Second derivative and concavity
In a minute
The , , is the derivative of the derivative. It tells you how the gradient is changing, and so which way the graph bends. Where the graph is , and where it is .
You'll be able to
- Differentiate twice to find the , written or , and find its value at a point.
- Use the sign of to say where a graph is or .
- Link the graphs of , and , and read features of one from another.
- Use your GDC to find where a graph is concave-up or concave-down when can't be solved by hand.
Before you start3 quick questions on what this builds on
Revise first: 5.2 Increasing and decreasing functions and 5.6 Differentiation rules and standard functions
Differentiating twice
When you differentiate , you get , the gradient function. It is a function of too, so you can differentiate it again.
The result is the . It measures how fast the gradient changes as increases.
Read as "f double prime of x". is said "d two y by d x squared", but nothing is squared: the 2s mean "differentiated twice".
Questions use both. Use when the function has a name, and when the curve is given as
You need no new rules. You use the rules from 5.6 twice: the power rule, the chain rule, and the product and quotient rules.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Differentiate each term once with the power rule: . The term gives , and the constant gives .
- Now differentiate term by term. gives , and gives .
- The constant in gives .
- So . Check the degree: each derivative lowers the highest power by one, so a quartic gives a quadratic .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- is a product, so use the product rule. Let and . Then and, by the chain rule, .
- First derivative: .
- This is a product again. Now let and , so and .
- Second derivative: .
- Simplify: . This is the given result, reached by working forwards.
Concavity: which way the graph bends
is the rate of change of the gradient. If , the gradient increases as you move right. If , the gradient decreases.
Picture . Its gradient is , which goes , , , as goes , , , . The gradient keeps increasing, and the curve bends upwards like a cup. Here .
Now picture . Its gradient, , keeps decreasing, and the curve bends downwards like an upside-down cup. Here .
A curve that bends upwards is . A curve that bends downwards is .
Another way to see it: a concave-up curve lies above its tangents, and a concave-down curve lies below them.
Concavity is separate from increasing and decreasing. The sign of gives the direction, up or down. The sign of gives the bend. So there are four combinations.
Where a graph switches from one concavity to the other, it has a . You will find and test these in 5.8.
To find where a graph is concave-up or concave-down:
1. Find .
2. Solve to find where its sign can change.
3. Find the sign of on each side. Answer with inequalities in .
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Differentiate once: .
- Differentiate again: .
- Substitute : .
- , so the gradient is decreasing at . The graph bends downwards there.
- Concave-down, because
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Differentiate twice: , so .
- Concave-down means , so solve .
- Find where the sign can change: , so or .
- is a parabola that opens upwards, so it is negative between its roots. Test a value: .
The graphs of f, f′ and f″
You can now link three graphs. Each one is the gradient graph of the one before it.
The sign of tells you where goes up or down. The sign of tells you where goes up or down. That is the same as how bends.
Follow the dashed lines. At and , has a maximum and a minimum. There crosses the -axis, because the gradient of is .
At , has its lowest point, so . changes from negative to positive there. On , the bend switches from to , and is falling most steeply.
For a polynomial, each derivative is one degree lower. A cubic has a quadratic and a linear . This helps you match graphs.
Explore it. Slide the point along from to , and watch the value of . It falls until , then rises. So the gradient decreases while the curve bends down, and increases while it bends up.
f(x) = x³ − 3x, so f′(x) = 3x² − 3
f′(−2.0) =
On your GDC you can do the same: graph , then find the derivative at several points and watch it rise or fall.
Sometimes you get only the graph of . Its sign shows where increases or decreases. Whether it rises or falls shows how bends.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Concave-up means . is the gradient of , so look for where the graph of is rising.
- The parabola falls until its lowest point at , then rises.
- So for and for .
- The crossings at and don't matter here. They are the stationary points of , which come from the sign of , not of .
On Paper 2, may have no algebraic solution. Find by hand, then graph on your GDC and find where it crosses the -axis.
Try it first, then reveal one step at a time.
- Differentiate twice by hand: , so .
- Concave-down means . Write down the equation you solve on the GDC: .
- Graph and find its zeros: and
- Test a point between them: . So between the zeros, and outside them.
- Round only at the end: the end points are and to 3 s.f.
Common mistakes
- Solving when the question asks where the graph is concave-up. Concavity comes from the sign of , so differentiate twice first.
- Stopping after one derivative. If the question asks for or , differentiate your first derivative again.
- Losing a sign with negative powers. differentiates to , and then to .
- Giving only the value where . That is where the concavity can change. The answer is a set of -values, such as .
- Reading the graph of as if it were . For the concavity of , ask whether the graph of is rising or falling, not whether it is above the axis.
Exam tips
- When a question asks where a graph is concave-up, write as your first line, then solve. Answer with inequalities in .
- "Show that ": show the first derivative and every line of the second. Your last line must match the given result exactly.
- On Paper 2, find by hand, then write down the equation you put into the GDC. Give the end points to 3 s.f.
- Use the notation the question uses. If it writes , answer with .
Key takeaways
Practise this
2 past-paper questions on 5.7 in the AA HL bank, each with a mark scheme and a worked explanation.