Elementary deductive proof
In a minute
A shows that a statement is true in every case, through steps that each follow from the last. Trying a few numbers is never enough. You'll write proofs that run from one side to the other, use for an , and check your own working.
You'll be able to
- Tell an equation from an , and use and correctly.
- Lay out a proof that starts from one side and works step by step to the other, in either direction.
- Prove simple results about numbers, first with a numerical case and then in general with algebra.
- Check a result, and your own working, by substituting values.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Equals or identically equal
Look at . It is true when and false for every other . It is an equation: a statement you solve to find the values that make it true.
Now look at . Try , or : the two sides always match. It is true for every value of , so there is nothing to solve.
Use for an equation you solve. Use when you state or prove that two expressions are the same for every value.
Between lines of working, is fine. The matters most in the statement you prove.
LHS means the left-hand side of the sign, and RHS the right-hand side.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Start from the LHS, the side with brackets. Multiply each term in the first bracket by each term in the second: .
- Work out each product: .
- Collect the terms: . So .
- Quick check with : and .
An identity holds for every , so the two sides must have the same term, the same term and the same constant. You can use this to find unknown constants.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Expand the LHS: .
- The two sides agree for every , so their constant terms are equal: , so .
- Their terms are equal too: .
- Check by expanding with these values: . It matches the RHS.
Laying out an LHS to RHS proof
In a 'show that' question the result is given. The safe layout is a chain: start from one side, change it one known step at a time, and finish on exactly the other side.
You may start from either side. Start from the more complicated one, because simplifying is easier than guessing how to make something longer.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- The LHS is the complicated side, so start there. Expand each product: and .
- Subtract the whole second product, kept in a bracket: .
- Remove the bracket. The minus sign in front changes every sign inside: .
- Collect like terms. The terms cancel and so do the constants, leaving .
- Check with : and .
Sometimes the right-hand side is the longer one. Then you start from the RHS and work back to the LHS.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- The RHS has two fractions, so it is the side to simplify. Start from the RHS.
- Use the common denominator : .
- Simplify the numerator, keeping the bracket after the minus: .
- Expand the denominator: . So .
- Check with : and .
Proving results about numbers
, and : two odd numbers make an even number. But a hundred examples still don't show it for the next pair.
A proof has to cover every case at once. That is what algebra is for.
To cover every case, write the numbers with letters. Let stand for any integer, written .
Two consecutive integers are and . Two unrelated numbers need two letters: any two odd numbers are and , where .
Then aim for the form the result needs: for even, for odd. Always say why the bracket is an integer.
Now prove the opening claim. Two odd numbers add to . is an integer, so the sum is even, for every pair.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- (a) Work out each side as a number. and . They match.
- (b) and sit either side of . Call the middle number , so the numbers either side are and .
- Start from the LHS and expand: .
- The terms cancel, so . No value of was assumed, so this holds for every .
- (c) Use the identity with : .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Let the odd numbers be and , where .
- Multiply them out, every term by every term: .
- Take a factor of out of the first three terms: .
- and are integers, so is an integer too.
- So the product is , which is odd.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- By place value the number is , just as .
- Reversing the digits gives .
- Add them and collect like terms: .
- Factorise: .
- and are whole numbers, so is an integer. So the sum is times an integer, which is a multiple of .
- Check with : , and . It fits.
Checking a result
One slipped sign breaks a proof. To check an , substitute an easy value into the expression you started with and into your result. If the two values differ, there is a mistake somewhere, so find it.
Choose values like or . Avoid and when you can: at every term vanishes, and at the terms and look the same. Errors can hide there.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Substitute into the left side: .
- Substitute into the right side: . The sides differ, so the expansion is wrong.
- Expand properly, keeping the middle term: .
- Check again at : . It now matches the left side.
For an equation, check by putting your answer back into the original equation. If both sides come out the same, the answer is right.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Expand the bracket: .
- Subtract from both sides and add to both sides: .
- Divide by : .
- Check in the original equation. and . They match, so is right.
Common mistakes
- Dropping the middle term when squaring: is , not . Write the bracket out twice.
- Checking a few numbers and calling it a proof. Examples only cover the cases you tried, so prove the general case with letters.
- Losing signs when you subtract a bracket. In every sign inside changes.
- Stopping at an expression without saying what it shows. Write as , then say that is an integer, so the result is a multiple of .
- Starting from the given result, or working on both sides at once. Begin from one side and finish on the other.
Exam tips
- Show that: the result is given, so show every step, and make your last line match it exactly. End with '' or 'as required'.
- Prove: give a general argument with letters, and finish with a sentence stating what you proved.
- Mark schemes give R marks for reasoning, such as saying why is an integer. Write that reason in words.
Key takeaways
Practise this
5 past-paper questions on 1.6 in the AA HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.