1.18 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Space–time diagrams and muon decay

In a minute

A plots events with ctct up and xx across, so light always travels at 45∘45^{\circ}. An object moving at constant velocity has a straight at angle θ\theta to the ctct axis, with tan⁡θ=v/c\tan\theta = v/c. show that and really happen.

You'll be able to

  • Draw and read a , with for objects at rest, moving objects and light.
  • Use tan⁡θ=v/c\tan\theta = v/c to link a world line's angle to a speed.
  • Draw a moving frame's axes, read coordinates in it, judge , set its scale, and see time dilation and length contraction on the diagram.
  • Explain, with calculations, how give evidence for time dilation and length contraction.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A spacecraft moves at 0.70c0.70c relative to the Earth. Calculate the γ\gamma. Give 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A clock on a spaceship ticks twice. Who measures the between the ticks?
Check yourself
Two events in frame S are separated by Δx=5.0 m\Delta x = \pu{5.0 m} and cΔt=13.0 mc\Delta t = \pu{13.0 m}. Calculate the (Δs)2(\Delta s)^2, in m2\text{m}^2.

Revise first: 1.15 Reference frames and Galilean relativity, 1.16 The postulates of special relativity and Lorentz transformations and 1.17 Time dilation, length contraction and simultaneity

Space–time diagrams

In 1.15 an event had a position xx and a time tt in a . A puts every event of one frame on one graph: xx across and ctct up.

Multiplying a time by cc turns it into a distance, how far light goes in that time. So both axes share one unit (m, km or ly).

To turn ctct into a time, divide by c=3.00⋅108 m s−1c = \pu{3.00e8 m s-1} (from the data booklet). So ct=600 mct = \pu{600 m} means t=2.00⋅10−6 st = \pu{2.00e-6 s}. In light-years it is easier: ct=1 lyct = \pu{1 ly} means t=1t = 1 year.

An object at rest keeps one xx, so its is vertical. Light moves one unit of xx for each unit of ctct, so its world line is at 45∘45^{\circ}, leaning right or left. An object moving at constant velocity, slower than light, has a straight world line in between, leaning left if it moves towards −x-x.

Space-time diagram with x in kilometres on the horizontal axis and c t in kilometres on the vertical axis, both from 0 to 6 with the same scale. Three world lines are drawn. A vertical line at x equals 4 kilometres is the world line of a lamp at rest. A dashed line at 45 degrees from the origin is the world line of a light pulse. It meets the lamp's world line at event E, at x equals 4 kilometres and c t equals 4 kilometres. A third straight line from the origin to x equals 3, c t equals 6 is the world line of a particle moving at 0.50 c. The angle theta between this world line and the c t axis is marked. 11 22 33 44 55 66 0 x / km ct / km lamp at rest light pulse particle at 0.50c θ E
A lamp at rest (vertical), a particle at 0.50c0.50c (tilted) and a light pulse (45∘45^{\circ}).
Worked exampleA lamp is at rest at x=4.0 kmx = \pu{4.0 km} in frame S. At t=0t = 0 a light pulse leaves the origin towards it. Describe both world lines, and determine the time in S at which the pulse reaches the lamp.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The lamp's world line is vertical, through x=4.0 kmx = \pu{4.0 km}. The pulse's is the 45∘45^{\circ} line through the origin.
Worked exampleIn frame S, event P is at x=0.6 kmx = \pu{0.6 km}, ct=1.5 kmct = \pu{1.5 km}; Q is at x=2.1 kmx = \pu{2.1 km}, ct=1.5 kmct = \pu{1.5 km}; and R is at x=0.6 kmx = \pu{0.6 km}, ct=3.9 kmct = \pu{3.9 km}. State which two events are simultaneous in S, and determine the time between P and R in S.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. P and Q have the same ctct: they are on one horizontal line, so they are simultaneous in S.
Check yourself
A buoy floats at rest in frame S. What does its world line look like on a space–time diagram for S?
Check yourself
Light leaves x=0x = 0 at t=0t = 0 in frame S and reflects straight back from a mirror at rest at x=2.7 kmx = \pu{2.7 km}. What is the ctct coordinate, in km, of its return to x=0x = 0? Give 2 significant figures.

The angle of a world line

An object leaves the origin at constant speed vv. After time tt it is at x=vtx = vt, and the time coordinate is ctct. Its world line runs from the origin to the point (vt, ct)(vt,\ ct).

Let θ\theta be the angle between the world line and the ctct axis. In the right-angled triangle, the side opposite θ\theta is vtvt and the side next to it is ctct, so tan⁡θ=vtct\tan\theta = \frac{vt}{ct}.

In the formula booklet
tan⁡θ=vc\tan\theta = \frac{v}{c}

This is in the data booklet. θ\theta is measured from the ctct axis, vv is the speed in the frame of the diagram, and both axes must have the same scale.

The gradient of a world line on the page is Δ(ct)Δx=cv\frac{\Delta(ct)}{\Delta x} = \frac{c}{v}, the inverse of tan⁡θ\tan\theta. From two points on a world line, use vc=ΔxΔ(ct)\frac{v}{c} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta(ct)}.

Worked exampleA probe's world line, on a space–time diagram for frame S, passes through the origin and the event x=1.5 kmx = \pu{1.5 km}, ct=5.0 kmct = \pu{5.0 km}. Determine the speed of the probe in S.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. tan⁡θ=vc=ΔxΔ(ct)=1.55.0=0.30\tan\theta = \frac{v}{c} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta(ct)} = \frac{1.5}{5.0} = 0.30, so v=0.30cv = 0.30c.
Worked exampleA spacecraft moves in the −x-x direction of frame S at 2.1⋅108 m s−1\pu{2.1e8 m s-1}. Calculate the angle between its world line and the ctct axis, and state which way the world line leans.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. vc=2.1×1083.00×108=0.70\frac{v}{c} = \frac{2.1 \times 10^{8}}{3.00 \times 10^{8}} = 0.70.
Check yourself
A particle moves at 0.250c0.250c in frame S. What angle, in degrees, does its world line make with the ctct axis? Give 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A particle with mass and a light pulse leave the same event in the same direction. How does the particle's world line compare with the pulse's?

Two frames on one diagram

Frame S′ moves at velocity vv along xx relative to S; the origins meet at t=t′=0t = t' = 0. Its axes can go on S's diagram.

The ct′ct' axis is every event with x′=0x' = 0: the world line of the origin of S′. So it leans from the ctct axis by θ\theta, where tan⁡θ=vc\tan\theta = \frac{v}{c}.

The x′x' axis is every event with t′=0t' = 0. Setting t′=0t' = 0 in the gives ct=vcxct = \frac{v}{c}x: a line tilted up from the xx axis by the same angle θ\theta.

As vv grows, the primed axes close in on the 45∘45^{\circ} light line from both sides. The light line is shared, because by the both frames measure light at cc.

Space-time diagram for frame S, with a horizontal x axis and a vertical c t axis meeting at origin O. The axes of frame S prime, moving at 0.50 c in the positive x direction, are drawn through the same origin. The c t prime axis is tilted to the right of the c t axis by an angle theta. The x prime axis is tilted up from the x axis by the same angle theta. A dashed 45 degree light line lies between the two primed axes. An event E is marked. A dashed line from E parallel to the x prime axis meets the c t prime axis, giving E's c t prime coordinate. A dashed line from E parallel to the c t prime axis meets the x prime axis, giving E's x prime coordinate. Dotted lines from E parallel to the x and c t axes give its coordinates in S. x ct O light, 45° ct′ x′ θ θ ct′ of E x′ of E ct of E x of E E
Read S′ coordinates with lines parallel to the primed axes (here v=0.50cv = 0.50c).

To find ct′ct' for event E, draw a line through E parallel to the x′x' axis to meet the ct′ct' axis. For x′x', draw a line through E parallel to the ct′ct' axis to meet the x′x' axis.

Worked exampleIn frame S, event A is at x=1.0 kmx = \pu{1.0 km}, ct=1.0 kmct = \pu{1.0 km} and event B is at x=6.0 kmx = \pu{6.0 km}, ct=3.0 kmct = \pu{3.0 km}. Frame S′ moves in the +x+x direction, and in S′ the events are simultaneous. Determine the speed of S′ relative to S.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. In S′ the events are simultaneous, so line AB is parallel to the x′x' axis. (In S, A happens first.)

One unit on the ct′ct' axis is longer on the page than one unit on ctct. The fixes the scale.

An event on the ct′ct' axis has x′=0x' = 0, so (Δs)2=(ct′)2(\Delta s)^2 = (ct')^2. In S, (Δs)2=(ct)2−x2(\Delta s)^2 = (ct)^2 - x^2. So the tick ct′=1ct' = 1 lies on the curve (ct)2−x2=1(ct)^2 - x^2 = 1, a line of constant space–time interval.

Space-time diagram for frame S, with x in light-years on the horizontal axis and c t in light-years on the vertical axis, both from 0 to 4. The axes of frame S prime, moving at 0.60 c, are drawn through the origin: the c t prime axis tilts right of the c t axis and the x prime axis tilts up from the x axis, either side of a dashed 45 degree light line. Four grey curves are lines of constant space-time interval. Each curve crosses the c t axis at 1, 2, 3 and 4 light-years and bends to the right, approaching the light line. Where the curves cross the c t prime axis, the ticks are labelled c t prime equals 1, 2, 3 and 4 light-years. The first tick, c t prime equals 1 light-year, is level with c t equals 1.25 light-years. Ticks at x prime equals 1, 2 and 3 light-years are marked along the x prime axis, further from the origin than the matching ticks on the x axis. 11 22 33 44 0 x / ly ct / ly ct′ / ly 1 2 3 4 x′ / ly 1 2 3 1.25
Lines of constant interval set the ct′ct' ticks (here v=0.60cv = 0.60c, so γ=1.25\gamma = 1.25).

On the ct′ct' axis x=vcctx = \frac{v}{c}ct, so (ct)2−x2=(ct′)2(ct)^2 - x^2 = (ct')^2 gives ct=γ ct′ct = \gamma\,ct'. Curves x2−(ct)2=(x′)2x^2 - (ct)^2 = (x')^2 set the x′x' ticks the same way.

Worked exampleFrame S′ moves at 0.50c0.50c relative to S. A clock at the origin of S′ reads ct′=6.0 kmct' = \pu{6.0 km}. Determine the ctct coordinate of this event in S, and explain what it shows.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. On the ct′ct' axis x′=0x' = 0, so (Δs)2=6.02=36 km2(\Delta s)^2 = 6.0^2 = \pu{36 km2}. In S the event has x=0.50 ctx = 0.50\,ct.

Length works the same way. S′ measures a rod at rest in S′ along a line parallel to x′x': its . S measures between the same two world lines along a horizontal line, and gets a length shorter by γ\gamma: .

Check yourself
Frame S′ moves at 0.50c0.50c relative to S. Event O is at the origin. In S, P is at (x,ct)=(2.0 km,4.0 km)(x, ct) = (\pu{2.0 km}, \pu{4.0 km}), Q at (4.0 km,2.0 km)(\pu{4.0 km}, \pu{2.0 km}), R at (4.0 km,0)(\pu{4.0 km}, 0) and T at (3.0 km,3.0 km)(\pu{3.0 km}, \pu{3.0 km}). Which event is simultaneous with O in S′?
Check yourself
Frame S′ moves at 0.28c0.28c relative to S. A clock at the origin of S′ reads ct′=4.8 lyct' = \pu{4.8 ly}. What is the ctct coordinate of this event in S, in ly? Give 2 significant figures.

Muon decay: evidence for relativity

Cosmic rays hitting the upper atmosphere, typically 10 to 15 km up, make unstable particles called muons. Many travel down at over 0.99c0.99c.

At rest, muons decay with a mean lifetime of about 2.2 μs2.2\ \mu\text{s}. Decay is random: this is an average.

Classically, even at cc a muon covers only 3.00×108×2.2×10−6=660 m3.00 \times 10^{8} \times 2.2 \times 10^{-6} = \pu{660 m} in one mean lifetime. From several kilometres up, almost every muon should decay before reaching the ground.

A finds far more at sea level than this predicts. Relativity explains the number, in either frame.

**Earth frame.** The moving muon's clock runs slow, so its mean lifetime is dilated to Δt=γΔt0\Delta t = \gamma\Delta t_0. Here Δt0=2.2 μs\Delta t_0 = 2.2\ \mu\text{s} is the proper time, in the muon's frame.

**Muon frame.** The muon is at rest and lives 2.2 μs2.2\ \mu\text{s} on average, while the atmosphere rushes past. Its thickness, a proper length L0L_0 in the Earth frame, is contracted to L=L0γL = \frac{L_0}{\gamma}.

Two panels. Left panel, Earth frame: a shaded atmosphere 6.0 kilometres thick above a detector at sea level. A muon at the top moves straight down at 0.994 c. A note says its mean lifetime is dilated to about 20 microseconds. Right panel, muon frame: the muon is at rest at the top of a much thinner shaded layer, 0.66 kilometres thick, with the detector at its lower edge. The layer moves up towards the muon at 0.994 c. A note says the atmosphere is contracted and the mean lifetime is 2.2 microseconds. Earth frame Muon frame detector at sea level muon 0.994c 6.0 km mean lifetime dilatedto about 20 µs detector moving up 0.994c muon at rest 0.66 km atmosphere contracted;mean lifetime 2.2 µs
One journey, two frames: time dilation (Earth) and length contraction (muon).
Worked exampleMuons are produced 6.0 km\pu{6.0 km} above a detector at sea level and travel straight down at 0.994c0.994c. Their mean lifetime at rest is 2.2 μs2.2\ \mu\text{s}. Calculate their mean lifetime in the Earth frame, and compare it with the travel time.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Travel time: t=6.0×1030.994×3.00×108=2.01⋅10−5 st = \frac{6.0 \times 10^{3}}{0.994 \times 3.00 \times 10^{8}} = \pu{2.01e-5 s}.
Worked exampleExplain, with a calculation, how an observer moving with the muons in the previous example accounts for the number reaching the detector.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Muons at rest: use the proper lifetime. Atmosphere moving at 0.994c0.994c: L=6.09.14=0.66 kmL = \frac{6.0}{9.14} = \pu{0.66 km}.
Check yourself
In the frame of a muon moving down through the atmosphere, which effect explains why it reaches the ground before decaying?
Check yourself
Muons move down at 0.980c0.980c through a layer of air 4.0 km\pu{4.0 km} thick in the Earth frame. What is its thickness in the muons' frame, in m? Give 2 significant figures.

Common mistakes

  • Reading S′ coordinates off the S grid. Draw lines parallel to the primed axes; one unit on ct′ct' is longer than one on ctct.
  • Saying a muon's lifetime is dilated in its own frame. There it lives the proper 2.2 μs2.2\ \mu\text{s}; the atmosphere is contracted instead.
  • Calling events simultaneous “for everyone”. Events at different places, simultaneous in one frame, are not simultaneous in a frame moving relative to it.

Exam tips

  • “Draw the x′x' axis”: a straight line from the origin, tilted up from xx by the same angle as ct′ct' is tilted from ctct.
  • “Determine the speed” from a diagram: read two far-apart points on the world line or ct′ct' axis and use v=c ΔxΔ(ct)v = c\,\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta(ct)}, as a fraction of cc or in m s−1\text{m s}^{-1}.
  • “Identify the simultaneous events” for an observer: draw a line through one event parallel to that observer's xx axis, and name the events on it.

Key takeaways

Learn thisA space–time diagram plots ctct against xx, same scale, for one inertial frame. Points are events; histories are world lines.
Learn thisAt rest: vertical world line. Light: 45∘45^{\circ}. Constant velocity v<cv < c: straight and steeper than light.
In booklettan⁡θ=vc\tan\theta = \frac{v}{c}
Learn thisFrame S′ at speed vv: ct′ct' leans θ\theta from ctct; x′x' leans θ\theta up from xx. Lines parallel to x′x' join events simultaneous in S′.
Learn thisLines of constant interval, (ct)2−x2=constant(ct)^2 - x^2 = \text{constant}, set the primed scales. On the ct′ct' axis, ct=γ ct′ct = \gamma\,ct'.
Learn thisFar more muons reach sea level than classical physics predicts. Earth frame: lifetime dilated to γΔt0\gamma\Delta t_0. Muon frame: atmosphere contracted to L0/γL_0/\gamma.

Practise this

89 past-paper questions on Special relativity and spacetime in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Special relativity and spacetime →