Second derivative and concavity
In a minute
The , , is the of the derivative: it tells you how fast the gradient is changing. At a , if it is not , its sign tells a maximum from a minimum. Elsewhere its sign tells you which way the graph bends, and where the bend changes there is a , often where a quantity grows or falls fastest.
You'll be able to
- Find or by differentiating twice, and say what it means in context.
- Use the to decide whether a stationary point is a or a , and know when the test decides nothing.
- Decide where a graph is or from the sign of .
- Find points of inflexion, by hand or with your GDC, and interpret them in context.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 2.4 Key features of graphs, 5.1 Limits and the derivative as a rate of change, 5.2 Increasing and decreasing functions, 5.4 Tangents and normals, 5.6 Local maximum and minimum points and 5.9 Differentiation rules and related rates
Differentiating twice
The derivative is the gradient function. It is a function of too, so you can differentiate it again.
The result is the second derivative. It tells you how fast the gradient is changing as increases.
Read as "f double prime of x". In nothing is squared: the 2s mean "differentiated twice". Questions use both, so answer in the notation the question uses.
You need no new rules. Use the power rule, and the chain, product and quotient rules from 5.9, twice.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Write the fraction as a power: .
- Differentiate once with the power rule: .
- Differentiate that again: , , and .
- So .
In context, has units of "units of per unit of , per unit of ". It says whether the rate of change is increasing () or decreasing (). In 5.13, the second derivative of displacement is acceleration.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Product rule with and , so and (chain rule): .
- (b) Product rule again, with and : .
- Collect the bracket: , so .
- (c) . Also
- Interpret: two hours after the dose the amount is still rising, by about mg per hour. But , so that rate of increase is falling, by about mg per hour each hour. The amount will soon peak.
- Check on your GDC: the numerical derivative of your at should also give
The second derivative test
In 5.6 you classified a stationary point by the sign of on each side. The second derivative gives a quicker test.
At a local minimum the gradient goes from negative, through , to positive. It is increasing, so the curve bends up like a cup. At a local maximum the gradient goes from positive to negative. It is decreasing, so the curve bends down like an upside-down cup.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) and .
- (b) . Divide by : , so and or .
- (c) , so is a local maximum. , so is a local minimum.
- (d) Substitute into , not : . Also .
- Interpret: the depth reaches a local high of m in month 5 and a local low of m in month 15.
Sometimes has the same sign for every in the domain. Then you need no substitution: say so, and every stationary point is the same kind.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Write . Then and .
- (b) Write down what you graph: on . The minimum tool gives km/h. (By hand: , so .)
- (c) For , both terms of are positive. So (it equals ), and the point is a local minimum.
- It is the only stationary point in the domain. The ends give and , both higher, so it is the least cost.
- (d) Use the full value of : dollars.
- Interpret: driving slower costs more in wages; driving faster costs more in fuel. About km/h balances the two.
The test fails when . At , all of , and have and . Yet the first has a minimum, the second a maximum, and the third neither.
Concavity and points of inflexion
The sign of tells you whether a graph goes up or down. The sign of tells you which way it bends. These are separate: a falling graph can still bend upwards.
To find one: solve (and note any where is undefined but is defined, such as for ), then check that changes sign there. Both parts matter. For , is at the origin but positive on both sides, so the graph stays concave-up and the origin is a minimum.
The gradient at a point of inflexion can be , as for at the origin. Often it is not. Either way, the there crosses the curve.
In context, the gradient is a rate of change. At a point of inflexion it has a local maximum or minimum. So that is where the rate of change is greatest or least, compared with nearby times.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) and . Concave-up needs : , so .
- (b) at . and , so the sign changes and the concavity changes.
- . The point of inflexion is .
- (c) . Downloads were growing fastest on day 10, at about 600 thousand a day. After that they keep rising, but more slowly each day.
Often is hard to solve by hand. Find yourself, graph and find its zeros. Check that the graph crosses the axis there, not just touches it.
Another GDC route: graph and find its local maximum and minimum points. Their -values are where the concavity of changes.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Product rule: .
- Again: , which is as required.
- (b) Write down what you graph: . Its zeros are and
- The graph crosses the axis at each zero, so changes sign and both are points of inflexion: and weeks.
- (c) At , changes from concave-up to concave-down, so has a local maximum. The number with flu is rising fastest then, at about people a week.
Common mistakes
- Dropping the inner factor when you differentiate again: the derivative of is . Write the product or chain rule out in full for each derivative.
- Squaring the first derivative instead of differentiating it. means differentiate once more.
- Writing "minimum" with no reason. Give or its sign and the conclusion, such as " for all , so the stationary point is a minimum".
- Calling a point a point of inflexion just because there. Check that changes sign: has and a minimum.
- Using the sign of for concavity. Increasing is about ; concave-up is about .
- Leaving out units or context in the final answer, such as giving 161.58 with no dollars, or a time with no units. Answer the question in its own terms.
Exam tips
- "Find ": show the first derivative and each rule you use. The method marks are for the product or chain rule seen in your working.
- "Justify" or "show that" a stationary point is a minimum: substitute its -value into (or explain why is always positive) and state the conclusion. The reasoning mark needs both the sign and the word "minimum".
- "Hence or otherwise find the points of inflexion": write the equation , or say you are finding the turning points of the graph of , before you give the GDC values to 3 s.f.
- "Interpret": say which rate is greatest or least at the point of inflexion, in the units of the question.
Key takeaways
Practise this
4 past-paper questions on Second order derivatives and concavity in the AI HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.