5.3 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Nuclear radius and the Bohr model

In a minute

A grows as you add , but only as the cube root of the , so every nucleus has about the same . Energy conservation gives the of an fired straight at a nucleus. The quantises the electron's angular momentum, which gives hydrogen's energy levels, E=−13.6n2 eVE = -\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV}.

You'll be able to

  • Use R=R0A13R = R_0A^{\frac{1}{3}} to find the radius of a nucleus, and explain why all nuclei have about the same density.
  • Calculate the distance of closest approach of an alpha particle in a head-on collision, using conservation of energy.
  • Explain why scattering at high energies deviates from Rutherford's model, and use the energy where it starts to estimate a .
  • Explain how quantised angular momentum, mvr=nh2πmvr = \frac{nh}{2\pi}, gives fixed orbits and discrete energies in the Bohr model.
  • Use E=−13.6n2 eVE = -\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV} to find hydrogen's energy levels, photon energies, wavelengths and ionisation energies.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
In the , a very small fraction of the alpha particles bounced back from a thin metal foil. What did this show?
Check yourself
Two positive point charges are pushed closer together. What happens to their ?
Check yourself
An electron in an atom falls from the at −2.1 eV-2.1\ \text{eV} to the level at −5.6 eV-5.6\ \text{eV}. What is the energy, in eV, of the it emits?

Revise first: 2.1 Particles, density and temperature, 4.6 Electric potential and potential energy, 5.1 The nuclear atom, 5.2 Atomic spectra and energy levels, 5.7 Radioactive decay and 6.1 Units, measurement and estimation

Nuclear radius and density

In 5.1 you met the tiny nucleus at the centre of every atom. Adding nucleons makes it bigger, but slowly: twenty-seven times as many nucleons only triples the radius. This cube-root rule is in the data booklet.

In the formula booklet
R=R0A13R = R_0A^{\frac{1}{3}}

RR is the radius of the nucleus and AA is its nucleon number. R0=1.20×10−15 mR_0 = 1.20 \times 10^{-15}\ \text{m} is the Fermi radius, roughly the radius of one nucleon (put A=1A = 1). Like every constant in this lesson, it comes from the data booklet.

Worked exampleA nucleus contains 64 nucleons. Calculate its radius.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Write the booklet equation: R=R0A13R = R_0A^{\frac{1}{3}}.

Why a cube root? A sphere's volume is 43πR3\frac{4}{3}\pi R^{3}. Cube the booklet equation and R3=R03AR^{3} = R_0^{3}A, so the volume is proportional to AA. Each nucleon takes up the same space, like marbles packed in a bag.

Worked exampleTake the mass of a nucleus with nucleon number AA to be AA atomic mass units. Show that its density is about 2×1017 kg m−32 \times 10^{17}\ \text{kg m}^{-3}, whatever the value of AA.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Mass: m=A×1.661×10−27 kgm = A \times 1.661 \times 10^{-27}\ \text{kg}, using the data booklet value of 1 u1\ \text{u}.

Water has a density of 1000 kg m−31000\ \text{kg m}^{-3}, so nuclear matter is about 101410^{14} times denser: 14 . Write values this size in and track the powers of ten carefully.

Check yourself
Nucleus P has 125 nucleons and nucleus Q has 8. How many times larger is the radius of P than the radius of Q?
Check yourself
Estimate the density of a nucleus with nucleon number 125. Take its mass to be 125 u125\ \text{u}.

Distance of closest approach

Fire an straight at a nucleus. Both are positive, so the electric force pushes against the alpha particle all the way in. It slows, stops for an instant, then is pushed back the way it came.

Head-on collision of an alpha particle with a nucleus. On the left, far away, an alpha particle of charge plus 2e moves right with all its energy as kinetic energy. Further right, a dashed outline shows the alpha particle stopped for an instant, where all its energy is electric potential energy. On the far right is the nucleus, charge plus Ze. A double-headed arrow below marks d, the distance from the stopped alpha particle to the centre of the nucleus. Not to scale. alpha particle, +2e far away: all kinetic energy stops: v = 0 all electric potential energy nucleus, +Ze d not to scale
At closest approach v=0v = 0: all of EkE_\text{k} is now EpE_\text{p}.

Use conservation of energy. Far away, the alpha particle has kinetic energy EkE_\text{k} and almost no . At closest approach it is at rest, so all of EkE_\text{k} has become electric potential energy.

In the formula booklet
Ep=kq1q2rE_\text{p} = k\frac{q_1q_2}{r}

The alpha particle has charge +2e+2e. A nucleus with proton number ZZ has charge +Ze+Ze. Set EkE_\text{k} equal to EpE_\text{p} at r=dr = d and rearrange:

Learn this
Ek=k(2e)(Ze)d⇒d=2kZe2EkE_\text{k} = k\frac{(2e)(Ze)}{d} \quad\Rightarrow\quad d = \frac{2kZe^{2}}{E_\text{k}}

This assumes the nucleus does not move, which is fair because it is much heavier than the alpha particle. In closest-approach questions the energies are low enough that only the electric force acts; the next section shows what changes at higher energies.

EkE_\text{k} is usually given in MeV, millions of . Convert to joules first: 1 MeV=106×1.60×10−19=1.60×10−13 J1\ \text{MeV} = 10^{6} \times 1.60 \times 10^{-19} = 1.60 \times 10^{-13}\ \text{J}.

Worked exampleAn alpha particle with kinetic energy 6.0 MeV6.0\ \text{MeV} moves head-on towards a nucleus with proton number 50. Calculate the distance of closest approach.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Convert the energy: Ek=6.0×1.60×10−13=9.6×10−13 JE_\text{k} = 6.0 \times 1.60 \times 10^{-13} = 9.6 \times 10^{-13}\ \text{J}.
Worked exampleDetermine the kinetic energy, in MeV, that an alpha particle needs to get within 2.0×10−14 m2.0 \times 10^{-14}\ \text{m} of the centre of a nucleus with proton number 60.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Aim it head-on. At closest approach all the kinetic energy has become electric potential energy, so Ek=k(2e)(60e)dE_\text{k} = k\frac{(2e)(60e)}{d}.
Check yourself
An alpha particle with kinetic energy 3.0 MeV3.0\ \text{MeV} moves head-on towards a nucleus with proton number 40. Calculate the distance of closest approach in units of 10−14 m10^{-14}\ \text{m}, to 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
The alpha particles in a head-on scattering experiment are given twice as much kinetic energy. What happens to the distance of closest approach?

Deviations from Rutherford scattering

Rutherford's scattering model treats the nucleus as a point charge that repels alpha particles by the electric force alone. For low-energy alpha particles it predicts how many are scattered at each angle very well.

Raise the energy and the distance of closest approach shrinks. Eventually the alpha particles reach the surface of the nucleus. There the acts too. It is attractive and acts only over a few times 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}.

Sketch graph of the number of alpha particles scattered through large angles, measured, divided by the number Rutherford's model predicts, against alpha particle kinetic energy. The ratio stays at 1 at low energies, where only the electric force acts and the model fits. Above an energy marked E0 the ratio falls well below 1: fewer alpha particles are scattered back than predicted, because the strong nuclear force also acts. 1 0 E0 alpha particle kinetic energy measured ÷ Rutherford prediction (large angles) electric force only: model fits strong nuclear force also acts: fewer scattered back
Above E0E_0, fewer alpha particles bounce back than predicted.

The energy where deviations start, E0E_0, is useful. At E0E_0 the distance of closest approach is about the radius of the nucleus, so R≈2kZe2E0R \approx \frac{2kZe^{2}}{E_0}. This was an early way to measure nuclear radii.

Deviations start at a lower energy for a light nucleus. Its radius is a little smaller, but its charge is much smaller, so it repels less and alpha particles reach its surface more easily.

Worked exampleA beam of alpha particles is aimed at a thin foil of a heavy metal. Above a certain energy, fewer alpha particles bounce back than Rutherford's model predicts. Explain why.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Start with what changes: more energy means the alpha particles get closer to the nucleus.
Worked exampleA nucleus has proton number 13 and nucleon number 27. Estimate the alpha particle energy, in MeV, above which scattering from it starts to deviate from Rutherford's model.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Find the radius: R=1.20×10−15×2713=1.20×10−15×3=3.60×10−15 mR = 1.20 \times 10^{-15} \times 27^{\frac{1}{3}} = 1.20 \times 10^{-15} \times 3 = 3.60 \times 10^{-15}\ \text{m}.
Check yourself
Alpha particles are fired at a light nucleus and at a heavy nucleus, and their energy is slowly raised. For which nucleus do deviations from Rutherford's model appear at the lower energy?
Check yourself
Deviations from Rutherford scattering start at 18 MeV18\ \text{MeV} for nuclei with proton number 26. Estimate their radius in units of 10−15 m10^{-15}\ \text{m}, to 2 significant figures.

Quantised angular momentum

In 5.2 you saw that hydrogen gives out only certain wavelengths, so its energy levels are discrete. But why should an electron's energy be restricted at all?

Classical physics says an orbiting electron is accelerating, so it should radiate energy and spiral into the nucleus. Bohr kept the circular orbit but added a rule: only some orbits are allowed, and an electron in one does not radiate.

is the rotational version of momentum. For a mass mm moving at speed vv in a circle of radius rr, it is mvrmvr. Bohr's rule says it comes in whole-number steps of h2π\frac{h}{2\pi}:

In the formula booklet
mvr=nh2πmvr = \frac{nh}{2\pi}

Here mm is the electron's mass, hh is the Planck constant and nn is a positive whole number, the quantum number of the orbit.

Combine this rule with the electric force that keeps the electron in its circle, and only certain radii work: r=n2×5.3×10−11 mr = n^{2} \times 5.3 \times 10^{-11}\ \text{m}. You don't need to derive this. Each allowed orbit has its own speed and its own energy.

Worked exampleIn the Bohr model, the electron in the n=1n = 1 orbit of hydrogen has an orbit radius of 5.3×10−11 m5.3 \times 10^{-11}\ \text{m}. Calculate its speed.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Rearrange mvr=nh2πmvr = \frac{nh}{2\pi} for vv: v=nh2πmrv = \frac{nh}{2\pi mr}.
Worked exampleOutline how the Bohr model explains why hydrogen has discrete energy levels.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Start from Bohr's rule: angular momentum is quantised, mvr=nh2πmvr = \frac{nh}{2\pi}.
Check yourself
Calculate the angular momentum of the electron in the n=3n = 3 orbit of hydrogen in units of 10−34 J s10^{-34}\ \text{J s}, to 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
The electron in a hydrogen atom moves from the n=2n = 2 orbit to the n=4n = 4 orbit. What happens to its angular momentum?

Hydrogen's energy levels

Bohr's orbits give hydrogen's energy levels directly. This equation is in the data booklet:

In the formula booklet
E=−13.6n2 eVE = -\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV}

n=1n = 1 is the ground state, at −13.6 eV-13.6\ \text{eV}. As nn grows, the levels rise towards zero and crowd closer together.

The energies are negative because zero is chosen as the electron completely free of the atom (n→∞n \to \infty). A bound electron has less energy than a free one. The minimum energy to free it from level nn is 13.6n2 eV\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV}, so the energy of hydrogen in its ground state is 13.6 eV13.6\ \text{eV}.

Energy level diagram for hydrogen in the Bohr model, not to scale. Horizontal lines from bottom to top: n equals 1 at minus 13.6 electronvolts, n equals 2 at minus 3.40, n equals 3 at minus 1.51, n equals 4 at minus 0.85, n equals 5 at minus 0.54, and zero at the top, where the electron is free. The levels crowd together towards zero. A downward arrow from n equals 5 to n equals 2 is labelled 2.86 electronvolt photon. A dashed upward arrow from n equals 1 to zero is labelled 13.6 electronvolts to ionise. n = 1 n = 2 n = 3 n = 4 n = 5 n = ∞ −13.6 eV −3.40 eV −1.51 eV −0.85 eV −0.54 eV 0 (electron free) 2.86 eV photon 13.6 eV to ionise not to scale
The levels crowd together towards 00. A fall from n=5n = 5 to n=2n = 2 emits a 2.86 eV2.86\ \text{eV} photon.

In an , one photon carries the energy difference between the two levels: E=hf=hcλE = hf = \frac{hc}{\lambda}, where EE is the gap. Convert eV to joules before using hh.

Worked exampleCalculate the wavelength of the photon emitted when the electron in a hydrogen atom falls from n=5n = 5 to n=2n = 2.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Find each level: E5=−13.625=−0.544 eVE_5 = -\frac{13.6}{25} = -0.544\ \text{eV} and E2=−13.64=−3.40 eVE_2 = -\frac{13.6}{4} = -3.40\ \text{eV}.
Worked exampleA hydrogen atom has its electron in the n=4n = 4 level. Determine the minimum frequency of a photon that can ionise it.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Ionising means raising the electron to E=0E = 0. From E4=−13.616=−0.850 eVE_4 = -\frac{13.6}{16} = -0.850\ \text{eV}, it needs 0.850 eV0.850\ \text{eV}.

The Bohr model works well for hydrogen, but it has limits. It fails for atoms with more than one electron, because it ignores how the electrons affect each other. It cannot predict how bright each spectral line is. And it assumes, without explaining why, that an electron in an allowed orbit does not radiate.

Check yourself
Calculate the energy, in eV, of the photon emitted when hydrogen's electron falls from n=3n = 3 to n=1n = 1. Give 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
Which transition in hydrogen emits the photon with the shortest wavelength?

Common mistakes

  • Using ee instead of 2e2e for the alpha particle's charge. An alpha particle has two protons, so its charge is +2e+2e.
  • Leaving EkE_\text{k} in MeV in d=2kZe2Ekd = \frac{2kZe^{2}}{E_\text{k}}. Multiply by 1.60×10−131.60 \times 10^{-13} to get joules first.
  • Thinking a bigger nucleus is denser. Its mass and volume both grow in proportion to AA, so the density stays the same.
  • Using one level's energy as the photon energy. The photon carries the difference between two levels.
  • Using E=−13.6n2 eVE = -\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV} for atoms other than hydrogen. The equation is for hydrogen only, and the Bohr model fails for atoms with more than one electron.

Exam tips

  • "Show that" a nuclear radius or density: write R=R0A13R = R_0A^{\frac{1}{3}} with 1.20×10−15 m1.20 \times 10^{-15}\ \text{m} substituted, then give one more significant figure than the value you were shown.
  • "Calculate" a proton number from a distance of closest approach: give a whole number, because ZZ counts protons.
  • "Outline" why scattering deviates at high energies: say the alpha particles get as close as the nuclear radius, and name the strong nuclear force.
  • In Paper 1A, ratio questions about nuclei rest on two facts: the radius goes as the cube root of AA, and the density does not change.

Key takeaways

In bookletR=R0A13R = R_0A^{\frac{1}{3}}
Learn thisEvery nucleus has about the same density, 2.3×1017 kg m−32.3 \times 10^{17}\ \text{kg m}^{-3}, because its mass and volume are both proportional to AA.
Learn thisd=2kZe2Ekd = \frac{2kZe^{2}}{E_\text{k}}
Learn thisAbove a certain energy, alpha particles reach the nucleus, the strong nuclear force acts, and scattering deviates from Rutherford's model. That energy gives an estimate of the nuclear radius.
In bookletmvr=nh2πmvr = \frac{nh}{2\pi}
In bookletE=−13.6n2 eVE = -\frac{13.6}{n^{2}}\ \text{eV}
Learn thisA photon's energy is the gap between two levels. The Bohr model works for hydrogen but fails for atoms with more than one electron.

Practise this

57 past-paper questions on Atomic structure and discrete energy levels in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Atomic structure and discrete energy levels →