Optimisation problems
In a minute
means finding the best value of something in a real situation: the greatest profit, the least cost, the largest volume. Write the quantity as a function of one variable, solve where its is zero, then check that point against the ends of the allowed values. Always finish by answering the question in context.
You'll be able to
- Write the quantity to optimise as a function of one variable, using a constraint to remove a second unknown.
- Solve by hand or with your GDC, and justify whether the point is a maximum or a minimum.
- Find the greatest or least value on a restricted domain, checking the endpoints and whole-number values.
- Interpret an optimum in context, such as profit, cost, area or volume, and know that motion (kinematics) questions are not set at SL.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 2.4 Key features of graphs, 5.1 Limits and the derivative as a rate of change, 5.2 Increasing and decreasing functions, 5.3 Differentiation of integer-power polynomials and 5.6 Local maximum and minimum points
Finding the best value
Which price brings in the most money? Which box uses the least card? Finding the greatest or least value of a quantity is . On a smooth graph the best value is often at a , where the derivative is zero.
1. Write the quantity you want to optimise as a function of one variable. Note the values that variable can take, its .
2. Differentiate. Then solve , by hand or with your GDC.
3. Justify that the point is the maximum or minimum you want. Check the ends of the domain too.
4. Answer the question asked, in context and with units. If it asks for the greatest profit, give the profit, not just .
To justify at SL, show that changes from positive to negative (a ) or negative to positive (a ). Or say which way the parabola opens, or sketch the GDC graph with the point marked.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Use the power rule on each term: .
- (b) Set the derivative to zero: , so . This is inside the domain .
- Justify: and . The profit rises and then falls, so is a maximum. (Or: is a quadratic with a negative coefficient, so its only stationary point is a maximum.)
- Check the ends: and . Both are much lower.
- (c) Substitute into , not : .
- Interpret: selling 56 bicycles a month gives the greatest profit, 2304 dollars a month.
If you can't differentiate the model by hand, as with at SL, graph it on your GDC and use the maximum or minimum tool. Write down the function you graphed: that line earns the method mark.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Revenue is price times number of subscribers: .
- (b) Write down what you graph: , for . A window of and shows the whole hill.
- The GDC's maximum tool gives the turning point . The graph rises and then falls, so this is the maximum.
- The greatest revenue is dollars a month, at a price of dollars.
- (c) A low price brings many subscribers but little money from each. A high price brings few subscribers. The best price is in between.
At SL, exam optimisation questions use contexts such as profit, cost, area and volume. Questions on motion (kinematics) are not set at SL.
Using a constraint
Often the quantity depends on two unknowns, such as a length and a width. A fixed fact links them: an area, a volume or an amount of material. This is the constraint. Rearrange it for one unknown and substitute, so one variable is left.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) The constraint is the area: , so .
- The fence is one side of and two sides of : , as required.
- (b) Write and differentiate: .
- Set it to zero: , so . A length is positive, so , not . Then .
- Justify: at the derivative is , and at it is . Falling then rising means a minimum.
- (c) . The pen is 30 m along the wall and 15 m deep, using 60 m of fence.
A classic design problem fixes the material and asks for the largest volume. The area and volume formulas are in the prior-learning section of the formula booklet.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) The surface is two circles plus the curved side: . So and .
- (b) . The height must be positive, so is between and about .
- (c) , so and (or graph on your GDC and use its maximum tool).
- The graph of rises to this point and then falls, so it is a maximum. So m.
- (d) Use the full value of : .
- (e) m, which is . The best tank is as tall as it is wide.
Endpoints, whole numbers and the answer
On a restricted domain the greatest or least value can be at an end, not at a stationary point. So work out the quantity at every stationary point inside the domain and at both endpoints. The greatest is the .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) .
- (b) Write down the equation: . The GDC's polynomial solver gives and
- (c) List the candidates. , (local maximum), (local minimum) and .
- The greatest is hundred, at the end of the domain. So the greatest membership is , at 15 months.
- (d) The cubic keeps rising faster and faster after . A real gym has limited space, so the model is unlikely to be reliable beyond its domain.
Some quantities must be whole numbers: chairs, tickets, workers. If the stationary point is not a whole number, work out the quantity at the whole numbers on each side and compare them.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Write as : .
- (b) Set it to zero: , so and , taking the positive root.
- The derivative goes from negative to positive here, so it is a minimum. But must be a whole number.
- Compare the whole numbers either side: and
- is lower. So 51 chairs a week gives the least average cost, dollars per chair.
Common mistakes
- Giving where the optimum happens when the question asks for the optimum itself. For "the greatest profit", substitute back into and give the profit.
- Writing "maximum" with no reason. Show changing sign, say a quadratic model's parabola opens downwards, or sketch the GDC graph with the point marked.
- Stopping at the local maximum on a restricted domain. Work out the quantity at both endpoints too: the greatest value may be at an end.
- Keeping a value the situation rules out, such as a negative length, or giving a fraction of a chair. Reject it and say why, or compare the whole numbers either side.
- Rounding an intermediate value, such as the radius, before using it. Keep the GDC's full value and round only the final answer.
Exam tips
- "Find the value of that maximises ...": write or the function you graph before the GDC answer. That written set-up earns the method mark even if the final value slips.
- "Justify" a maximum or minimum: give a reason, such as the sign of on each side or "negative quadratic, so its only stationary point is a maximum". A bare "maximum" earns no reasoning mark.
- In a multi-part optimisation question, use the given "show that" result in later parts even if you couldn't show it. A wrong earlier answer used correctly can still earn follow-through (FT) marks.
Key takeaways
Practise this
6 past-paper questions on Modelling with differentiation in the AI HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.