7.2 · CorePaper 5Paper 6

Planning investigations

24 min read

In a minute

A planning question asks you to design an experiment you won't carry out. You decide what to change, what to measure and what to keep the same, choose the values and apparatus, keep it safe, and say how the results will answer the question.

You'll be able to

  • Identify the and the , and describe how and explain why to control the others.
  • Suggest how many values to use and their , and choose and justify the apparatus or technique.
  • Describe a method with its risks and precautions, a results table, and how the results lead to a conclusion.
  • Make a prediction with a physics reason, and judge whether results support it.
Before you start2 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A student measures the same length three times: 4.2 cm4.2\ \text{cm}, 4.6 cm4.6\ \text{cm} and 4.4 cm4.4\ \text{cm}. What is the mean, in cm?
Check yourself
Which instrument measures the current in a circuit?

Variables and a fair test

Every investigation asks how one quantity affects another, such as how the drop height of a ball affects how high it bounces.

Anything else that could affect the dependent variable is a . Keep each one the same for every reading. This makes the experiment a fair test.

Why? If two things change at once, you can't tell which one caused the change in your results. A fair test has : it tests what it says it tests.

Worked exampleA student drops a tennis ball from different heights onto the floor and measures how high it bounces. Identify the independent and dependent variables, and name two control variables.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. She chooses the drop height, so that is what she changes.

To describe how you control a variable, say what stays the same and how. "Keep the current constant" is weaker than "adjust the variable resistor so the ammeter shows the same current each time".

Worked exampleA student winds wire around an iron nail to make an electromagnet. She investigates how the number of turns affects how many paper clips it picks up. Describe how she should control the current, and explain why.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The current also changes an electromagnet's strength, so it is a control variable.
Check yourself
A student changes the length of a vibrating guitar string and measures the frequency of the note. Which is the dependent variable?
Check yourself
A student tests how the area of a paper parachute affects its fall time. Why must she hang the same mass of plasticine on each parachute?

Choosing values and apparatus

Next, choose the values of the independent variable. Plan at least five different values, so a graph shows a clear pattern and an stands out.

Spread them evenly over a wide , from the smallest to the largest sensible value. A narrow range can hide the pattern. Give real values with units, and check your apparatus can reach them.

Worked exampleA student investigates how the distance between a lamp and a small solar cell affects the current from the cell. Her bench allows distances up to about 80 cm. Suggest a suitable number and range of distances, and explain your choice.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Pick at least five values.
Check yourself
A student plans six equally spaced loads from 1.5 N1.5\ \text{N} to 9.0 N9.0\ \text{N}. What is the step between loads, in N?

Then choose apparatus. Pick an instrument whose range reaches the largest reading and whose scale divisions are small compared with the reading, and justify it with a reason. A technique can help too, such as timing 10 oscillations of a pendulum and dividing by 10. 7.1 covers the common choices.

Worked exampleThe solar cell gives a current of about 40 mA. The student can use an ammeter reading 0–5 A in 0.1 A divisions, or a milliammeter reading 0–100 mA in 2 mA divisions. Suggest which to use, and justify your choice.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Convert: 40 mA=0.04 A40\ \text{mA} = 0.04\ \text{A}.
Check yourself
To test how the angle of a ramp affects a trolley's speed, a student plans angles of 10°, 11°, 12°, 13° and 14°. What is the main problem?

Writing the plan: method, safety and results

Papers 5 and 6 usually include a planning question. It lists what your plan must contain: work through that list in order.

A full plan covers: 1. apparatus, including any you add; 2. the method in clear steps; 3. the control variables and how you keep them the same.

4. A risk in this experiment, such as hot water or falling masses, and the precaution that matches it. 5. A results table. 6. How the results lead to a conclusion.

Write the method so someone else could follow it: what to set up, what to measure and with what, then "repeat for each value". Repeat each reading and calculate a mean.

In the table, put the independent variable first, then the dependent variable, with columns for repeats and the mean. Head each column quantity / unit, such as mass / g, so the boxes hold numbers only.

To reach a conclusion, plot the dependent variable (yy-axis) against the independent variable (xx-axis) and describe the pattern. A straight line through the origin means they are directly proportional.

Side view of a ruler clamped to the edge of a bench with a G-clamp. Part of the ruler sticks out past the bench edge: this overhang length is marked with a double-headed arrow and kept constant. A hanger with slotted masses hangs from the free end, which bends down below its starting level, shown by a dashed horizontal line. The drop of the end below that line is marked d, the deflection. A vertical metre rule stands just beyond the end to measure its height. A tray of sand sits on the floor under the masses. overhang length (kept constant) G-clamp ruler bench d masses on a hanger tray of sand metre rule
A loaded ruler bends down by a deflection dd.
Worked examplePlan an experiment to find how the mass hung on the end of a ruler clamped to a bench, as in the figure, affects how far the end bends down. A 100 g hanger and 100 g slotted masses are available. Include extra apparatus, method, control variables, a risk and precaution, a results table and how to reach a conclusion.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Independent variable: the mass. Dependent variable: the deflection dd. Anything else that changes the bend is a control variable.
Check yourself
In a results table, which quantity goes in the first column?
Check yourself
A student plots mean deflection against mass. The points lie close to a straight line through the origin. What can she conclude?

Predictions and testing them

A prediction says what you expect to happen. A reasoned prediction adds why, using physics you know.

Weak: "the bounce height will change". Better: "the bounce height will increase as the drop height increases, because the ball has more kinetic energy when it hits the floor".

Worked examplePredict how the fall time of a paper parachute carrying the same load changes as its area increases. Give a reason.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. State the direction of the change, then the physics behind it.

Afterwards, compare the results with the prediction. At IGCSE, a predicted and a measured value agree within the limits of experimental if they differ by 10% or less of the predicted value (7.4).

Worked exampleFor the ruler experiment, a student predicts that doubling the mass doubles the deflection. With 200 g she measures 14 mm, and with 400 g she measures 27 mm. Explain whether her results support the prediction.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Predicted deflection for 400 g: 2×14=28 mm2 \times 14 = 28\ \text{mm}.
Check yourself
A student adds identical cells in series to a circuit with one lamp. Which is the best reasoned prediction?

Common mistakes

  • Naming a control variable without saying how it is kept the same.
  • Writing "different values" instead of at least five real values, with units, over a wide range.
  • Leaving units out of table headings, or writing "repeat" without "calculate a mean".
  • Giving a prediction with no physics reason.

Exam tips

  • "Identify" a variable: name the exact quantity, such as "bounce height", not just "the ball".
  • "Describe how" to control a variable: name the apparatus and what stays the same. "Explain why": it would also change the dependent variable.
  • In a planning question, answer every point in the list you are given, in order.

Key takeaways

Learn thisIndependent variable: what you change. Dependent variable: what you measure. Control variables: anything else that could affect the result, kept the same so the test is fair.
Learn thisTo control a variable, say how you keep it the same, such as setting the same current with a variable resistor and an ammeter. Explain why: it also affects the dependent variable.
Learn thisValues: at least five, with units, evenly spaced over a wide range.
Learn thisJustify apparatus or a technique with a reason, such as a range that reaches the reading with scale divisions small compared with it, or timing 10 oscillations to get a larger time to measure.
Learn thisPlan: apparatus, method, control variables, a risk and its precaution, a results table, and how to reach a conclusion.
Learn thisResults table: independent variable first, headings as quantity / unit, columns for repeats and the mean. Plot the dependent variable against the independent variable.
Learn thisA reasoned prediction gives the expected change and the physics reason. At IGCSE, a numerical prediction is supported if the measured value differs from it by 10% or less of the predicted value.

Practise this

387 past-paper questions on Experimental skills and investigations in the 0625 Extended bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Experimental skills and investigations →