Gas processes and heat engines
In a minute
A gas can change state while one thing stays fixed: its volume, its pressure, its temperature or, in an change, its heat exchange. Take a gas round a closed loop of such changes and you have a , turning thermal energy into work again and again. The sets the highest any engine can reach between two temperatures.
You'll be able to
- Describe , , and adiabatic processes, and apply the to each one on a .
- Use to find the pressure, volume and temperature after an adiabatic change of a monatomic .
- Explain how a cyclic gas process runs a heat engine, and find the net work from the area enclosed on a P-V diagram.
- Calculate the efficiency of a heat engine running on a given cycle, using .
- Use to find the maximum efficiency between two reservoirs, and explain why real engines fall short of it.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 1.11 Power, efficiency and energy density, 2.7 Pressure, amount of substance and the ideal gas model, 2.8 The ideal gas equations and the kinetic model, 2.9 The first law of thermodynamics and 2.10 Entropy and the second law
Four simple gas processes
In 2.9 you met the for a closed system: a fixed amount of gas that exchanges energy with its surroundings, but not matter. Every problem uses the same sign convention.
is the thermal energy supplied to the gas. It is negative when energy leaves the gas as heat.
is the work done by the gas. It is positive when the gas expands and negative when the gas is compressed.
For a monatomic , the depends only on the temperature. So is positive when the gas warms and negative when it cools. All constants in this lesson, such as , come from the data booklet.
The state of a gas is described by , and , linked by the . Four simple processes each keep one quantity fixed.
1. An keeps fixed. The gas pushes nothing back, so and .
2. An keeps fixed. The work done by the gas is .
3. An keeps fixed. For an ideal gas this means , so . All the heat supplied becomes work, or all the work done on the gas leaves it as heat.
4. An keeps fixed at zero: no thermal energy enters or leaves, so . It happens when the gas is insulated, or when the change is too fast for heat to flow.
On a , each point is one state of the gas and each line is a process. Here are the four processes, all starting from the same state.
The work done by the gas is the area under its line. Moving right (expansion), the gas does positive work. Moving left (compression), is negative: work is done on the gas. A vertical line has no area under it, so .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Work done by the gas at constant pressure: .
- Change in internal energy: . At constant pressure, gives , so .
- First law: .
- Only two-fifths of the heat becomes work; the rest warms the gas. The pressure has 2 significant figures, so give 2.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Say what a constant temperature means for .
- Give the sign of for a compression.
- Combine them in .
- The internal energy of an ideal gas depends only on its temperature, which is constant, so the internal energy does not change and . The gas is compressed, so work is done on the gas and the work done by the gas, , is negative. From the first law, , so is negative. Thermal energy leaves the gas, equal in size to the work done on it.
Adiabatic changes
In an expansion no heat enters, but the gas still does work as it pushes outwards. That energy must come from the gas itself. So is negative, and the gas cools.
An adiabatic compression does the reverse. Work is done on the gas (), so and the gas warms. This is how a diesel engine ignites its fuel without a spark: compressing the air makes it hot enough.
As a gas expands adiabatically, it moves onto cooler and cooler isotherms. So its curve on a is steeper than the isotherm through the same point. The pressure falls both because the volume grows and because the temperature drops.
This model is for a monatomic changing adiabatically, with the same pressure throughout the gas at each moment. Between two states, . Use alongside it to find a temperature.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- For an adiabatic change, , so .
- The volume ratio is , and .
- So . Give 2 significant figures.
- Sense check: an isothermal compression to a quarter of the volume would only multiply the pressure by 4. The adiabatic one multiplies it by about 10, because the gas also heats up.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Starting pressure: .
- Final pressure: .
- Final temperature: . The gas has cooled, as expected.
- No heat flows, so .
- is positive because the gas expands. Carry unrounded values through, then give 2 significant figures.
Cycles and heat engines
One expansion can do work only once: the piston soon reaches the end of the cylinder. To keep doing work, the gas must be brought back to its starting state and the process repeated. A series of processes that ends where it began is called a cycle.
After a full cycle the gas is back at its starting temperature, so . The first law then says that the net thermal energy taken in over the cycle equals the net work done by the gas.
On a a cycle is a closed loop, and the net work is the area it encloses. Going clockwise, the gas expands at a higher pressure than it is compressed at, so net work is done by the gas. Going anticlockwise, net work is done on the gas.
A runs a gas round such a cycle. In each cycle it takes in thermal energy from a hot reservoir, does useful work , and gives out thermal energy to a cold reservoir. Here and are sizes, both positive.
The Kelvin form of the , from 2.10, says no cyclic engine can turn all of into work. Some energy must always go to the cold reservoir, so .
Engines run on many different cycles. A petrol engine roughly follows two adiabatic and two isovolumetric stages; other designs use isobaric or isothermal stages. Each cycle gives a different efficiency, but you work it out the same way.
The of an engine compares the useful work it does with the energy put in. For a heat engine, the input energy is , the thermal energy taken in.
So . For a cycle on a P-V diagram, is the enclosed area. is the sum of the positive values of only, from the stages where heat flows in.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Useful work per cycle: .
- Efficiency: .
- The work is known to 2 significant figures, so give 2. As a percentage, this is about 29%.
In a cycle made of several processes, find for each stage from the first law. Only the stages where is positive count towards the input energy.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Net work is the enclosed area: .
- In isovolumetric and isobaric stages, has the same sign as , so heat flows in where the gas warms, from A to B and from B to C. It flows out from C to D and from D to A, where the gas cools. For each stage, .
- A to B: , so .
- B to C: and , so .
- Input energy: , so . Give 2 significant figures.
- Check: the stages C to D and D to A give out , and , the net work.
The Carnot cycle and the efficiency limit
Every heat engine wastes some heat. How small can the wasted fraction be? The answer depends only on the temperatures of the two reservoirs, and the reaches it.
A Carnot engine takes an ideal gas through four reversible stages:
1. A to B: isothermal expansion at . The gas takes in from the hot reservoir.
2. B to C: adiabatic expansion. The gas does work and cools from to .
3. C to D: isothermal compression at . The gas gives out to the cold reservoir.
4. D to A: adiabatic compression. Work done on the gas warms it back to .
Heat flows only while the gas is at (almost exactly) the reservoir's temperature, so no heat crosses a real temperature difference. With no friction either, every stage is reversible, with no losses. Over a cycle, the total of the gas and the two reservoirs does not change.
This gives the limit. The hot reservoir loses entropy and the cold one gains . With no overall change these are equal, so and .
Both temperatures must be in kelvin. No heat engine working between the same two reservoirs can be more efficient than a Carnot engine. A more efficient one would send less heat to the cold reservoir, so the total entropy would fall, which the forbids.
Real engines fall well short of the Carnot efficiency. They have friction and turbulence, and their heat flows across real temperature differences, which is irreversible. A true Carnot cycle would also have to run infinitely slowly, so it would deliver no power. It is a theoretical limit, not a practical design.
To raise the limit, make higher or lower. This is why power stations run their steam as hot as their materials allow.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Convert to kelvin: and .
- Carnot limit: .
- Give 2 significant figures. Real turbines reach much less than this, because they are not reversible.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Work out the efficiency she claims.
- Work out the Carnot limit for these two temperatures.
- Compare them, and say what the comparison means.
- The claimed efficiency is . The Carnot efficiency for these reservoirs is , which is about 0.55. This is the maximum efficiency of any heat engine working between these two temperatures. The claimed efficiency is greater than this maximum. So the claim is impossible, because such an engine would break the second law of thermodynamics.
Common mistakes
- Using Celsius in . Convert both temperatures to kelvin first.
- Taking work done on the gas as positive. In , is the work done by the gas, so a compression has .
- Thinking adiabatic means constant temperature. Adiabatic means ; the temperature changes because work is done.
- Saying no net work is done over a cycle because . The net work equals the net heat taken in, which is the enclosed area.
- Saying a well-designed real engine could reach the Carnot efficiency. The Carnot cycle is reversible and infinitely slow, so it is only a limit.
Exam tips
- "Show, using the first law" that heat enters or leaves: state (from the temperature change), then the sign of (expansion or compression), then combine them in . Each step is a marking point, so don't jump to the conclusion.
- "Show that" a volume or pressure after an adiabatic change: write with the numbers in, then give one more significant figure than the stated value.
- "Sketch" or "draw" a cycle on P-V axes: the marks are for the shapes. Isovolumetric is vertical, isobaric is horizontal, and an adiabatic curve is steeper than an isotherm through the same point.
- "Explain" why a real engine cannot reach the Carnot efficiency: the Carnot cycle is reversible (no friction, no heat flow across a temperature difference) and would have to run infinitely slowly.
Key takeaways
Practise this
42 past-paper questions on Thermodynamics, entropy and cycles in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.