechanism for 2 NO+2 HX2→NX2+2 HX2O\ce{2NO + 2H2 -> N2 + 2H2O} is: step 1 (fast) 2 NO⇌NX2OX2\ce{2NO <=> N2O2}; step 2 (slow) NX2OX2+HX2→NX2O+HX2O\ce{N2O2 + H2 -> N2O + H2O}; step 3 (fast) NX2O+HX2→NX2+HX2O\ce{N2O + H2 -> N2 + H2O}. Deduce the rate equation it predicts.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Step 2 is the rate-determining step, so the rate depends on [NX2OX2][HX2][\ce{N2O2}][\ce{H2}].

To evaluate a proposed mechanism, test it twice. Its steps must add up to the overall equation, and the rate equation it predicts must match the experimental one. One mismatch rules it out. A match supports it but can't prove it, because other mechanisms might predict the same rate equation.

Worked exampleFor 2 NOX2(g)+FX2(g)→2 NOX2F(g)\ce{2NO2(g) + F2(g) -> 2NO2F(g)}, experiments give rate=k[NOX2][FX2]\text{rate} = k[\ce{NO2}][\ce{F2}]. Mechanism A is one step: 2 NOX2+FX2→2 NOX2F\ce{2NO2 + F2 -> 2NO2F}. Mechanism B is NOX2+FX2→NOX2F+F\ce{NO2 + F2 -> NO2F + F} (slow), then NOX2+F→NOX2F\ce{NO2 + F -> NO2F} (fast). Evaluate the two mechanisms.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Stoichiometry: B's steps add up, with F\ce{F} cancelling. A is the equation itself.
Check yourself
A proposed mechanism for 2 NO+OX2→2 NOX2\ce{2NO + O2 -> 2NO2} is: NO+OX2⇌NOX3\ce{NO + O2 <=> NO3} (fast), then NOX3+NO→2 NOX2\ce{NO3 + NO -> 2NO2} (slow). Which rate equation does it predict?
Check yourself
For rate=k[NO]2[HX2]\text{rate} = k[\ce{NO}]^{2}[\ce{H2}], you triple [NO][\ce{NO}] and halve [HX2][\ce{H2}]. By what factor does the rate change?

Energy profiles for multistep reactions

On an , each elementary step is one hump. The peak of each hump is a transition state. The dip between two humps is an intermediate.

So a is at a maximum and can't be collected. An intermediate is at a minimum: a real species that lasts long enough to react again, and some can be detected. Two steps means two transition states and one intermediate.

Energy profile for a two-step exothermic reaction: two peaks, each a transition state, with the intermediate in the dip between them; step 2 has the larger activation energy, so it is rate-determining TS 1 TS 2 intermediate reactants products Ea1 Ea2 (larger: RDS) ΔH reaction coordinate potential energy
Two steps: two transition states, one intermediate. Step 2 has the larger activation energy.

Each step has its own : the climb from the energy just before that step up to its peak. The rate-determining step is the step with the largest activation energy. ΔH\Delta H for the whole reaction runs from the reactants to the products.

Worked exampleOn the energy profile of a two-step reaction, energies relative to the reactants are: first peak +52 kJ mol−1\pu{+52 kJ mol-1}, intermediate +30 kJ mol−1\pu{+30 kJ mol-1}, second peak +95 kJ mol−1\pu{+95 kJ mol-1}, products −40 kJ mol−1\pu{-40 kJ mol-1}. Calculate the activation energy of the second step, and deduce which step is rate-determining.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. First step: from the reactants (0) to the first peak, 52 kJ mol−1\pu{52 kJ mol-1}.

To construct a profile from kinetic data, work out which step is rate-determining, then give that step the bigger climb. Draw one hump per step, an intermediate in each dip, and end the products below the reactants if ΔH\Delta H is negative.

Worked exampleFor the iodide-catalysed decomposition of hydrogen peroxide above, rate=k[HX2OX2][IX−]\text{rate} = k[\ce{H2O2}][\ce{I^-}] and the reaction is exothermic. Outline the main features of its energy profile.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Two steps, so two humps. IOX−\ce{IO^-} is the intermediate.
Check yourself
On the energy profile of a multistep reaction, what is found at a minimum between two peaks?
Check yourself
A three-step reaction has activation energies of 38 kJ mol−1\pu{38 kJ mol-1} (step 1), 81 kJ mol−1\pu{81 kJ mol-1} (step 2) and 24 kJ mol−1\pu{24 kJ mol-1} (step 3). Which step is rate-determining?

Molecularity

The of a step can be unimolecular: one particle breaks apart or rearranges, like NOX2Cl→NOX2+Cl\ce{NO2Cl -> NO2 + Cl}.

It can be bimolecular: two particles collide, like NOX2+FX2→NOX2F+F\ce{NO2 + F2 -> NO2F + F}. This is the most common kind.

It can be termolecular: three particles collide at once. This is rare, because three particles seldom meet at the same instant with enough energy and the right orientation.

The first step of SN1 hydrolysis is unimolecular: a tertiary halogenoalkane breaks into a carbocation, the intermediate, and a halide ion (6.18).

Molecularity belongs to one elementary step, and is always 1, 2 or 3. For an elementary step only, each reactant's order equals the number of its particles in that step. Order belongs to the whole reaction, is measured, and can be zero.

Worked exampleState the molecularity of each step in the NO\ce{NO} and HX2\ce{H2} mechanism above, and explain why the reaction is unlikely to happen in a single step.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Count the reacting particles. Step 1: two NO\ce{NO}. Step 2: NX2OX2\ce{N2O2} and HX2\ce{H2}. Step 3: NX2O\ce{N2O} and HX2\ce{H2}.
Worked exampleThe step Cl+OX3→ClO+OX2\ce{Cl + O3 -> ClO + O2} is elementary. Deduce its rate equation, then the factor by which its rate changes when [Cl][\ce{Cl}] is doubled and [OX3][\ce{O3}] is multiplied by 1.5.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. It is bimolecular, with one Cl\ce{Cl} and one OX3\ce{O3}, so rate=k[Cl][OX3]\text{rate} = k[\ce{Cl}][\ce{O3}].
Check yourself
As an elementary step, what is the molecularity of NX2OX4→2 NOX2\ce{N2O4 -> 2NO2}?
Check yourself
Which statement is correct?

Common mistakes

  • Calling an intermediate a transition state. Intermediates sit in dips and can exist; transition states sit at peaks and can't be isolated.
  • Leaving an intermediate in the rate equation. Replace it with the reactants that form it.
  • Putting a reactant that joins after the slow step into the rate equation.
  • Saying the data prove a mechanism. They can only support it or rule it out.

Exam tips

  • "Evaluate" a mechanism: check the steps add up to the overall equation, deduce the rate equation from the slow step, compare it with the data and conclude.
  • "Identify" the intermediate: it is made in one step and used in a later one. A catalyst is used first and made again.
  • "Sketch" a multistep profile: label each transition state and intermediate, make the rate-determining step the largest climb, and place the products by the sign of ΔH\Delta H.
  • In Paper 1A, read the molecularity off one step's reactants, never its products or the overall equation.

Key takeaways

Learn thisA mechanism's elementary steps must add up to the overall equation. Intermediates are made then used up; catalysts are used then regenerated.
Learn thisThe slowest step is rate-determining. The rate equation holds its reactants, each to the power of its coefficient; swap an intermediate for the reactants of the fast equilibrium that makes it. Species reacting after it are zero order.
Learn thisA mechanism that fits the stoichiometry and the rate equation is consistent, not proven.
Learn thisEnergy profile: one hump per step; transition state at each peak, intermediate in each dip; the rate-determining step has the largest activation energy.
Learn thisMolecularity (elementary steps only): unimolecular 1, bimolecular 2, termolecular 3 (rare).

Practise this

108 past-paper questions on Rate laws, orders, Arrhenius and mechanisms in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Rate laws, orders, Arrhenius and mechanisms →