Reference frames and Galilean relativity
In a minute
A is the set of axes and clocks you use to give the and time of an event. Newton's laws work the same way in every frame that moves at constant : this is . Two short equations, and , convert positions and velocities from one such frame to another.
You'll be able to
- Describe a and give the coordinates of an event in it.
- State what makes a frame an , one in which holds, and recognise a frame that is not.
- Explain : Newton's laws take the same form in every inertial frame.
- Use and to find the coordinates of an event in a second frame.
- Derive and use it, with signs, to find a velocity in another frame.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 1.1 Describing motion, 1.4 Newton's laws and free-body diagrams and 6.2 Scalars and vectors
Reference frames and inertial frames
Drop your keys in a smoothly moving train. To you, they fall straight down. To someone on the platform, they also move forwards with the train, so they follow a curved path.
Both descriptions are correct. They are made from different .
Every observer can set up a frame in which they are at rest. Different frames can give the same event different coordinates.
Some frames are special. In an , holds: an object with zero resultant force on it stays at rest or keeps moving at constant velocity.
Any frame moving at constant velocity relative to an inertial frame is also inertial. The ground is very nearly inertial: the accelerations from the Earth's spin and orbit are small enough to ignore in most problems.
A frame that is not inertial: a bus brakes hard, and a ball on its smooth floor rolls forwards with nothing pushing it. Newton's first law fails in the bus's frame.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Decide whether the train's frame is inertial.
- Use Galilean relativity to bring in Newton's laws.
- Work in the train's frame: what horizontal force acts on the coin?
- Compare with a train at rest.
- The train moves at constant velocity, so it is not accelerating and its frame is an inertial reference frame. By Galilean relativity, Newton's laws hold in the train's frame just as on the platform. In that frame the coin starts with no horizontal velocity, and its weight acts vertically, so there is no horizontal force on it. So it falls straight down, landing directly below the release point. The same happens in a train at rest, so the passenger cannot tell that the train is moving.
From the platform, the coin keeps the train's horizontal velocity as it falls, so its path curves. The floor keeps pace, so both frames agree on where it lands.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Work in the road's inertial frame, with the acceleration's direction positive. The mass accelerates with the lorry, so the resultant force on it is , horizontal.
- Two forces act: tension along the string and weight . Vertically there is no acceleration, so .
- Horizontally, .
- Divide the two equations: , so , or to 2 significant figures. The value is from the data booklet.
- In the lorry's frame the mass is at rest, yet and do not cancel. Newton's first law fails there, so the lorry's frame is not inertial.
The Galilean transformation
Now compare two inertial frames. Frame is fixed to the ground. Frame moves along the -axis at constant velocity relative to .
Both clocks read zero at the instant the two origins, and , pass each other. By a later time , has moved a distance from .
An event P happens at time . The figure shows that its distance from is plus its distance from . Rearranging gives the first equation below.
Here and are the event's coordinates in , and and are its coordinates in . is the velocity of relative to . All three of , and carry signs.
Positions are not absolute: the same event has different and . But in Galilean relativity an object's length, found by marking both ends at the same instant, is the same in both frames.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Take downstream as positive. Then , and .
- Time is the same in both frames: .
- .
- The minus sign means the heron lands behind the bow. Check: by the bow is past the bridge, so it has already passed the heron's spot.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Take the drone's direction as positive, so .
- Kick: . The ball is kicked from directly below the drone.
- Landing: .
- Separation in : . In it is .
- The time between the events is in both frames, because . Only the distance changes.
Galilean velocity addition
In the drone example the ball moved in in the field's frame: . In the drone's frame it moved : . The difference is the drone's velocity, .
Here is the object's velocity in , its velocity in , and the velocity of relative to . Choose a positive direction first. A velocity in the opposite direction is negative.
Rearranged, : an object's velocity relative to the ground is its velocity relative to a moving frame plus that frame's own velocity. Along a line, this is with signs.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Take the cyclist's direction as positive. Frame is the road; frame moves with the cyclist, so .
- The bus moves the opposite way: .
- .
- So, to the cyclist, the bus approaches at in the negative direction. Check: approaching objects close at the sum of their speeds.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Take the walkway's direction of motion as positive. Frame is the floor; frame moves with the walkway, so .
- The child's velocity in is . You want , the velocity in .
- Rearrange : .
- The child moves slowly backwards relative to the floor, against the walkway's motion.
Because is constant, a change in gives the same change in , so every inertial observer measures the same acceleration. Forces and masses are the same too, so holds in both frames. This is why Galilean relativity works.
Galilean velocity addition works very well at everyday speeds but fails near the speed of light, . For light travelling the same way as a spacecraft moving at , it predicts relative to the spacecraft. In fact light in a vacuum travels at relative to every inertial observer. 1.16 shows what replaces .
Common mistakes
- Defining an inertial frame as one "at rest". Any frame that is not accelerating is inertial, whether or not it moves.
- Dropping signs. Fix a positive direction, then give opposite velocities and positions a minus sign before using .
- Using Galilean addition for light or particles near . It predicts speeds that experiments never measure.
Exam tips
- "State what is meant by an inertial reference frame": say it is not accelerating (it moves at constant velocity), or that Newton's first law holds in it. "At rest" alone is not enough.
- In "calculate" or "determine" questions, state your positive direction, write or with values substituted, then give the answer with its sign and unit. "Write down" a Galilean answer needs no working.
- "Explain" why an observer cannot detect uniform motion: say the frame is inertial, then quote Galilean relativity, that Newton's laws are the same in all inertial frames.
Key takeaways
Practise this
89 past-paper questions on Special relativity and spacetime in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.