3.4 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Ionization energy trends and transition elements

In a minute

The dips in first across a period show that each main energy level is split into . In the the 3d sublevel is only partly filled. That gives them , coloured compounds, catalytic and magnetic properties, high melting points and .

You'll be able to

  • Explain how the dips in first ionization energy across a period are evidence for sublevels, using the energy of the electron removed.
  • Recognize the characteristic properties of transition elements and link them to the incomplete d sublevel.
  • Describe a complex ion using and , and find its charge or the metal's ; argue for and against counting scandium and zinc.
  • Write the of a period 4 transition-metal , removing 4s before 3d.
  • Explain variable oxidation states using successive ionization energies that rise without a large jump.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
Iron has atomic number 26. Which is the condensed of an iron atom?
Check yourself
In a , where do the two shared electrons come from?
Check yourself
What is the of manganese in manganese dioxide, MnOX2\ce{MnO2}? Include the sign.

Revise first: 1.4 Sublevels, orbitals and electron configurations, 1.5 Ionization energy, 2.2 Covalent bonds and Lewis formulas, 2.10 The metallic model, 3.1 The periodic table and periodicity and 3.3 Oxidation states

Dips in first ionization energy: evidence for sublevels

Across a period the nuclear charge rises by one each time, while the outer electrons stay in the same main energy level with similar . So the first ionization energy generally rises.

If every electron in a main energy level had the same energy, the rise would be smooth. Instead period 2 has two dips, at boron and at oxygen (data booklet, section 9).

To explain a dip, look at **which electron is removed**. The higher its energy, the less energy is needed to remove it.

Orbital diagrams of the 2s and 2p sublevels of beryllium, boron, nitrogen and oxygen, with the electron removed on ionization highlighted Be 2s 2p removed: 2s B 2s 2p removed: 2p N 2s 2p removed: 2p O 2s 2p removed: paired 2p highlighted arrow = the electron removed in first ionization
The electron removed (highlighted) in the first ionization of Be, B, N and O.

**Beryllium to boron.** Beryllium loses a 2s electron, but boron loses a 2p electron. The 2p is higher in energy than 2s, and the 2p electron is partly shielded by the 2s pair. So boron's electron needs less energy to remove: 801 kJ mol−1\pu{801 kJ mol-1} against 900 kJ mol−1\pu{900 kJ mol-1}.

**Nitrogen to oxygen.** In nitrogen each 2p electron is alone in its , as predicts. In oxygen the fourth 2p electron must share an orbital. Repulsion between the paired electrons raises their energy, so one is removed more easily: 1314 kJ mol−1\pu{1314 kJ mol-1} against 1402 kJ mol−1\pu{1402 kJ mol-1}.

Worked exampleThe first ionization energy of boron is lower than that of beryllium, although boron has one more proton. Explain how this provides evidence for sublevels.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Say which electron each atom loses: beryllium 1s2 2s2\mathrm{1s^{2}\,2s^{2}} loses a 2s electron; boron 1s2 2s2 2p1\mathrm{1s^{2}\,2s^{2}\,2p^{1}} loses a 2p electron.
Worked exampleExplain why the first ionization energy of oxygen is lower than that of nitrogen. Base your answer on the electron removed.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Draw the 2p boxes: nitrogen [↑][↑][↑][\uparrow][\uparrow][\uparrow], oxygen [↑↓][↑][↑][\uparrow\downarrow][\uparrow][\uparrow].
Check yourself
The first ionization energy falls from zinc (906 kJ mol−1\pu{906 kJ mol-1}) to gallium (579 kJ mol−1\pu{579 kJ mol-1}). Which is the best explanation?
Check yourself
Which observation is evidence that the second main energy level is split into sublevels?

Transition elements and their properties

A has an incomplete d sublevel in its atom or in one of its common . In period 4 this covers scandium to copper, although scandium is a borderline case (see below).

1. **Variable oxidation states.** Iron forms FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+} and FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+}; the next section explains why.

2. **High melting points.** Both the 4s and 3d electrons can be delocalized, so the metallic bonding is strong (see 2.10).

3. **Magnetic properties.** Unpaired d electrons make many transition-element compounds attracted into a magnetic field. Iron, cobalt and nickel metals are strongly magnetic. You don't need to name the types of magnetism.

4. **Catalytic properties.** Iron catalyses the Haber process, nickel the hydrogenation of alkenes and manganese(IV) oxide the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide. Variable oxidation states let a catalyst pass electrons to and from reactants.

5. **Coloured compounds.** Hydrated copper(II) sulfate is blue and aqueous nickel(II) chloride green; 3.5 explains why.

6. **Complex ions.** A transition-element ion can accept lone pairs from several molecules or ions at once.

Common are HX2O\ce{H2O}, NHX3\ce{NH3}, ClX−\ce{Cl^-}, OHX−\ce{OH^-} and CNX−\ce{CN^-}. Each has at least one lone pair. In a the ligands are written inside square brackets with the overall charge outside, as in [Ni(HX2O)X6]X2+\ce{[Ni(H2O)6]^2+}.

The complex ion hexaaquanickel(II): a central nickel 2+ ion with six water ligands, each joined by a coordination bond drawn as an arrow from oxygen to nickel H2O H2O H2O H2O H2O H2O Ni2+ 2+ each arrow: a coordination bond, lone pair from O to the nickel ion
[Ni(HX2O)X6]X2+\ce{[Ni(H2O)6]^2+}: each arrow is a coordination bond, the lone pair coming from the oxygen of a water ligand.

The charge of a complex is the charge of the metal ion plus the charges of the ligands. Neutral ligands such as HX2O\ce{H2O} and NHX3\ce{NH3} add nothing.

Worked exampleA green complex of chromium has the formula [Cr(HX2O)X4ClX2]X+\ce{[Cr(H2O)4Cl2]^+}. Deduce the oxidation state of chromium in it.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Let the oxidation state of chromium be xx. Water ligands are neutral; each chloride ligand is −1-1.

Zinc sits in the d-block but is not a transition element. Scandium is a borderline case: its atom, [Ar] 4s2 3d1\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{2}\,3d^{1}}, has an incomplete d sublevel, so it meets the definition. Against that, its only ion, ScX3+\ce{Sc^3+}, has no d electrons at all. So scandium has one oxidation state and colourless compounds, and lacks most of the characteristic properties.

Worked exampleExplain why zinc is not considered a transition element, although it is in the d-block.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Write the atom and its only ion: Zn\ce{Zn} is [Ar] 4s2 3d10\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{2}\,3d^{10}} and ZnX2+\ce{Zn^2+} is [Ar] 3d10\mathrm{[Ar]\,3d^{10}}.
Check yourself
Which is **not** a characteristic property of transition elements?
Check yourself
Which molecule cannot act as a ligand?

Ions of transition elements and variable oxidation states

In a neutral atom 4s fills before 3d. But once the atom is ionized, the 4s electrons are the outermost and highest in energy, so **4s electrons are removed before 3d electrons**.

So most period 4 transition elements form a +2+2 ion by losing both 4s electrons.

Worked exampleVanadium has atomic number 23. Deduce the of the VX3+\ce{V^3+} ion.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Write the atom first: 23 electrons give [Ar] 4s2 3d3\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{2}\,3d^{3}}.

Chromium and copper keep their atom exceptions: Cr\ce{Cr} is [Ar] 4s1 3d5\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{1}\,3d^{5}} and Cu\ce{Cu} is [Ar] 4s1 3d10\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{1}\,3d^{10}}. The 4s electron still leaves first.

Why can transition elements lose different numbers of electrons? Compare the of calcium and manganese.

Line graph of the first eight successive ionization energies of calcium and manganese 0 5000 10000 15000 20000 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 number of electrons removed ionization energy / kJ mol⁻¹ manganese (Mn) calcium (Ca) big jump big jump
Calcium jumps after 2 electrons (both 4s\mathrm{4s} electrons gone). Manganese rises steadily through all seven 4s and 3d electrons, then jumps.

Calcium's third electron would come from the full 3p sublevel of a lower main energy level, so the energy jumps. Calcium only ever forms CaX2+\ce{Ca^2+}.

In manganese the 4s and 3d sublevels are close in energy. Its successive ionization energies rise gradually across all seven 4s and 3d electrons, with no large jump. The energy for each extra electron can be repaid by stronger bonding in the compound.

So a is characteristic of transition elements. Manganese shows +2+2 in MnClX2\ce{MnCl2}, +4+4 in MnOX2\ce{MnO2} and +7+7 in MnOX4X−\ce{MnO4^-}, the highest, using all seven 4s and 3d electrons.

Worked exampleCalcium forms only CaX2+\ce{Ca^2+}, but manganese forms compounds with oxidation states from +2+2 to +7+7. Explain this difference using successive ionization energies.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Calcium: where does the third electron come from, and what happens to the ionization energy?
Check yourself
Copper has atomic number 29. Which is the electron configuration of the CuX+\ce{Cu^+} ion?
Check yourself
Which ion has the same electron configuration as MnX2+\ce{Mn^2+}? (Atomic numbers: Cr 24, Mn 25, Fe 26, Co 27.)
Check yourself
How many unpaired electrons does a gaseous FeX3+\ce{Fe^3+} ion have? Iron has atomic number 26.
Check yourself
In the MnOX4X−\ce{MnO4^-} ion manganese has an oxidation state of +7+7. Which of manganese's electrons are involved?

Common mistakes

  • Explaining the boron or oxygen dip by the stability of a full 2s or half-full 2p sublevel. Use the energy of the electron removed.
  • Removing 3d electrons before 4s when writing a transition-metal ion. The 4s electrons always leave first.
  • Writing [Ar] 4s2 3d4\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{2}\,3d^{4}} for chromium or [Ar] 4s2 3d9\mathrm{[Ar]\,4s^{2}\,3d^{9}} for copper. Both atoms have only one 4s electron.
  • Saying a ligand gains or accepts electrons. A ligand donates a lone pair; the metal ion accepts it.
  • Saying zinc has no d electrons. It has ten; the 3d sublevel is full in the atom and in ZnX2+\ce{Zn^2+}.

Exam tips

  • "Explain" an ionization energy dip: name the sublevel (or paired orbital) the electron comes from, say its energy is higher, then say less energy is needed. One marking point per sentence.
  • "Deduce" the configuration of a transition-metal ion: write the atom first, then remove 4s electrons before 3d. Either the full form or the [Ar]\mathrm{[Ar]} form earns the mark.
  • In Paper 1A questions on complexes, add up the metal ion's charge and each ligand's charge, remembering that HX2O\ce{H2O} and NHX3\ce{NH3} are neutral.
  • "Outline" the bond between a ligand and a metal ion: a coordination bond, with both electrons of the pair coming from the ligand.

Key takeaways

Learn thisThe drops in first ionization energy from group 2 to 13 (a p electron is higher in energy than an s electron) and from group 15 to 16 (a paired p electron is raised by repulsion) are evidence for sublevels.
Learn thisExplain ionization energy dips by the energy of the electron removed, never by the "special stability" of full or half-full sublevels.
Learn thisTransition elements have an incomplete d sublevel in the atom or a common ion. Properties: variable oxidation states, high melting points, magnetic properties, catalytic activity, coloured compounds and complex ions.
Learn thisZinc is not a transition element: Zn\ce{Zn} and ZnX2+\ce{Zn^2+} both have a full 3d sublevel. Scandium is borderline: ScX3+\ce{Sc^3+} has no d electrons.
Learn thisA ligand donates a lone pair to a metal ion through a coordination bond. A complex ion's charge is the metal ion's charge plus the ligands' charges.
Learn thisIons of first-row transition elements lose their 4s electrons before their 3d electrons.
Learn thisIn transition elements, variable oxidation states arise because the 4s and 3d electrons are close in energy, so successive ionization energies rise gradually with no large jump.

Practise this

76 past-paper questions on Transition elements and complexes in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Transition elements and complexes →