Relationships between lines
In a minute
Two lines in 3D can be the same line, be , cross at one point, or be : not parallel, yet never meeting. Two tests tell them apart. Compare the , then look for a common point. When the lines meet, the same working gives the point of intersection.
You'll be able to
- Tell whether two lines are coincident, parallel, intersecting or skew, starting from their direction vectors.
- Show that two lines are skew, giving both parts of the reason.
- Find the point where two lines meet, and check it in every component equation.
- Find an unknown constant that makes two lines meet.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 3.14 Vector equations of lines
Four ways two lines can sit
Draw two lines on a sheet of paper. They cross at one point, run side by side without meeting, or lie on top of each other. In 3D there is a fourth option.
Picture a road on a bridge and a railway underneath it, heading off in another direction. They are not , but they never meet. Lines like these are called .
So any two lines and fall into exactly one of four cases.
1. : they are the same line, so every point is shared.
2. Parallel: the same direction, but no point in common.
3. : different directions and exactly one point in common.
4. Skew: different directions and no point in common.
In 2D, two lines that are not parallel always meet. In 3D that is no longer true, so different directions alone don't tell you the lines cross.
The first test uses only the and . It splits the four cases into two pairs.
To test, divide matching components. If every one gives the same , the directions match.
Same direction still leaves two cases. Take any point on and test whether it lies on . If it does, the lines share a point and a direction, so they are coincident. If not, they are parallel.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Compare the directions: . Every component gives , so the lines have the same direction.
- Test whether the point of lies on . Set .
- From : , so . From : , so .
- The components need different values of , so is not on . The lines share a direction but no point.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Check the directions first: . So the lines are parallel or coincident.
- Coincident means the point lies on . Use the components without to find .
- From : , so . Check in : , which matches.
- The -component must agree for the same : .
- For any other value of , the point is off , and the lines are parallel instead.
Finding the point of intersection
Suppose and meet at a point P. P is on , so some value of gives it. P is also on , so some value of gives it.
The two values are usually different. Each line has its own parameter, so give them different letters. Using for both would force the lines to reach P at the same value, which is almost never true.
Setting the two general points equal gives one equation per component. In 3D that is three equations in just two unknowns, and .
1. Write both lines with different parameters, such as and .
2. Set the -, - and -components equal. You get three equations.
3. Solve two of them for and . Pick the pair that looks easiest.
4. Substitute both values into the third equation. If it holds, the lines meet. If it fails, they don't.
5. Put into , or into , to get the point. Doing both is a quick check.
Step 4 matters. Two equations in two unknowns nearly always have a solution, so they can't tell you on their own whether the lines meet.
In 2D there are only two equations, so step 4 has nothing to test.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Set the general points equal: .
- From the -components: .
- Substitute into the -components: , so .
- Then , so and .
- Put into : . Check with in : .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Equate the components: , and .
- The -equation gives . Substitute into the -equation: .
- So , which gives and then .
- Check in the -equation, the one not used yet: and . Both sides agree, so the lines intersect.
- Put into : . Check with in : .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Equate the components: , and .
- The -equation contains , so solve the other two first. Substitute into the -equation: .
- That gives , so and .
- The lines meet only if the -equation holds too: , so .
- The point is at : . Check with in : .
Showing that lines are skew
fail both tests: the directions are not multiples, and the third equation fails.
Look at a closed box. Take the front edge of the lid and the left edge of the floor, which runs from front to back. They point different ways and never touch, so they are skew.
So a proof that two lines are skew has two parts. Leave either out and the proof has a gap: lines with no common point could still be parallel.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Not parallel: if , the -components give but the -components give . So the directions are not multiples of each other.
- Equate the components: , and .
- From the -equation, . Substitute into the -equation: , so and .
- Test the -equation. The left side is , but the right side is . Since , there is no common point.
- Different directions and no shared point: that combination is exactly what skew means.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Give its own parameter. Setting each part equal to gives , and .
- Not parallel: the directions are and . The second has a zero -component and the first doesn't, so neither is a multiple of the other.
- Equate the components: , and .
- The -equation gives at once. Then the -equation gives .
- Test the -equation: , but . Since , there is no common point.
- Not parallel and no common point, so the lines are skew.
Deciding which case you have
To decide how two lines are related, run the two tests in order.
1. Compare the . Is one a multiple of the other?
2. If yes, test one point of on . On the line means . Off the line means .
3. If no, solve two component equations for and , then test the third. If it holds, the lines , and you can find the point. If it fails, they are .
If one line holds an unknown, solve the two equations without it first. Then use the last equation to find it.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Equate the components: , and .
- The -equation contains , so use and . From : . Substitute into : .
- So , which gives and .
- The lines meet only if the -equation holds too: , so and . They then meet at with , which is .
- The directions and are not multiples: the -components double, but the -components halve. So for the lines are not parallel and don't meet. They are skew.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Directions first. The -components have ratio but the -components have ratio . So the lines are not parallel.
- Equate the - and -components and tidy them into the form the solver needs: and . Write these down: they earn the method mark.
- Solve them with the simultaneous equation solver: and . Some models show them as fractions, and . Keep the full values.
- Test the -equation with those values. gives , and gives .
- The two values differ, so there is no common point. The lines are not parallel either, so they are skew.
Common mistakes
- Using the same parameter for both lines. The lines usually reach their common point at different parameter values, so write for one line and for the other.
- Calling lines skew after showing only that they don't meet. Parallel lines don't meet either, so also show that the directions are not multiples.
- Putting into , or into . Each value belongs to its own line. Check the point by putting the other value into the other line.
- Calling lines coincident because their directions match. One point of must also lie on ; if it doesn't, the lines are parallel.
- Sign slips when expanding, such as writing as . The wrong or then makes the third equation seem to fail.
Exam tips
- "Show that the lines are skew" needs two reasons: the directions are not multiples, and the third equation fails. Write the failing equation with its numbers.
- "Find the point of intersection" wants coordinates. Show the test of the third equation, since it is part of the method.
- On Paper 2, write down the two equations you enter in the solver, then the values of and . Carry the full values into the third equation.
Key takeaways
Practise this
8 past-paper questions on 3.15 in the AA HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.