6.3 · SLPaper 1Paper 2

Uncertainties and errors

31 min read

In a minute

Every measurement has an . You record it, carry it through calculations and quote results to sensible . and affect and differently, and shows whether a result agrees with an accepted value.

You'll be able to

  • Tell random from systematic errors, and say how each affects precision and accuracy.
  • Round values to a sensible number of significant figures or decimal places.
  • Record a reading with its , such as (0.34±0.01)(0.34 \pm 0.01) A.
  • Find and and percentage error, and judge whether a result agrees with an accepted value.
  • Work out and interpret and .
  • through sums, differences, products, quotients and powers.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Check yourself
Find the mean of 4.24.2, 4.74.7 and 4.54.5. Give 2 decimal places.
Check yourself
A 60 g\pu{60 g} sample loses 9 g\pu{9 g} of its mass. What percentage of its mass did it lose?
Check yourself
Calculate 5.3×0.01375.3 \times 0.0137. Give 2 significant figures.

Random and systematic errors

Time the same event five times and you get five slightly different readings. Errors come in two kinds.

Random errors come from things you can't control exactly, like reaction time. Systematic errors come from the instrument or method, like a zero error or heat lost in every trial.

Four rows of five measurement dots, each on its own horizontal line, with a dashed vertical line marking the true value through all four rows. Row 1, precise and accurate: the dots are tightly bunched on the true value. Row 2, precise but not accurate, labelled systematic error: the dots are tightly bunched but all well to the right of the true value. Row 3, accurate but not precise, labelled random error: the dots are widely spread, but centred on the true value. Row 4, neither, labelled both kinds of error: the dots are widely spread and centred well to the right of the true value. true value precise and accurate small errors precise, not accurate systematic error accurate, not precise random error neither both kinds of error
Precision is the spread of the dots. Accuracy is where their centre sits.
Worked exampleA newton-meter reads 0.3 N\pu{0.3 N} with nothing hanging from it. A student hangs a stone from it three times and records 4.6 N\pu{4.6 N}, 4.7 N\pu{4.7 N} and 4.6 N\pu{4.6 N}. Explain whether the readings are precise and accurate, and how to correct them.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: the readings agree within 0.1 N\pu{0.1 N}: precise.
Worked exampleA student times a toy car over a marked distance with a hand-held stopwatch. Five trials give times from 1.38 s\pu{1.38 s} to 1.71 s\pu{1.71 s}. Explain the main cause of the spread and how to get a more reliable time.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: varying reaction time is a random error.
Check yourself
A metre rule has lost the first 2 mm\pu{2 mm} of its end. Measuring from that end causes:
Check yourself
Which of these reduces the effect of random errors on a result?

Significant figures

2.50 m\pu{2.50 m} says more than 2.5 m\pu{2.5 m}: the final zero shows the length was measured to the nearest centimetre. Digits that carry this information are .

Non-zero digits always count, and so do zeros between them: 1.05 kg\pu{1.05 kg} has three. Leading zeros never count: 0.0062 m\pu{0.0062 m} has two.

Trailing zeros count after a decimal point: 3.40 s\pu{3.40 s} has three. In a whole number they are unclear, so write 1.3⋅103 m\pu{1.3e3 m} or 1.30⋅103 m\pu{1.30e3 m}, not 1300 m\pu{1300 m}.

Round only the final answer, never along the way.

Worked exampleA toy car travels 2.65 m\pu{2.65 m} in 1.8 s\pu{1.8 s}. Calculate its average speed to an appropriate number of significant figures.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. v=2.651.8=1.4722… m s−1v = \frac{2.65}{1.8} = 1.4722\ldots\ \text{m s}^{-1}.
Worked exampleTwo resistors are connected in series. One is labelled 22.4 Ω22.4\ \Omega and the other is measured as 3.87 Ω3.87\ \Omega. Calculate the total resistance to an appropriate precision.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. In series, resistances add: R=22.4+3.87=26.27 ΩR = 22.4 + 3.87 = 26.27\ \Omega.
Check yourself
How many significant figures are there in 0.04070 m\pu{0.04070 m}?
Check yourself
A trolley of mass 0.250 kg\pu{0.250 kg} accelerates at 3.6 m s−2\pu{3.6 m s-2}. Use F=maF = ma to find the resultant force, in N, to an appropriate number of significant figures.

Recording a measurement with its uncertainty

No instrument gives the exact true value, so every reading comes with an .

Write value ±\pm absolute uncertainty, with the unit: (0.34±0.01)(0.34 \pm 0.01) A, or I=0.34±0.01 AI = 0.34 \pm \pu{0.01 A}. The current lies between 0.33 A\pu{0.33 A} and 0.35 A\pu{0.35 A}.

1. Analogue scale: half the smallest division, unless the reading is harder to judge.

2. Digital display: one unit in the last digit. A balance showing 12.47 g\pu{12.47 g} has an uncertainty of ±0.01 g\pm\pu{0.01 g}.

3. Repeated readings: half the range, largest−smallest2\frac{\text{largest} - \text{smallest}}{2}, if that is bigger than the instrument's uncertainty.

Worked exampleAn analogue ammeter scale is marked every 0.02 A\pu{0.02 A}. The needle points exactly at the 0.34 A\pu{0.34 A} mark. Record the current with its absolute uncertainty.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Analogue scale, so take half the smallest division: 0.022=0.01 A\frac{0.02}{2} = \pu{0.01 A}.
Worked exampleA student times a ball rolling down a ramp five times, with a stopwatch that reads to 0.01 s\pu{0.01 s}: 2.43 s\pu{2.43 s}, 2.38 s\pu{2.38 s}, 2.46 s\pu{2.46 s}, 2.40 s\pu{2.40 s} and 2.44 s\pu{2.44 s}. Record the mean time with its absolute uncertainty.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Mean: 12.115=2.422 s\frac{12.11}{5} = \pu{2.422 s}.
Check yourself
A digital voltmeter displays 3.07 V\pu{3.07 V}. What is the absolute uncertainty in this reading?
Check yourself
A mean length is 15.264 cm\pu{15.264 cm}, with an absolute uncertainty of 0.03 cm\pu{0.03 cm}. How should it be recorded?

Percentage uncertainty and percentage error

±1 mm\pm\pu{1 mm} is tiny on a 2 m\pu{2 m} rod but huge on a 3 mm\pu{3 mm} bead. To compare uncertainties, divide by the value.

Learn this
percentage uncertainty=Δxx×100%\text{percentage uncertainty} = \frac{\Delta x}{x} \times 100\%

Δx\Delta x is the absolute uncertainty in xx. Fractional and percentage uncertainties have no unit; give them to one or two significant figures.

Worked exampleA micrometer gives the diameter of a wire as 0.48±0.01 mm0.48 \pm \pu{0.01 mm}. Calculate the fractional and percentage uncertainties in the diameter.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Fractional: 0.010.48=0.0208…≈0.021\frac{0.01}{0.48} = 0.0208\ldots \approx 0.021, with no unit.

For the same absolute uncertainty, small readings have large percentage uncertainties. To shrink one, measure something bigger: time ten swings instead of one, or measure a stack of 50 sheets and divide by 50.

Learn this
percentage error=∣experimental value−accepted value∣∣accepted value∣×100%\text{percentage error} = \frac{\lvert \text{experimental value} - \text{accepted value} \rvert}{\lvert \text{accepted value} \rvert} \times 100\%
A horizontal number line for g in metres per second squared, marked from 9.0 to 10.0 in steps of 0.1. A dot at 9.4 shows the measured value, with a horizontal bar from 9.1 to 9.7 showing its range. A separate vertical marker at 9.81 shows the accepted value. The accepted value lies to the right of the end of the bar, outside the range. 9.0 9.2 9.4 9.6 9.8 10.0 g / m s⁻² measured: 9.4 ± 0.3 accepted: 9.81
The range 9.4±0.39.4 \pm 0.3 runs from 9.19.1 to 9.79.7. The accepted value, 9.819.81, is outside it.
Worked exampleA student drops a ball through light gates and finds g=9.4±0.3 m s−2g = 9.4 \pm \pu{0.3 m s-2}. The accepted value where the student lives is 9.81 m s−2\pu{9.81 m s-2}. Comment on whether the result agrees with it, and what this suggests.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Marking point 1: the range is 9.19.1 to 9.7 m s−2\pu{9.7 m s-2}, and 9.819.81 lies outside it.
Check yourself
A time is measured as 0.84±0.02 s0.84 \pm \pu{0.02 s}. What is its percentage uncertainty? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
A student uses LEDs to find the Planck constant as 7.1⋅10−34 J s\pu{7.1e-34 J s}. What is the percentage error, compared with the data-booklet value?

Percentage change and percentage difference

Two more percentages compare values, not uncertainties. Which one you use depends on whether one value came first.

Learn this
percentage change=new value−original valueoriginal value×100%\text{percentage change} = \frac{\text{new value} - \text{original value}}{\text{original value}} \times 100\%

A rise gives a positive percentage change and a fall a negative one. Keep the sign.

Worked exampleWhen a thermistor is warmed, its resistance falls from 2.40 kΩ2.40\ \text{k}\Omega to 1.65 kΩ1.65\ \text{k}\Omega. Calculate the percentage change in its resistance.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Change: 1.65−2.40=−0.75 kΩ1.65 - 2.40 = -0.75\ \text{k}\Omega. It is a fall, so it is negative.
Learn this
percentage difference=∣a−b∣12(a+b)×100%\text{percentage difference} = \frac{\lvert a - b \rvert}{\tfrac{1}{2}(a + b)} \times 100\%

Use percentage difference when neither value is the right one or the starting one, such as two groups' results. With an accepted value, use percentage error.

Worked exampleTwo groups measure the speed of water waves in the same ripple tank: 1.46 m s−1\pu{1.46 m s-1} and 1.52 m s−1\pu{1.52 m s-1}. Calculate the percentage difference between their results.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Difference =0.06 m s−1= \pu{0.06 m s-1}; mean =1.46+1.522=1.49 m s−1= \frac{1.46 + 1.52}{2} = \pu{1.49 m s-1}.
Check yourself
A solar panel's output rises from 250 W\pu{250 W} to 320 W\pu{320 W} after cleaning. What is the percentage change? Give 2 significant figures.
Check yourself
Two students find the same spring constant by different methods. There is no accepted value. Which quantity best compares their results?

Propagating uncertainties

Most results are calculated from several measurements, each with its own uncertainty. combines them into the uncertainty of the result.

Three rules cover sums, differences, products, quotients and powers; combine them for longer formulas. They are printed in the data booklet under Uncertainties, so the skill is choosing the right one.

In the formula booklet
y=a±b  ⇒  Δy=Δa+Δby = a \pm b \;\Rightarrow\; \Delta y = \Delta a + \Delta b

1. Adding or subtracting: add the absolute uncertainties, even for a subtraction. They never cancel.

In the formula booklet
y=abc  ⇒  Δyy=Δaa+Δbb+Δccy = \frac{ab}{c} \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{\Delta y}{y} = \frac{\Delta a}{a} + \frac{\Delta b}{b} + \frac{\Delta c}{c}

2. Multiplying or dividing: add the fractional (or percentage) uncertainties, then multiply by yy for the absolute uncertainty.

In the formula booklet
y=an  ⇒  Δyy=∣n Δaa∣y = a^{n} \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{\Delta y}{y} = \left\lvert n\,\frac{\Delta a}{a} \right\rvert

3. Raising to a power: multiply the fractional uncertainty by the size of the power. A square root, power 12\tfrac12, halves it.

Exact numbers, such as the 12\tfrac12 in 12mv2\tfrac12 mv^{2} or the 22 and π\pi in 2πr2\pi r, have no uncertainty.

Worked exampleThe potential difference across a resistor is 4.5±0.1 V4.5 \pm \pu{0.1 V} and the current is 0.30±0.01 A0.30 \pm \pu{0.01 A}. Determine its resistance, R=VIR = \frac{V}{I}, with its absolute uncertainty.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Value: R=4.50.30=15 ΩR = \frac{4.5}{0.30} = 15\ \Omega.
Worked exampleA trolley of mass 0.600±0.006 kg0.600 \pm \pu{0.006 kg} moves at 2.5±0.1 m s−12.5 \pm \pu{0.1 m s-1}. Determine its kinetic energy, Ek=12mv2E_\text{k} = \tfrac12 mv^{2}, with its absolute uncertainty.

Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.

  1. Value: Ek=12×0.600×2.52=1.875 JE_\text{k} = \tfrac12 \times 0.600 \times 2.5^{2} = \pu{1.875 J}.
Check yourself
A spring is 12.7±0.1 cm12.7 \pm \pu{0.1 cm} long unloaded and 18.4±0.1 cm18.4 \pm \pu{0.1 cm} long with a load. What is its extension?
Check yourself
Radiated power is proportional to T4T^{4}, with TT in kelvin. If TT has a percentage uncertainty of 1.5%1.5\%, what is the percentage uncertainty in the power?

Common mistakes

  • Writing 'human error' or 'to reduce error'. Name the error as random or systematic, give its cause, and say what your change does to it.
  • Quoting too many digits, such as 15±0.833 Ω15 \pm 0.833\ \Omega. Round the uncertainty to one significant figure, then match the value: 15.0±0.8 Ω15.0 \pm 0.8\ \Omega.
  • Subtracting uncertainties when values are subtracted. In a sum or difference, absolute uncertainties always add.
  • Forgetting the power. In v2v^{2} the fractional uncertainty in vv counts twice; an exact 12\tfrac12 or π\pi adds nothing.
  • Dividing by your own result in a percentage error. Divide by the accepted value.
  • Calling a result correct because its percentage error is small. It agrees only if the accepted value lies inside its range.

Exam tips

  • 'Determine the absolute uncertainty' needs working: the fractional uncertainties, their sum, then multiplying by the value.
  • To 'state' a result to the appropriate precision, give the uncertainty to one significant figure, match the value's decimal places, and add the unit.
  • To 'comment on' agreement with an accepted value, give the range, say whether the accepted value is inside it, and if not name a likely systematic error. Paper 1B data-based questions test this.

Key takeaways

Learn thisRandom error: scatter, lowers precision, reduced by averaging repeats. Systematic error: same shift each time, lowers accuracy, not reduced by repeats.
Learn this×\times and ÷\div: fewest significant figures. ++ and −-: fewest decimal places.
Learn thisAnalogue: half the smallest division. Digital: one unit in the last digit. Repeats: half the range. Uncertainty to 1 s.f., value to the same decimal place.
Learn thispercentage uncertainty=Δxx×100%\text{percentage uncertainty} = \frac{\Delta x}{x} \times 100\%
Learn thispercentage error=∣experimental value−accepted value∣∣accepted value∣×100%\text{percentage error} = \frac{\lvert \text{experimental value} - \text{accepted value} \rvert}{\lvert \text{accepted value} \rvert} \times 100\%
Learn thisPercentage change =new−originaloriginal×100%= \frac{\text{new} - \text{original}}{\text{original}} \times 100\%. Percentage difference =∣a−b∣mean×100%= \frac{\lvert a - b \rvert}{\text{mean}} \times 100\%.
Learn thisSums and differences: add absolute uncertainties. Products and quotients: add fractional ones. Power nn: multiply the fractional uncertainty by ∣n∣\lvert n \rvert.
Learn thisAccepted value outside the range (value ± absolute uncertainty): a systematic error is likely. Comparing percentage error with percentage uncertainty only agrees with this when the gap is clear.

Practise this

37 past-paper questions on Uncertainty, error and significant figures in the Physics HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.

Practise Uncertainty, error and significant figures →