7.4 · CorePaper 5Paper 6

Graphs, conclusions and evaluation

In a minute

After the readings come the marks for using them: calculating, plotting a graph with a , reading a or intercept, and writing a conclusion backed by numbers. Then you judge the experiment and suggest improvements.

You'll be able to

  • Process readings with a calculator, and plot a graph with labelled axes, a good scale and a .
  • Find a gradient or an intercept from a graph, using and .
  • Write a conclusion that quotes the data, and decide whether two results are equal within ±10%.
  • Spot an , tell random from , and say why a conclusion may be uncertain.
  • Evaluate a method, including its , and suggest useful improvements.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A distance–time graph is a straight line from the origin to (40 s,120 m)(40\ \text{s}, 120\ \text{m}). What is its gradient, in m/s?
Check yourself
A student changes the length of a pendulum and times its swings. Which is the ?
Check yourself
An ammeter reads 0.02 A0.02\ \text{A} before the switch is closed. With the switch closed it reads 0.36 A0.36\ \text{A}. What is the true current, in A?

Revise first: 1.2 Motion, 7.2 Planning investigations and 7.3 Taking and recording measurements

Processing data and plotting graphs

Readings often need a calculation first, such as a mean or R=VIR = \frac{V}{I}.

Give calculated values to 2 or 3 significant figures, no more than the least precise reading. Give a mean to its readings' decimal places.

Worked exampleA student reads 2.6 V2.6\ \text{V} on the voltmeter and 0.38 A0.38\ \text{A} on the ammeter. Calculate the resistance of the lamp, to a suitable number of significant figures.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. R=VI=2.60.38=6.842…R = \frac{V}{I} = \frac{2.6}{0.38} = 6.842…
Worked exampleA student times a ball rolling down a long slope three times: 2.47 s2.47\ \text{s}, 2.53 s2.53\ \text{s} and 2.41 s2.41\ \text{s}. Calculate the mean time.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Add the readings and divide by 3: 2.47+2.53+2.413=7.413=2.47 s\frac{2.47 + 2.53 + 2.41}{3} = \frac{7.41}{3} = 2.47\ \text{s}.

A good graph has five features. 1. Each axis labelled quantity / unit, such as current / A.

2. A scale where the points fill more than half the grid each way. 3. An easy scale, such as 1, 2 or 5 (or 0.5, 20…) per large square, never 3 or 7.

4. Each point plotted to within half a small square. 5. One best-fit line.

It needn't pass through every point or the origin. Rule it if the trend is straight; otherwise draw a smooth curve.

Check yourself
Loads go from 0 to 4.6 N4.6\ \text{N} on a grid 10 large squares tall. Which scale is best?
Check yourself
A trolley travels 1.50 m1.50\ \text{m} in 2.37 s2.37\ \text{s}. What is its average speed, in m/s, to 3 significant figures?

Gradients, intercepts and reading values

Reading a value between your plotted points is . Extending the line beyond them, for example back to an axis, is . Always read from the line, not from one point.

Speed-time graph for a trolley. Time in seconds from 0 to 3.5 is on the horizontal axis, with small squares of 0.1 seconds. Speed in metres per second from 0 to 1.8 is on the vertical axis, with small squares of 0.1 metres per second. Six crosses at times 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 seconds have speeds 0.63, 0.79, 0.98, 1.14, 1.33 and 1.50 metres per second. A straight best-fit line passes close to all of them, and a dashed extension of it meets the speed axis at 0.45 metres per second, labelled intercept. A large right-angled triangle under the line has corners on the line at 0.40 seconds, 0.59 metres per second and at 3.40 seconds, 1.64 metres per second. Its horizontal side is labelled 3.00 s and its vertical side 1.05 m/s. 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 time / s speed / (m/s) 3.00 s 1.05 m/s intercept 0.45 m/s
A trolley rolling down a slope: a gradient triangle and an intercept.

To find a , draw a triangle covering more than half the line. A big triangle keeps reading errors small.

Learn this
gradient=change in ychange in x\text{gradient} = \frac{\text{change in } y}{\text{change in } x}

A gradient's unit is the yy unit ÷ the xx unit. The intercept is the value of yy where the line meets x=0x = 0, and it has the yy unit. If the xx scale doesn't start at 0, don't read it where the line crosses the drawn axis.

Worked exampleUse the graph above. Determine the gradient, and say what it tells you.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Take two points on the line, far apart: (0.40 s,0.59 m/s)(0.40\ \text{s}, 0.59\ \text{m/s}) and (3.40 s,1.64 m/s)(3.40\ \text{s}, 1.64\ \text{m/s}).
Extended only

The gradient of a speed–time graph is the acceleration, so this trolley's acceleration is a=0.35 m/s2a = 0.35\ \text{m/s}^2 (1.2).

Worked exampleThe first reading was taken at 0.5 s0.5\ \text{s}. Use the graph to find the trolley's speed at t=0t = 0.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. t=0t = 0 is outside the readings, so extrapolate: extend the line back to the speed axis.
Check yourself
Read from the graph above: what is the trolley's speed at t=2.2 st = 2.2\ \text{s}, in m/s?
Check yourself
A graph has extension / cm on the yy-axis and load / N on the xx-axis. What is the unit of its gradient?

Conclusions and the ±10% rule

A conclusion answers the experiment's question, then gives the evidence from the graph or table.

Be as exact as the data allow. A straight line is a linear relationship. Directly proportional needs a straight line through the origin.

Worked exampleFrom the trolley graph, a student concludes that speed is directly proportional to time. Explain whether the graph supports this.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Check both conditions, straight and through the origin, and quote the graph.

Real readings rarely agree exactly. At IGCSE, two results agree within the limits of experimental if they differ by 10% or less.

Find the difference, then give it as a percentage of one value: the value predicted by theory, if there is one. Then say whether they agree, quoting both values.

Worked exampleA student predicts that a pendulum's period doesn't depend on the mass of the bob. She measures a period of 1.42 s1.42\ \text{s} with a light bob and 1.47 s1.47\ \text{s} with a heavy one. Comment on whether her results support the prediction.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Difference: 1.47−1.42=0.05 s1.47 - 1.42 = 0.05\ \text{s}, and 0.051.47×100≈3%\frac{0.05}{1.47} \times 100 \approx 3\%.
Check yourself
Two methods give the focal length of a lens as 9.6 cm9.6\ \text{cm} and 10.9 cm10.9\ \text{cm}. What is the difference as a percentage of 10.9 cm10.9\ \text{cm}, to 2 significant figures?
Check yourself
Two density values for the same metal differ by 4%. Which conclusion is best?

Anomalies, errors and uncertainty

Graph of current against potential difference for a resistor. P.d. in volts from 0 to 3.0 is on the horizontal axis, with small squares of 0.1 volts. Current in amperes from 0 to 0.70 is on the vertical axis, with small squares of 0.02 amperes. Crosses at 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 volts have currents 0.10, 0.21, 0.32, 0.52, 0.52 and 0.63 amperes. The point at 2.0 volts and 0.52 amperes is circled and labelled anomaly: it lies well above the line through the others. A straight best-fit line passes through the origin and close to the other five points, ignoring the circled point. 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 p.d. / V current / A anomaly
One reading doesn't fit the pattern. The best-fit line ignores it.

Check an anomaly by repeating that reading. If you can't, leave it out of the mean or best-fit line, circle it, and say so.

Worked exampleA toy car's times down a ramp are 3.12 s3.12\ \text{s}, 3.08 s3.08\ \text{s}, 3.71 s3.71\ \text{s} and 3.15 s3.15\ \text{s}. Identify the anomaly, then calculate a mean to 3 significant figures.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. 3.71 s3.71\ \text{s} is far from the other three, so it is the anomaly.

Measurement error is the difference between a measured value and the true value. It comes in two kinds.

Causes include hand timing with a stopwatch, or a flickering reading. Repeating and taking a mean reduces their effect.

A is the classic cause. Repeats don't help, because every repeat is shifted too. Correct the readings or the instrument instead.

Worked exampleIn melting ice at 0 °C0\ \text{°C}, a thermometer reads 2 °C2\ \text{°C}. Assume it reads 2 °C2\ \text{°C} too high at every temperature. Explain what type of error this causes and how to deal with it.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Is every reading wrong the same way, or do they scatter?

A conclusion carries more with few readings, a small , widely scattered points, or values close to the 10% limit.

Check yourself
Three readings of the same time are 2.31 s2.31\ \text{s}, 2.45 s2.45\ \text{s} and 2.38 s2.38\ \text{s}. What does the scatter show?
Check yourself
Which of these reduces the effect of random error?

Evaluating and improving an experiment

To evaluate a method, ask: was it a fair test? If a changed, the results can't show the effect of the independent variable alone.

Then find the biggest source of error. A good improvement is specific and says how it helps.

Common ones: repeat and calculate a mean; more readings over a wider range; time many oscillations and divide; light gates instead of a stopwatch; smaller scale divisions.

Worked exampleA student times 20 complete oscillations of a pendulum and gets 31.4 s31.4\ \text{s}. Calculate the period, and explain why timing 20 oscillations is better than timing one.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. One oscillation: 31.420=1.57 s\frac{31.4}{20} = 1.57\ \text{s}.
Worked exampleA student lets a toy car roll down a ramp from any point on it. She times it with a hand-held stopwatch, once for each ramp height. Suggest two improvements and say how each helps.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Look for a control variable that changed, then for the largest measurement error.
Check yourself
A mass on a spring makes 10 complete up-and-down oscillations in 8.6 s8.6\ \text{s}. What is the time for one oscillation, in s?
Check yourself
A student tests how a wire's length affects its resistance, using thin wire for short lengths and thick wire for long ones. What is wrong?

Common mistakes

  • Drawing dot to dot or a thick line. Draw one thin best-fit line.
  • Calling a line proportional "because it goes up". It must be straight and pass through the origin.
  • Saying two results differ because the numbers aren't identical. Give the difference as a percentage of one value (the predicted one, if any) and compare with 10%.
  • Writing "repeat it" without "calculate a mean", or "be more careful". Name the change and how it helps.

Exam tips

  • "Plot": each point within half a small square, axes labelled quantity / unit.
  • "Determine" a gradient: show the triangle and write down the readings used.
  • "Comment" on agreement: quote both values, give the difference as a percentage of one value (the predicted one, if any), compare with 10%, then conclude.
  • "Suggest" an improvement: name the change and what it improves.

Key takeaways

Learn thisGraphs: axes labelled quantity / unit, an easy scale filling over half the grid, one thin best-fit line or smooth curve.
Learn thisgradient=change in ychange in x\text{gradient} = \frac{\text{change in } y}{\text{change in } x}
Learn thisGradient: use a triangle covering over half the line, corners on the line. Unit = yy unit ÷ xx unit.
Learn thisDirectly proportional: a straight line through the origin. A straight line that misses the origin is linear but not proportional.
Learn thisAt IGCSE, two results agree within experimental accuracy if their difference is 10% or less of one of them (the predicted value, if there is one).
Learn thisRandom error scatters readings both ways: repeat and take a mean to reduce its effect. Systematic error, such as a zero error, shifts every reading the same way: correct the readings or the instrument.
Learn thisAnomaly: repeat it if you can; otherwise leave it out of the mean and best-fit line, and say so.
Learn thisImprovements are specific and say how they help: repeat and take a mean, a wider range, time many oscillations, light gates.

Practise this

387 past-paper questions on Experimental skills and investigations in the 0625 Extended bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Experimental skills and investigations →