1.15 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Reference frames and Galilean relativity

In a minute

A is the set of axes and clocks you use to give the and time of an event. Newton's laws work the same way in every frame that moves at constant : this is . Two short equations, x′=x−vtx' = x - vt and u′=u−vu' = u - v, convert positions and velocities from one such frame to another.

You'll be able to

  • Describe a and give the coordinates of an event in it.
  • State what makes a frame an , one in which holds, and recognise a frame that is not.
  • Explain : Newton's laws take the same form in every inertial frame.
  • Use x′=x−vtx' = x - vt and t′=tt' = t to find the coordinates of an event in a second frame.
  • Derive u′=u−vu' = u - v and use it, with signs, to find a velocity in another frame.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A puck slides across smooth, level ice. The resultant force on it is zero. What happens to it?
Check yourself
A runner's position changes from x=12 mx = \pu{12 m} to x=−18 mx = \pu{-18 m} in 6.0 s\pu{6.0 s}. Taking the +x+x direction as positive, what is her average velocity, in m s−1\text{m s}^{-1}? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Two forces act on a crate along the same line: 7.0 N\pu{7.0 N} to the right and 10.0 N\pu{10.0 N} to the left. Taking right as positive, use to find the resultant force, in N.

Revise first: 1.1 Describing motion, 1.4 Newton's laws and free-body diagrams and 6.2 Scalars and vectors

Reference frames and inertial frames

Drop your keys in a smoothly moving train. To you, they fall straight down. To someone on the platform, they also move forwards with the train, so they follow a curved path.

Both descriptions are correct. They are made from different .

Every observer can set up a frame in which they are at rest. Different frames can give the same event different coordinates.

Some frames are special. In an , holds: an object with zero resultant force on it stays at rest or keeps moving at constant velocity.

Any frame moving at constant velocity relative to an inertial frame is also inertial. The ground is very nearly inertial: the accelerations from the Earth's spin and orbit are small enough to ignore in most problems.

A frame that is not inertial: a bus brakes hard, and a ball on its smooth floor rolls forwards with nothing pushing it. Newton's first law fails in the bus's frame.

Worked exampleA train moves along a straight, level track at a constant 30 m s−1\pu{30 m s-1}. A passenger releases a coin from rest above the floor. Air resistance is negligible. Explain why the coin lands directly below the release point, and why this cannot show that the train is moving.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Decide whether the train's frame is inertial.

From the platform, the coin keeps the train's horizontal velocity as it falls, so its path curves. The floor keeps pace, so both frames agree on where it lands.

Side view of a lorry on a level road, accelerating to the right, shown by an arrow labelled acceleration a above the lorry. A small mass hangs on a string from a point on the roof inside the cargo box. The string is tilted backwards, towards the rear of the lorry, at an angle theta to a dashed vertical line. Two forces act on the mass: the tension T, pulling up along the string, and the weight m g, pulling straight down. acceleration a level road θ T mg
In the road's frame, TT and mgmg add to a horizontal resultant force mama in the direction of the acceleration.
Worked exampleA small mass hangs on a string from the roof of a lorry. The lorry accelerates along a straight, level road at 1.50 m s−2\pu{1.50 m s-2}, and the string settles at a steady angle θ\theta to the vertical. Determine θ\theta, and explain why the lorry's frame is not inertial.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Work in the road's inertial frame, with the acceleration's direction positive. The mass accelerates with the lorry, so the resultant force on it is mama, horizontal.
Check yourself
Which of these is an inertial reference frame, to a good approximation?
Check yourself
A bus pulls away from a stop. A ball resting on its smooth floor rolls towards the back of the bus. Which statement is correct?

The Galilean transformation

Now compare two inertial frames. Frame SS is fixed to the ground. Frame S′S' moves along the xx-axis at constant velocity vv relative to SS.

Both clocks read zero at the instant the two origins, OO and O′O', pass each other. By a later time tt, O′O' has moved a distance vtvt from OO.

Two parallel horizontal x-axes. The lower axis belongs to frame S, with origin O at the left. The upper axis belongs to frame S prime, with origin O prime further to the right, and an arrow labelled v shows that frame S prime moves to the right relative to S. A dashed vertical line marks event P, to the right of both origins. Below the axes, an arrow from O to O prime is labelled v t, and a longer arrow from O to P is labelled x. Beside the upper axis, an arrow from O prime to P is labelled x prime. So x equals v t plus x prime. event P v x′ (frame S′) O′ x′ x (frame S) O vt x
At time tt, the event's position in SS is x=vt+x′x = vt + x'.

An event P happens at time tt. The figure shows that its distance from OO is vtvt plus its distance from O′O'. Rearranging gives the first equation below.

In the formula booklet
x′=x−vtx' = x - vt
In the formula booklet
t′=tt' = t

Here xx and tt are the event's coordinates in SS, and x′x' and t′t' are its coordinates in S′S'. vv is the velocity of S′S' relative to SS. All three of xx, x′x' and vv carry signs.

Positions are not absolute: the same event has different xx and x′x'. But in Galilean relativity an object's length, found by marking both ends at the same instant, is the same in both frames.

Worked exampleA ferry sails downstream along a straight canal at a constant 3.5 m s−1\pu{3.5 m s-1}. Frame SS is fixed to the bank, with its origin at a bridge. Frame S′S' moves with the ferry, with its origin at the bow, which passes the bridge at t=0t = 0. At t=40 st = \pu{40 s} a heron lands on the bank 110 m\pu{110 m} downstream of the bridge. Determine the coordinates of this event in S′S'.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take downstream as positive. Then v=+3.5 m s−1v = \pu{+3.5 m s-1}, x=+110 mx = \pu{+110 m} and t=40 st = \pu{40 s}.
Worked exampleA drone flies in a straight line at a constant 12 m s−1\pu{12 m s-1} over a level field. Frame SS is fixed to the field and frame S′S' moves with the drone; their origins coincide at t=0t = 0. Along the drone's path, a ball is kicked at x=18 mx = \pu{18 m}, t=1.5 st = \pu{1.5 s}, and lands at x=63 mx = \pu{63 m}, t=4.0 st = \pu{4.0 s}. Determine the distance between these two events in the drone's frame.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take the drone's direction as positive, so v=+12 m s−1v = \pu{+12 m s-1}.
Check yourself
Frame S′S' moves at +8.0 m s−1\pu{+8.0 m s-1} relative to frame SS, and their origins coincide at t=0t = 0. An event happens at x=62 mx = \pu{62 m}, t=4.0 st = \pu{4.0 s} in SS. What is x′x', in m? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Two observers are in different inertial frames moving relative to each other. According to Galilean relativity, which of these do they always agree on?

Galilean velocity addition

In the drone example the ball moved 45 m\pu{45 m} in 2.5 s\pu{2.5 s} in the field's frame: 18 m s−1\pu{18 m s-1}. In the drone's frame it moved 15 m\pu{15 m}: 6 m s−1\pu{6 m s-1}. The difference is the drone's velocity, 12 m s−1\pu{12 m s-1}.

In the formula booklet
u′=u−vu' = u - v

Here uu is the object's velocity in SS, u′u' its velocity in S′S', and vv the velocity of S′S' relative to SS. Choose a positive direction first. A velocity in the opposite direction is negative.

Rearranged, u=u′+vu = u' + v: an object's velocity relative to the ground is its velocity relative to a moving frame plus that frame's own velocity. Along a line, this is with signs.

Worked exampleA cyclist rides along a straight road at 6.4 m s−1\pu{6.4 m s-1}. A bus comes towards her at 11.0 m s−1\pu{11.0 m s-1}. Both speeds are relative to the road. Calculate the velocity of the bus in the cyclist's frame.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take the cyclist's direction as positive. Frame SS is the road; frame S′S' moves with the cyclist, so v=+6.4 m s−1v = \pu{+6.4 m s-1}.
Worked exampleA moving walkway at an airport carries passengers at 0.90 m s−1\pu{0.90 m s-1} relative to the floor. A child walks the wrong way along it, at 1.4 m s−1\pu{1.4 m s-1} relative to the walkway. Determine the child's velocity relative to the floor.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take the walkway's direction of motion as positive. Frame SS is the floor; frame S′S' moves with the walkway, so v=+0.90 m s−1v = \pu{+0.90 m s-1}.

Because vv is constant, a change in uu gives the same change in u′u', so every inertial observer measures the same acceleration. Forces and masses are the same too, so F=maF = ma holds in both frames. This is why Galilean relativity works.

Check yourself
On parallel straight tracks, train P moves at +32 m s−1\pu{+32 m s-1} and train Q at +27 m s−1\pu{+27 m s-1}, both relative to the ground. What is the velocity of Q in P's frame?
Check yourself
In frame SS, a trolley's velocity rises steadily from +2.0 m s−1\pu{+2.0 m s-1} to +8.0 m s−1\pu{+8.0 m s-1} in 3.0 s\pu{3.0 s}. Frame S′S' moves at +5.0 m s−1\pu{+5.0 m s-1} relative to SS. What is the trolley's acceleration in S′S', in m s−2\text{m s}^{-2}? Give 2 significant figures.

Galilean velocity addition works very well at everyday speeds but fails near the speed of light, cc. For light travelling the same way as a spacecraft moving at 0.40c0.40c, it predicts c−0.40c=0.60cc - 0.40c = 0.60c relative to the spacecraft. In fact light in a vacuum travels at cc relative to every inertial observer. 1.16 shows what replaces t′=tt' = t.

Check yourself
For which situation does Galilean velocity addition give an accurate answer?

Common mistakes

  • Defining an inertial frame as one "at rest". Any frame that is not accelerating is inertial, whether or not it moves.
  • Dropping signs. Fix a positive direction, then give opposite velocities and positions a minus sign before using u′=u−vu' = u - v.
  • Using Galilean addition for light or particles near cc. It predicts speeds that experiments never measure.

Exam tips

  • "State what is meant by an inertial reference frame": say it is not accelerating (it moves at constant velocity), or that Newton's first law holds in it. "At rest" alone is not enough.
  • In "calculate" or "determine" questions, state your positive direction, write u′=u−vu' = u - v or x′=x−vtx' = x - vt with values substituted, then give the answer with its sign and unit. "Write down" a Galilean answer needs no working.
  • "Explain" why an observer cannot detect uniform motion: say the frame is inertial, then quote Galilean relativity, that Newton's laws are the same in all inertial frames.

Key takeaways

Learn thisA reference frame is a set of axes and clocks. An event has coordinates (x,t)(x, t) in each frame.
Learn thisAn inertial reference frame is not accelerating, and Newton's first law holds in it. Any frame at constant velocity relative to an inertial frame is inertial.
Learn thisGalilean relativity: Newton's laws are the same in all inertial frames. All inertial observers measure the same time and the same acceleration.
In bookletx′=x−vtx' = x - vt
In booklett′=tt' = t
In bookletu′=u−vu' = u - v
Learn thisvv is the velocity of frame S′S' relative to SS. Fix a positive direction first. Galilean velocity addition fails for speeds close to cc.

Practise this

89 past-paper questions on Special relativity and spacetime in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Special relativity and spacetime →