4.7 · AHL · HL onlyPaper 1Paper 2

Gibbs energy and spontaneity

In a minute

Whether a reaction can happen on its own depends on two things: the and the change. The change in , ΔG=ΔH−TΔS\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S, combines them into one number. A negative ΔG\Delta G means the change is spontaneous, and as reactants react, ΔG\Delta G rises to zero at equilibrium.

You'll be able to

  • Calculate ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus from ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus, ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus and TT, with consistent units, using data from the data booklet.
  • Explain how ΔG\Delta G accounts for the entropy change of both the and the surroundings.
  • Use the sign of ΔG\Delta G to decide whether a change is spontaneous, and find the crossover temperature where the sign changes.
  • Describe how ΔG\Delta G changes as a reaction approaches equilibrium, and calculate with ΔG=ΔG⊖+RTln⁡Q\Delta G = \Delta G^\ominus + RT\ln Q and ΔG⊖=−RTln⁡K\Delta G^\ominus = -RT\ln K.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
A reaction is carried out at 45 ∘C\pu{45 ^\circ C}. What is this temperature in , to the nearest kelvin?
Check yourself
Which change has a positive entropy change, ΔS\Delta S?
Check yourself
Methanoic acid can decompose: HCOOH(l)→CO(g)+HX2O(l)\ce{HCOOH(l) -> CO(g) + H2O(l)}. Use the S⊖S^\ominus values in section 13 of the data booklet to calculate ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus, in J K−1 mol−1\pu{J K-1 mol-1}. Include the sign.

Revise first: 1.1 The particulate nature of matter, 1.9 Ideal gases, 4.1 Measuring enthalpy changes, 4.3 Enthalpies of formation and combustion and 4.6 Entropy

Gibbs energy

Two things push a change forward. Releasing heat (a negative ΔH\Delta H) helps, and so does an increase in entropy (a positive ΔS\Delta S). In 4.6 you met entropy; now you put the two together.

Often they pull in opposite directions. Ice melting is an change, yet it happens on its own above 0 ∘C\pu{0 ^\circ C} because the entropy increase wins. Temperature decides which effect matters more.

The change in also measures useful energy. When ΔG\Delta G is negative, at constant temperature and pressure, its size is the most energy the reaction can supply as useful work, such as electrical energy from a cell.

In the formula booklet
ΔG⊖=ΔH⊖−TΔS⊖\Delta G^\ominus = \Delta H^\ominus - T\Delta S^\ominus

This equation is in section 1 of the data booklet. Watch the units: ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus and ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus are in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}, but ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus is in J K−1 mol−1\pu{J K-1 mol-1}. Divide ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus by 1000 before you substitute, and always put TT in kelvin.

Worked exampleFor NX2OX4(g)→2 NOX2(g)\ce{N2O4(g) -> 2NO2(g)}, ΔH⊖=+57.2 kJ mol−1\Delta H^\ominus = \pu{+57.2 kJ mol-1} and ΔS⊖=+176 J K−1 mol−1\Delta S^\ominus = \pu{+176 J K-1 mol-1}. Calculate ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus at 298 K\pu{298 K}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Convert ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus to kJ: +0.176 kJ K−1 mol−1\pu{+0.176 kJ K-1 mol-1}.
Worked exampleEthanol is made industrially from ethene and steam: CX2HX4(g)+HX2O(g)→CX2HX5OH(l)\ce{C2H4(g) + H2O(g) -> C2H5OH(l)}. Use section 13 of the data booklet to calculate ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus at 298 K\pu{298 K}.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus from enthalpies of formation (4.3): −278−(52+(−242))=−88 kJ mol−1-278 - (52 + (-242)) = \pu{-88 kJ mol-1}.
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔH⊖=−46.0 kJ mol−1\Delta H^\ominus = \pu{-46.0 kJ mol-1} and ΔS⊖=−99.0 J K−1 mol−1\Delta S^\ominus = \pu{-99.0 J K-1 mol-1}. Calculate ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus, in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}, at 400 K\pu{400 K}. Give 3 significant figures and include the sign.
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔH⊖=+31.0 kJ mol−1\Delta H^\ominus = \pu{+31.0 kJ mol-1} and ΔS⊖=+92.5 J K−1 mol−1\Delta S^\ominus = \pu{+92.5 J K-1 mol-1}. What is ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus at 360 K\pu{360 K}?

The sign of $\Delta G$ and spontaneity

Where does the surroundings' entropy come in? A reaction that releases heat warms its surroundings, so their entropy rises by −ΔHT-\frac{\Delta H}{T}. Heat taken in lowers it by the same amount. This is the indirect entropy change.

The direct change is ΔS\Delta S of the system itself. The total is ΔStotal=ΔS−ΔHT\Delta S_\text{total} = \Delta S - \frac{\Delta H}{T}. Multiply by −T-T and you get ΔH−TΔS\Delta H - T\Delta S, which is ΔG\Delta G. So a negative ΔG\Delta G means total entropy increases.

A need not be fast. Methane and oxygen have a very negative ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus, but a mixture of them sits unchanged until a spark supplies the activation energy. ΔG\Delta G tells you whether a change can happen, not how quickly.

Graph of standard Gibbs energy change against absolute temperature for four kinds of reaction. Each line starts at the left axis at the value of delta H and slopes with gradient minus delta S. The horizontal line through zero divides the non-spontaneous region above from the spontaneous region below. Delta H negative, delta S positive: starts below zero and falls further, so it is always spontaneous. Delta H positive, delta S negative: starts above zero and rises, so it is never spontaneous. Delta H positive, delta S positive: starts above zero and falls, crossing zero at a crossover temperature, so it is spontaneous above that temperature. Delta H negative, delta S negative: starts below zero and rises, crossing zero at a crossover temperature, so it is spontaneous below that temperature. ΔG⦵ / kJ mol⁻¹ 0 T / K non-spontaneous (ΔG⦵ > 0) spontaneous (ΔG⦵ < 0) ΔH < 0, ΔS > 0: always ΔH > 0, ΔS < 0: never ΔH > 0, ΔS > 0: above crossover ΔH < 0, ΔS < 0: below crossover crossover crossover
ΔG⊖=ΔH⊖−TΔS⊖\Delta G^\ominus = \Delta H^\ominus - T\Delta S^\ominus is a straight line in TT. As TT rises, the TΔS⊖T\Delta S^\ominus term matters more.

Read the four cases from the graph. If ΔH\Delta H is negative and ΔS\Delta S positive, ΔG\Delta G is negative at every temperature. If ΔH\Delta H is positive and ΔS\Delta S negative, it is never negative.

If ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S have the same sign, there is a crossover temperature where ΔG=0\Delta G = 0. Both positive: spontaneous above it. Both negative: spontaneous below it.

To find the crossover, set ΔG⊖=0\Delta G^\ominus = 0, so T=ΔH⊖ΔS⊖T = \frac{\Delta H^\ominus}{\Delta S^\ominus}. This assumes ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus and ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus barely change with temperature, which is close enough for IB calculations.

Worked exampleAmmonium nitrate dissolves in water at room temperature, and the solution gets colder. Explain why it dissolves spontaneously.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. The solution cools, so the change is endothermic: give the sign of ΔH\Delta H.
Worked exampleFor ZnCOX3(s)→ZnO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{ZnCO3(s) -> ZnO(s) + CO2(g)}, ΔH⊖=+68.8 kJ mol−1\Delta H^\ominus = \pu{+68.8 kJ mol-1} and ΔS⊖=+175 J K−1 mol−1\Delta S^\ominus = \pu{+175 J K-1 mol-1}. Determine the temperature above which the decomposition is spontaneous.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Both values are positive, so the reaction becomes spontaneous above a crossover temperature.
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔH⊖<0\Delta H^\ominus < 0 and ΔS⊖<0\Delta S^\ominus < 0. Under which conditions is it spontaneous?
Check yourself
Use section 13 of the data booklet to find the temperature, in K, above which HX2O(l)→HX2O(g)\ce{H2O(l) -> H2O(g)} is spontaneous at 100 kPa\pu{100 kPa}. Give 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔG⊖=−210 kJ mol−1\Delta G^\ominus = \pu{-210 kJ mol-1} at 298 K\pu{298 K}, but no change is seen when the reactants are mixed. Which statement is correct?

$\Delta G$ and equilibrium

ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus is a single value for standard conditions. A real mixture is rarely standard, and its composition changes as it reacts. The value of ΔG\Delta G for the actual mixture changes too.

Graph of the Gibbs energy of a reaction mixture against its composition, from pure reactants on the left to pure products on the right. The curve starts high on the left, falls to a minimum about two thirds of the way across, then rises a little to the right end, which is lower than the left end. The minimum is labelled equilibrium, where the slope is zero and delta G equals zero. Left of the minimum the curve slopes down towards it, labelled delta G negative, forward reaction spontaneous. Right of the minimum it slopes up away from it, labelled delta G positive, reverse reaction spontaneous. The drop from the left end to the right end is labelled delta G standard. Gibbs energy of the mixture, G pure reactants pure products composition of the mixture ΔG⦵ equilibrium slope 0, ΔG = 0 ΔG < 0: forward reaction spontaneous ΔG > 0: reverse spontaneous
ΔG\Delta G is the slope of the curve. It is negative on the way down to the minimum and zero at the minimum.

The data booklet (section 1) links ΔG\Delta G to the QQ, which is the equilibrium expression filled in with the mixture's actual concentrations: ΔG=ΔG⊖+RTln⁡Q\Delta G = \Delta G^\ominus + RT\ln Q. Here RR is the , 8.31 J K−1 mol−1\pu{8.31 J K-1 mol-1} (section 2).

At equilibrium ΔG=0\Delta G = 0 and QQ equals the KK. Substituting gives ΔG⊖=−RTln⁡K\Delta G^\ominus = -RT\ln K, also in section 1. Use the natural log, and divide RTRT by 1000 to get kJ.

The sign of ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus tells you where equilibrium lies. If ΔG⊖<0\Delta G^\ominus < 0, K>1K > 1 and products are favoured. If ΔG⊖>0\Delta G^\ominus > 0, K<1K < 1 and reactants are favoured, though some product still forms. If ΔG⊖=0\Delta G^\ominus = 0, K=1K = 1.

Worked exampleAn esterification has K=4.20K = 4.20 at 298 K\pu{298 K}. Calculate ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus for the reaction.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use ΔG⊖=−RTln⁡K\Delta G^\ominus = -RT\ln K with R=8.31 J K−1 mol−1R = \pu{8.31 J K-1 mol-1}.
Worked exampleFor NX2OX4(g)⇌2 NOX2(g)\ce{N2O4(g) <=> 2NO2(g)}, ΔG⊖=+4.75 kJ mol−1\Delta G^\ominus = \pu{+4.75 kJ mol-1} at 298 K\pu{298 K}. A mixture at 298 K\pu{298 K} has Q=0.0100Q = 0.0100. Calculate ΔG\Delta G for this mixture and deduce which way it reacts.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Use ΔG=ΔG⊖+RTln⁡Q\Delta G = \Delta G^\ominus + RT\ln Q, with RTRT in kJ.
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔG⊖=+25 kJ mol−1\Delta G^\ominus = \pu{+25 kJ mol-1} at 298 K\pu{298 K}. Which best describes its equilibrium mixture at this temperature?
Check yourself
A reaction has ΔG⊖=−12.0 kJ mol−1\Delta G^\ominus = \pu{-12.0 kJ mol-1} at 310 K\pu{310 K}. Calculate KK to 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A mixture of pure reactants starts to react. What happens to ΔG\Delta G as the mixture approaches equilibrium?

Common mistakes

  • Mixing kJ and J. ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus is given in J K−1 mol−1\pu{J K-1 mol-1}, so divide it by 1000 before combining it with ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus.
  • Using a Celsius temperature in TΔST\Delta S or RTln⁡KRT\ln K. Convert to kelvin first.
  • Giving a negative temperature as the crossover. When ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S have opposite signs, there is no crossover temperature at all.
  • Saying a spontaneous reaction is fast. ΔG\Delta G shows whether a change can happen on its own; the rate depends on the activation energy.
  • Thinking a positive ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus means no products form. It means K<1K < 1, so reactants are favoured but some products are present.

Exam tips

  • "Calculate" ΔG⊖\Delta G^\ominus: write ΔG⊖=ΔH⊖−TΔS⊖\Delta G^\ominus = \Delta H^\ominus - T\Delta S^\ominus, substitute with ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus already in kJ, and give the answer with its sign and kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}.
  • "Determine" the crossover temperature: set ΔG⊖=0\Delta G^\ominus = 0, show T=ΔH⊖ΔS⊖T = \frac{\Delta H^\ominus}{\Delta S^\ominus} with matching units, and give TT in K.
  • "Explain" spontaneity: state the signs of ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S, compare TΔST\Delta S with ΔH\Delta H, then conclude with the sign of ΔG\Delta G, one point per sentence.
  • In Paper 1A sign questions, picture the straight line ΔG⊖=ΔH⊖−TΔS⊖\Delta G^\ominus = \Delta H^\ominus - T\Delta S^\ominus: at low TT the ΔH\Delta H term decides, at high TT the TΔST\Delta S term does.

Key takeaways

In bookletΔG⊖=ΔH⊖−TΔS⊖\Delta G^\ominus = \Delta H^\ominus - T\Delta S^\ominus
Learn thisDivide ΔS⊖\Delta S^\ominus (in J K−1 mol−1\pu{J K-1 mol-1}) by 1000 before using it with ΔH⊖\Delta H^\ominus (in kJ mol−1\pu{kJ mol-1}). TT is always in kelvin.
Learn thisAt constant temperature and pressure, ΔG<0\Delta G < 0 means spontaneous, ΔG>0\Delta G > 0 non-spontaneous, and ΔG=0\Delta G = 0 at equilibrium. Spontaneous says nothing about rate.
Learn thisΔH<0\Delta H < 0, ΔS>0\Delta S > 0: always spontaneous. ΔH>0\Delta H > 0, ΔS<0\Delta S < 0: never. Same signs: spontaneous above (+,++,+) or below (−,−-,-) the crossover T=ΔHΔST = \frac{\Delta H}{\Delta S}.
In bookletΔG=ΔG⊖+RTln⁡Q\Delta G = \Delta G^\ominus + RT\ln Q, and at equilibrium ΔG⊖=−RTln⁡K\Delta G^\ominus = -RT\ln K (data booklet, section 1).
Learn thisΔG⊖<0\Delta G^\ominus < 0: K>1K > 1, products favoured. ΔG⊖>0\Delta G^\ominus > 0: K<1K < 1, reactants favoured but some products still form.

Practise this

91 past-paper questions on Entropy, Gibbs energy and spontaneity in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Entropy, Gibbs energy and spontaneity →