Shapes of molecules (VSEPR)
In a minute
The electron pairs around a central atom repel each other, so they spread out as far apart as they can. Count the in the , and the gives you the shape and the bond angles. and double bonds squeeze some of those angles.
You'll be able to
- Count the electron domains around a central atom, counting a double or triple bond as one domain.
- Predict the and bond angle for two, three or four domains.
- Predict and name the when the central atom has lone pairs.
- Explain how lone pairs and multiple bonds change bond angles.
- Judge how useful the VSEPR model is, and where it falls short.
Before you start2 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 2.2 Covalent bonds and Lewis formulas
Electron domains and the VSEPR model
Electrons are negatively charged, so electron pairs around an atom repel each other. They spread out as far apart as they can, like balloons tied together at their knots.
The (valence shell electron pair repulsion) uses this idea to predict shapes. Start from the (2.2) and look at the central atom.
A double bond counts as one because all four of its electrons sit between the same two atoms. They point in one direction.
1. Two domains: linear, .
2. Three domains, in one flat plane: trigonal planar, .
3. Four domains: tetrahedral, . This is wider than the of a flat square, so four domains are never flat.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Four bonds and no lone pairs: four domains.
- Four identical domains sit furthest apart at the corners of a tetrahedron.
- Silicon has four bonding pairs and no lone pairs, so it has four electron domains. The domains repel each other and get as far apart as possible. The electron domain geometry is tetrahedral and the F–Si–F bond angle is .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Each double bond is one domain, and there are no lone pairs: two domains.
- Check: counting each double bond twice would wrongly give four domains.
- Carbon has two electron domains, because each double bond counts as one domain and there are no lone pairs. The two domains repel to opposite sides of the carbon atom. The electron domain geometry is linear and the S=C=S bond angle is .
Lone pairs and molecular geometry
A takes up a domain, so it helps decide where the bonds point. But a shape is named from the positions of the atoms only. So a molecule with lone pairs has two geometries.
With no lone pairs on the central atom, the two geometries are the same. With lone pairs, they differ.
A lone pair is held by only one nucleus. Its electron cloud sits closer to the central atom and spreads wider than a bonding pair, so it repels more strongly.
1. Four domains, no lone pairs: tetrahedral, .
2. Four domains, one lone pair: trigonal pyramidal, about .
3. Four domains, two lone pairs: bent (V-shaped or angular), about .
4. Three domains, one lone pair: bent, about .
5. Two domains, or any molecule of two atoms: linear, .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Three bonding pairs plus one lone pair: four domains, tetrahedral.
- Atoms sit at only three corners, a pyramid. The lone pair squeezes the bonds below .
- Nitrogen has three bonding pairs and one lone pair, so it has four electron domains and a tetrahedral electron domain geometry. The lone pair repels more strongly than the bonding pairs and pushes the bonds closer together. The molecular geometry is trigonal pyramidal, with a Cl–N–Cl bond angle of about .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Two bonding pairs and two lone pairs: four domains, tetrahedral. Atoms sit at only two corners: bent.
- Two lone pairs squeeze harder than one, so the angle is below . The measured value, about , agrees.
- Sulfur has two bonding pairs and two lone pairs, so the electron domain geometry is tetrahedral. The two lone pairs repel more strongly than the bonding pairs. The molecular geometry is bent, with a predicted Cl–S–Cl bond angle of about .
Multiple bonds, and how good the model is
A double bond packs four electrons into one domain, so it repels the other domains more strongly than a single bond does.
The domain geometry stays the same. But the angles next to the double bond open up, and the angle between the single bonds closes.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Three bonded atoms, no lone pairs: trigonal planar, about .
- The domain repels harder and pushes the bonds together. Measured: Cl–C–Cl about , Cl–C=O about .
- Carbon has three electron domains and no lone pairs, so the molecular geometry is trigonal planar. The C=O double bond has more electron density than a C–Cl single bond, so it repels more strongly. The Cl–C=O angles are greater than and the Cl–C–Cl angle is less than .
How useful is the VSEPR model? From a Lewis formula alone, it predicts the right shape for most molecules and ions. It also predicts which way lone pairs and double bonds move the angles.
Its limits: the angles are estimates. It says nothing about the orbitals that form bonds. And it is only as good as the Lewis formula you start from.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Model: four domains, one a lone pair, so a trigonal pyramid at about .
- Data: the shape is right, but the angle is about smaller.
- The VSEPR model correctly predicts that phosphine is trigonal pyramidal, because phosphorus has four electron domains, one of them a lone pair. It predicts a bond angle of about , but the measured angle is . So the model is useful for predicting shapes, but its bond angles are only approximate.
Common mistakes
- Leaving lone pairs off the Lewis formula, so you count too few domains. Draw every lone pair on the central atom before you count.
- Counting a double or triple bond as two or three domains. Count each bonded atom once, however many pairs join it.
- Giving the electron domain geometry when the question asks for the molecular geometry. The domains in are tetrahedral, but the molecule is trigonal pyramidal.
- Saying a lone pair repels less because it is not in a bond. It repels more: it sits closer to the central atom and spreads wider.
Exam tips
- State the molecular geometry: the name earns the mark. Explain it: give the bonding pairs and lone pairs, then say the domains repel to get as far apart as possible.
- To deduce a bond angle, give a number. With lone pairs, pick a value below the parent angle, such as about ; mark schemes often accept a sensible range.
- In Paper 1A, options often pair an electron domain geometry with a molecular geometry. Work out both before you read the options.
Key takeaways
Practise this
161 past-paper questions on Lewis structures, VSEPR, hybridization, formal charge and resonance in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.