Entropy and the second law
In a minute
measures how disordered the particles of a system are. You can find a change in it from heat and temperature, , or count arrangements of particles, . The says the total entropy of an never decreases. That one rule explains why heat flows from hot to cold, why no engine is 100% efficient, and why a fridge needs a power supply.
You'll be able to
- Describe entropy as a measure of the disorder of the particles in a system, and calculate an entropy change from for a reversible transfer at constant temperature.
- Count the of a simple model, such as a set of coins, and use .
- State the second law of thermodynamics in its entropy, Clausius and Kelvin forms, and use it to decide whether a process is possible.
- Explain why real processes are irreversible, and so why an isolated system in the real world always gains entropy.
- Explain how the entropy of a system that is not isolated can fall, and show that the surroundings gain at least as much.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 1.6 Momentum and impulse, 2.1 Particles, density and temperature and 2.2 Internal energy, phase changes and specific heats
Entropy from heat and temperature
Drop an ice cube into a warm drink. The water molecules, once locked in a neat crystal, end up moving randomly through the liquid. You never see the reverse: a drink that cools itself while an ice cube grows in it. Physics needs a quantity that tracks this one-way change.
A solid has lower than the same substance as a liquid, and a liquid lower than a gas. Heating a substance also raises its entropy, because its particles move more randomly. Melting and boiling raise the and the entropy together.
You can measure an entropy change without looking at particles at all. When thermal energy is transferred reversibly (slowly, with no other losses) to a system at a constant absolute temperature , its entropy changes by .
Signs follow the system. Thermal energy into the system makes positive, so its entropy rises. Thermal energy out makes negative, so its entropy falls. must be on the .
Use the equation only when stays constant and the transfer is reversible: a pure substance melting or boiling, a gas expanding slowly at constant temperature, or a reservoir so large that its temperature barely changes. Constant temperature alone is not enough: in a free expansion into a vacuum no heat flows and stays the same, yet the entropy rises. The same energy causes a bigger entropy change at a low temperature than at a high one, because a cold system starts out more ordered.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Thermal energy supplied to the water: . It goes in, so it is positive.
- The water boils at a constant temperature: .
- .
- The data have 3 significant figures, so give 3. Steam is far more disordered than liquid water, so the rise makes sense.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Thermal energy leaves the lead as it solidifies: .
- The temperature is constant: .
- .
- Give 2 significant figures and keep the sign: the solid is more ordered than the liquid, so the entropy of the lead falls.
Counting microstates
Entropy can also be found by counting. Toss four coins. The result "two heads" describes the overall state, called a macrostate. Each exact sequence that gives it, such as HTTH, is a .
Every microstate is equally likely. So the macrostate with the most microstates is the most likely one: two heads turns up 6 times in 16, four heads only once. The mixed, disordered macrostate wins because there are more ways to make it.
Real systems have around particles, not four coins. Then the most disordered macrostates have so many more microstates than the ordered ones that the system is almost certain to be found in one of them.
Here is the , from the data booklet, and is the natural logarithm. A state with only one microstate has : perfect order. More microstates means more entropy.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Count the microstates. Choose which 3 of the 5 coins show heads: HHHTT, HHTHT, HHTTH, HTHHT, HTHTH, HTTHH, THHHT, THHTH, THTHH, TTHHH. So .
- Use .
- . Give 3 significant figures.
- Compare: "five heads" has , so its entropy is zero.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Say what is true of every microstate.
- Compare how many microstates the spread-out and the gathered macrostates have.
- Link the most likely macrostate to entropy.
- All microstates of the gas are equally likely. Far more microstates have the molecules spread through the whole container than have them all in one corner. So the spread-out macrostate is overwhelmingly the most probable, and the random motion of the molecules carries the gas into it. The spread-out state has a larger , so it has a higher entropy, from . A return to the corner would need the gas to reach one of the very few gathered microstates, which is so improbable that it is never observed.
The second law of thermodynamics
In thermodynamics an is one that neither mass nor energy can enter or leave. Nothing outside can push it towards order, so it drifts towards its most probable macrostates. That is the content of the second law.
A reversible process is an ideal one that could be run backwards, returning both the system and its surroundings exactly to their starting states. It would have to happen infinitely slowly, with no friction and no temperature differences. Real processes are not like that.
Friction, mixing, thermal energy flowing across a temperature difference and a gas rushing into a vacuum are all . So any real isolated system gains entropy.
The second law limits what can happen. Energy conservation alone would allow a cup of tea to get hotter by cooling the air around it. The second law forbids it, because the total entropy would fall. Two older statements say the same thing.
Clausius form: thermal energy cannot flow by itself from a colder body to a hotter one. A fridge does move energy from cold to hot, but only because work is done on it.
Kelvin form: no device working in a cycle can take thermal energy from a single reservoir and turn all of it into work. Every must pass some thermal energy to a colder reservoir. This is why no engine can be 100% efficient; 2.11 finds the limit.
The entropy form gives the Clausius form directly. Let thermal energy flow from a body at to one at . The hot body loses entropy and the cold body gains . The total change, , is positive only when .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Take each body's thermal energy as positive when it goes in. Furnace wall: .
- Cooling water: .
- The bar is in a steady state, so its entropy does not change.
- Total: . It is positive, as the second law requires for a real flow from hot to cold.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Say what happens to the entropy of the hot reservoir.
- Say what happens to the engine's own entropy over a cycle, and whether work carries entropy.
- Find what must happen for the total not to decrease.
- Each cycle the engine takes thermal energy from the hot reservoir, so the entropy of the hot reservoir decreases by . The engine returns to its initial state at the end of each cycle, so its own entropy does not change. Work done on the surroundings transfers no entropy. If all of became work, the total entropy would decrease, which the second law forbids. So the engine must transfer thermal energy to a cold reservoir, whose entropy increase is at least as large as the decrease of the hot reservoir.
When entropy falls locally
Most systems are not isolated. A closed system can exchange energy with its surroundings, as heat or as work, but no mass can enter or leave it; an open system, such as a living cell, exchanges mass too. The entropy of a system that is not isolated can go down.
Water freezing in a freezer, the cold inside of a fridge, a growing crystal and a living cell all become more ordered. None of them breaks the second law. Each one passes thermal energy (and a cell also waste matter) to its surroundings, and the surroundings gain at least as much entropy as the system loses.
To test a process, draw a boundary around the system and its surroundings together. That larger system is isolated, so its total entropy must not decrease: .
The work is what makes a fridge possible. The kitchen is warmer, so each joule adds less entropy there than it removed from the inside. Without the work, the kitchen's entropy gain would be smaller than the inside's loss. With it, the kitchen receives , enough extra energy to make up the difference.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Inside, at : .
- Energy into the kitchen, by energy conservation: .
- Kitchen, at : .
- Total: . The entropy inside falls, but the total rises, as it must.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Say whether the water is an isolated system, and where its thermal energy goes.
- Say what happens to the entropy of the surroundings.
- Compare the two changes and state the total.
- The water is not an isolated system, so the second law does not require its own entropy to stay the same or rise. As it freezes, the water transfers thermal energy to its surroundings. The surroundings are colder than the water, so their entropy increase, , is larger than the water's decrease. The freezer also does work and transfers that energy to the room, adding more entropy. The total entropy of the water and its surroundings, which together form an isolated system, increases, as the second law requires.
Common mistakes
- Using a Celsius temperature in . Convert to kelvin first, or the answer is far too large.
- Dropping the sign. Thermal energy leaving a system makes its entropy change negative.
- Saying the second law means entropy can never decrease anywhere. It forbids a decrease in the total entropy of an isolated system; a part of it can lose entropy.
- Using when the temperature of the system changes a lot. It needs a constant temperature and a reversible transfer, as in a phase change or a large reservoir; it does not apply to a free expansion, where but the entropy rises.
- Taking as the total number of outcomes, or forgetting the in .
- Saying a fridge breaks the Clausius form. It moves thermal energy from cold to hot only because work is done on it.
Exam tips
- "State the second law": the entropy form needs both "isolated system" and "total entropy never decreases". For the Clausius form, include "by itself" or "without work being done".
- "Calculate the change in entropy": write , substitute with in kelvin, and give a signed answer in .
- Paper 1A coin questions: count the microstates of the stated macrostate only, then use .
- "Explain why this does not violate the second law": say the system is not isolated, name the surroundings, say their entropy rises by more than the system's falls, and end with the total increasing.
Key takeaways
Practise this
42 past-paper questions on Thermodynamics, entropy and cycles in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.