5.2 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Limiting reactants, yield and atom economy

In a minute

The runs out first, so it decides the : the most product you could make. Real reactions give less, and the compares the with that maximum. asks a different question: how much of the reactants' mass ends up in the product you want, rather than as waste.

You'll be able to

  • Identify the limiting and excess reactants from masses or solution concentrations.
  • Use the limiting reactant to calculate the theoretical yield of a product.
  • Distinguish theoretical from experimental yield, and suggest errors that make a yield too low or too high.
  • Calculate a percentage yield, including problems where you first find the limiting reactant.
  • Calculate atom economy from an equation and explain why a low atom economy means more waste.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
How many of potassium chloride, KCl\ce{KCl}, are in 7.45 g\pu{7.45 g}? Give 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
In NX2(g)+3 HX2(g)→2 NHX3(g)\ce{N2(g) + 3H2(g) -> 2NH3(g)}, how many moles of hydrogen react with 0.250 mol\pu{0.250 mol} of nitrogen?
Check yourself
How many moles of solute are in 25.0 cm3\pu{25.0 cm3} of a solution whose is 0.120 mol dm−3\pu{0.120 mol dm-3}?

Revise first: 1.6 The mole and molar mass, 1.8 Concentration and Avogadro's law, 2.12 Polymers and 5.1 Chemical equations and reacting quantities

Limiting and excess reactants

A bike needs one frame and two wheels. With 10 frames and 14 wheels you can build only 7 bikes. The wheels run out first, and 3 frames are left over.

Reactions work the same way. Reactants are rarely mixed in exactly the ratio of the equation, so one of them runs out first and the reaction stops.

Any other reactant is in excess: some of it is still there when the reaction stops. For a reaction that goes to completion, adding more of an excess reactant makes no more product.

Particle diagram for hydrogen reacting with oxygen to make water. The left box, before, holds six hydrogen molecules and five oxygen molecules. An arrow leads to the right box, after, which holds six water molecules and two oxygen molecules that did not react, ringed and labelled excess. Hydrogen ran out first, so it is the limiting reactant. Before: 6 H2 + 5 O2 After: 6 H2O + 2 O2 left react excess O2 hydrogen atom oxygen atom 2 H2 + O2 → 2 H2O
In 2 HX2+OX2→2 HX2O\ce{2H2 + O2 -> 2H2O}, six HX2\ce{H2} need only three OX2\ce{O2}. Hydrogen is limiting and two OX2\ce{O2} are left in excess.

Notice that there were fewer oxygen molecules than hydrogen molecules, yet oxygen was in excess. The smaller amount is not always the limiting one: the equation's ratio decides.

1. Work out the amount, in , of each reactant.

2. Divide each amount by that reactant's coefficient in the balanced equation.

3. The smallest result belongs to the . Use its amount, with the mole ratio, to find the amount of product.

The mass of product you would get if all of the limiting reactant turned into it, with nothing lost, is the .

Worked exampleA mixture of 3.25 g\pu{3.25 g} of zinc powder and 2.00 g\pu{2.00 g} of sulfur is heated: Zn(s)+S(s)→ZnS(s)\ce{Zn(s) + S(s) -> ZnS(s)}. Determine the limiting reactant and the theoretical yield, in g, of zinc sulfide.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Amounts, using ArA_\text{r} values from the data booklet (section 7): n(Zn)=3.2565.38=0.04971 moln(\ce{Zn}) = \frac{3.25}{65.38} = \pu{0.04971 mol} and n(S)=2.0032.07=0.06236 moln(\ce{S}) = \frac{2.00}{32.07} = \pu{0.06236 mol}.
Worked example25.0 cm3\pu{25.0 cm3} of 0.200 mol dm−3\pu{0.200 mol dm-3} silver nitrate solution is mixed with 20.0 cm3\pu{20.0 cm3} of 0.150 mol dm−3\pu{0.150 mol dm-3} calcium chloride solution: 2 AgNOX3(aq)+CaClX2(aq)→2 AgCl(s)+Ca(NOX3)X2(aq)\ce{2AgNO3(aq) + CaCl2(aq) -> 2AgCl(s) + Ca(NO3)2(aq)}. Determine the limiting reactant and the theoretical yield, in g, of silver chloride.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Amounts from n=CVn = CV: n(AgNOX3)=0.200×0.0250=0.00500 moln(\ce{AgNO3}) = 0.200 \times 0.0250 = \pu{0.00500 mol} and n(CaClX2)=0.150×0.0200=0.00300 moln(\ce{CaCl2}) = 0.150 \times 0.0200 = \pu{0.00300 mol}.

For gases at the same temperature and pressure, equal volumes hold equal amounts, so you can compare volumes divided by coefficients in the same way.

Check yourself
2.70 g\pu{2.70 g} of aluminium reacts with 7.10 g\pu{7.10 g} of chlorine: 2 Al(s)+3 ClX2(g)→2 AlClX3(s)\ce{2Al(s) + 3Cl2(g) -> 2AlCl3(s)}. Which reactant is limiting?
Check yourself
3.20 g\pu{3.20 g} of methane is burned with 9.60 g\pu{9.60 g} of oxygen: CHX4(g)+2 OX2(g)→COX2(g)+2 HX2O(l)\ce{CH4(g) + 2O2(g) -> CO2(g) + 2H2O(l)}. Calculate the theoretical yield, in g, of carbon dioxide. Give 3 significant figures.

Experimental and percentage yield

The theoretical yield is a calculation. What you actually collect and weigh at the end of the practical is the . It is almost always smaller.

The compares the two. Both yields must be for the same substance and in the same units, either both in grams or both in moles.

Learn this
percentage yield=experimental yieldtheoretical yield×100\text{percentage yield} = \frac{\text{experimental yield}}{\text{theoretical yield}} \times 100

This formula is not in the data booklet, so learn it.

Worked exampleA student heats 6.18 g\pu{6.18 g} of copper(II) carbonate until it has fully decomposed: CuCOX3(s)→CuO(s)+COX2(g)\ce{CuCO3(s) -> CuO(s) + CO2(g)}. They collect 3.62 g\pu{3.62 g} of copper(II) oxide. Calculate the percentage yield.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Amount of the reactant: M(CuCOX3)=63.55+12.01+3(16.00)=123.56 g mol−1M(\ce{CuCO3}) = 63.55 + 12.01 + 3(16.00) = \pu{123.56 g mol-1}, so n=6.18123.56=0.05002 moln = \frac{6.18}{123.56} = \pu{0.05002 mol}.
Worked exampleTitanium is made by reducing titanium(IV) chloride with molten magnesium: TiClX4(g)+2 Mg(l)→Ti(s)+2 MgClX2(l)\ce{TiCl4(g) + 2Mg(l) -> Ti(s) + 2MgCl2(l)}. In a trial run, 375 g\pu{375 g} of TiClX4\ce{TiCl4} reacts with 105 g\pu{105 g} of magnesium and 82.4 g\pu{82.4 g} of titanium is obtained. Determine the percentage yield.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Amounts: M(TiClX4)=47.87+4(35.45)=189.67 g mol−1M(\ce{TiCl4}) = 47.87 + 4(35.45) = \pu{189.67 g mol-1}, so n(TiClX4)=375189.67=1.977 moln(\ce{TiCl4}) = \frac{375}{189.67} = \pu{1.977 mol}. n(Mg)=10524.31=4.319 moln(\ce{Mg}) = \frac{105}{24.31} = \pu{4.319 mol}.

Why is the experimental yield usually lower? The reaction may not go to completion, side reactions may make other products, and some product is lost when it is transferred, filtered or purified.

A yield above 100%100\% is impossible for pure product, so it points to an error. The usual cause is a product that is still wet or contains impurities, which adds to the mass weighed.

Worked exampleA student makes crystals of a salt and weighs them. Explain why the experimental yield is usually less than the theoretical yield. Suggest one error that could make it appear greater than the theoretical yield.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Lower, reason 1: the reaction is incomplete (reversible, too slow, or stopped too early).
Check yourself
1.31 g\pu{1.31 g} of zinc is added to excess copper(II) sulfate solution: Zn(s)+CuSOX4(aq)→ZnSOX4(aq)+Cu(s)\ce{Zn(s) + CuSO4(aq) -> ZnSO4(aq) + Cu(s)}. The dried copper has a mass of 1.12 g\pu{1.12 g}. Calculate the percentage yield to 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A student reports a percentage yield of 112%112\% for a solid product. Which error best explains this?

Atom economy

A 100%100\% yield can still waste a lot. Most reactions make by-products as well as the product you want, and atoms that end up in by-products are often waste.

In the formula booklet
% atom economy=molar mass of desired productmolar mass of all reactants×100\%\ \text{atom economy} = \frac{\text{molar mass of desired product}}{\text{molar mass of all reactants}} \times 100

This equation is in the data booklet. Use the balanced equation and multiply each by its coefficient. Because mass is conserved, the reactants' total equals the products' total.

Two bars of equal length for the reaction of iron(III) oxide with carbon monoxide to make iron. The top bar is the reactants: 159.70 grams of iron(III) oxide plus 84.03 grams of carbon monoxide, 243.73 grams in total. The bottom bar is the same 243.73 grams split into products: 111.70 grams of iron, the desired product, taking 45.8 percent of the bar, and 132.03 grams of carbon dioxide, waste, taking the other 54.2 percent. Reactants Products Fe2O3: 159.70 g 3CO: 84.03 g 2Fe: 111.70 g 3CO2: 132.03 g total 243.73 g in, 243.73 g out desired product: 45.8% waste: 54.2%
Every gram of reactant ends up in a product. Only the iron is wanted, so the atom economy is 45.8%45.8\%.
Worked exampleIn a blast furnace, iron is made by FeX2OX3(s)+3 CO(g)→2 Fe(l)+3 COX2(g)\ce{Fe2O3(s) + 3CO(g) -> 2Fe(l) + 3CO2(g)}. Calculate the atom economy for making iron.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Desired product: 2Fe2\ce{Fe}, so 2×55.85=111.70 g mol−12 \times 55.85 = \pu{111.70 g mol-1}.

The higher the atom economy, the less waste. If no by-product is used, 100−atom economy100 - \text{atom economy} is the percentage of the reactant mass that ends up as by-product waste. Selling or using a by-product cuts the waste.

When the desired product is the only product, the atom economy is 100%100\%. Addition reactions do this, and so does making an , where every monomer ends up in the chain.

Worked examplePropan-2-ol can be made by two routes. Route A: CHX2=CHCHX3+HX2O→CHX3CH(OH)CHX3\ce{CH2=CHCH3 + H2O -> CH3CH(OH)CH3}. Route B: CHX3CHBrCHX3+NaOH→CHX3CH(OH)CHX3+NaBr\ce{CH3CHBrCH3 + NaOH -> CH3CH(OH)CH3 + NaBr}. Explain which route is greener in terms of atom economy.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Route A: propan-2-ol is the only product, so the atom economy is 100%100\%.

Atom economy and percentage yield measure different things. Yield tells you how well the reaction worked in practice. Atom economy is fixed by the equation, before you do anything.

Neither tells the whole story about how efficient or green a process is. Chemists also weigh the energy needed, the rate, the cost of the raw materials, the hazards of the chemicals and solvents, and whether the by-products can be used.

Check yourself
Hydrogen is made from methane and steam: CHX4(g)+HX2O(g)→CO(g)+3 HX2(g)\ce{CH4(g) + H2O(g) -> CO(g) + 3H2(g)}. Calculate the atom economy for making hydrogen, to 3 significant figures.
Check yourself
A reaction has an atom economy of 100%100\%. Which statement must be true?

Common mistakes

  • Choosing the reactant with fewer moles as limiting. Divide each amount by its coefficient before you compare.
  • Calculating the theoretical yield from the reactant in excess. Only the limiting reactant sets how much product can form.
  • Finding percentage yield as product mass over reactant mass. Compare experimental and theoretical yields of the same product.
  • Rounding the theoretical yield before dividing. Carry the unrounded value and round only the final percentage.
  • Forgetting coefficients in atom economy, or leaving a reactant out of the bottom line. Use every reactant in the balanced equation.
  • Treating atom economy as a yield. It comes from the equation alone and doesn't change with how well the practical went.

Exam tips

  • "Determine the limiting reactant": show the amount of each reactant in mol, divide by the coefficients, then name the limiting one. A name with no working earns little.
  • "Calculate the percentage yield": write the theoretical yield as a separate line, then experimental over theoretical times 100, to 3 significant figures.
  • In Paper 1A atom economy questions, multiply by the coefficients before you add; the wrong options are often what you get without them.
  • "Suggest" why a yield is low or above 100%: name a specific practical error and say which way it moves the mass.

Key takeaways

Learn thisTo find the limiting reactant, divide each reactant's amount in mol by its coefficient. The smallest value is limiting.
Learn thisThe theoretical yield is calculated from the limiting reactant, never from a reactant in excess.
Learn thispercentage yield=experimental yieldtheoretical yield×100\text{percentage yield} = \frac{\text{experimental yield}}{\text{theoretical yield}} \times 100
Learn thisYields are lowered by incomplete reaction, side reactions and losses of product. A wet or impure product makes the yield look too high.
In booklet% atom economy=molar mass of desired productmolar mass of all reactants×100\%\ \text{atom economy} = \frac{\text{molar mass of desired product}}{\text{molar mass of all reactants}} \times 100
Learn thisThe lower the atom economy, the more waste. A reaction with one product, such as an addition reaction, has 100%100\% atom economy. Atom economy is not the same as yield.

Practise this

18 past-paper questions on Yield and atom economy in the Chemistry HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Yield and atom economy →